
(3/3) I suggest that for their next stunt, OpenAI should throw a $1,000,000 in tokens into the prompt “Search for a contradiction in math”; if nothing else, this would be a good way to debug Lean or increase our confidence that it is bug-free.

I'm a professor at UMass Lowell. I write a monthly blog called Mathematical Enchantments (mathenchant.org). Sometimes I’m facetious w/o using smileys.

(3/3) I suggest that for their next stunt, OpenAI should throw a $1,000,000 in tokens into the prompt “Search for a contradiction in math”; if nothing else, this would be a good way to debug Lean or increase our confidence that it is bug-free.

(2/3) If there were an inconsistency, exploring the tree of implications the way OpenAI did would be a good way to find it!

(1/3) The Big Compute of 2026 by OpenAI (and others) offers a kind of empirical evidence in favor of the consistency of mathematics (or rather, whatever axiom system is embedded in Lean).

Georg Cantor set out to solve an arcane problem about trigonometric series and ended up revolutionizing mathematics. Along the way he gave the world new ways to think about infinity. See "On Beyond Omega!" at Mathematical Enchantments: mathenchant.wordpress.com/20…

(3/3) There is another theory which states that this has already happened.”

(2/3) of Universal Bizarreness and Inexplicability: “There is a theory which states that if ever anyone discovers exactly what the Universe is for and why it is here, it will instantly disappear and be replaced by something even more bizarre and inexplicable.

(1/3) I just realized that the reason our universe is three-dimensional rather than two-dimensional is that two-dimensional stat mech models are exactly solvable while three-dimensional ones are not. The connecting link is Douglas Adams’s Second Theory of

Here's a more symmetric and satisfying one.

Here's another dynamic Hamiltonian circuit. This one visits 16 moving points on 8 circles; the points form diameters of the 8 incircles of the faces of an octahedron. The circles alternate rotation direction around each vertex. The circuit has constant length!

I was mistaken. "Nested Loops" does indeed have the property that the length doesn't change. (Though perhaps I'm still mistaken; I'm modeling it as a single loop, but the title of the piece suggests that there are several.)

Here's another constant-length dynamic Hamiltonian path using six circles.

My latest Mathematical Enchantment, "Solving the Flat Cube", describes a new puzzle devised by Oskar van Deventer, Dmitry Andreev, and me, and shows how sometimes you can solve a math problem by adding a dimension OR by throwing a dimension away. mathenchant.wordpress.com/20…

"Nested Loops" is on display at the National Museum of Mathematics in New York City. The exhibit in an easily-overlooked spot, so if you have trouble finding it, ask a docent.

The inspiration for this came from Chuck Hoberman's "Nested Loops" exhibit. I used ChatGPT to search the space of possible solutions in which total length doesn't change (I'm pretty sure that "Nested Loops" lacks this property). youtube.com/watch?v=e4sARevL…

A loop joins eight moving points on four circles in such a way that the length of the loop remains constant.

David Kelly is no longer with us (see mathenchant.wordpress.com/20…) but Yellow Pig Seventeen lives on!