There may be a technical path to zero/negative emissions on this path. But I do not see a political one, as it will only get harder to build new clean energy capacity as people get more and more polarized in response to this abundance-themed buildout.
Yes and also the central concern with BAAJA imo is that it keeps the US on its current transition pathway: growing clean energy capacity *and* growing emissions.
All while stoking continued backlash to reindustrialization in rural and suburban communities that swing elections.
Building lots of clean is ofc extremely important, but within that the climate left tends to dispute market a) appetite for clean and b) ability to rapidly outcompete fossil without active state intervention beyond cutting red tape, including market (re)design
Centrist US climate politics seems to revolve mostly around a belief that the only meaningful thing to do is allow markets to build lots of clean energy in the US. That allows for A) narrow advocacy around cutting red tape & B) ignoring that a crisis is actively unfolding here
I'm baffled about the centrist position on climate change at this point. Is the idea that it isn't happening anymore? Or that we don't need to take drastic measures to prevent it, even if they are unpopular?
Anyway, I think it's telling that the tech and fossil fuel industries, along with the chamber of commerce, are fronting this bill. Tagging that to the Dems is great politics for Rs, who then get to run in 2028 on a version of the platform that swung the 2026 midterms in our favor
The Rhodium modeling, which was also wildly optimistic about the IRA and IIJA, doesn't account for this kind of political fragility (and can't be expected to). But I worry this creates the condition for dramatic backlash to Dems for passing BAAJA and a 2028 wipeout. What then?
And if passing it contributes to a lost opportunity for a Dem trifecta in 2028, well, I guess the idea that expediting all projects and relying on the President to exercise discretion re: clean energy projects, that seems like a fraught path to forge.
Expecting people to be excited about BAAJA because it will reduce their electricity bills relative to inflation by a couple of dollars in the mid-2030s is almost too farcical to believe. But that's the core political argument I keep seeing around its passage.
It will pass or not regardless of this concern, but I don't see any of the bill's proponents talking about how it gets sold to voters in realtime and the near future. This is the same mistake made during the IRA negotiations--a technocratic policy w/a tiny constituency.
Among many other concerns with the bill, one concern is how this shapes the 2028 cycle.
Fair or not, Dems who vote for BAAJA will be held responsible by voters for the ongoing/coming data center buildout, an issue which swung the midterms historically left in 2026.
The way BAAJA haters talk about this bill’s treatment of data centers — basically it makes more electricity and data centers use electricity — is like saying IIJA was is a data center bill because when people build data centers they use roads to transport construction material.
In my mind, this idea is directly linked to the Jentleson comment about Dems throwing down for legalizing various forms of child abuse (e.g. spanking).
Their solution to the lack of support for parents and children is to make it easier to open scam/dangerous child care centers.
"Abundance" org unveils policies it wants 2028 presidential hopefuls to support:
— Reduced regs for day care centers
— Allow PAs to serve as primary providers
— Incentives to reduce housing environmental reviews
W/ @mara_hopwashingtonsun.com/campaigns/…
Many debates about this bill aside—have seen good arguments on either side—I'm a bit mystified by the framing of it as a critical test of Dems' willingness to deliver affordability to voters, esp. relative to 2028. Rhodium modeling shows it'd lower bills by ~$4-7 a month in 2040
can you imagine herding three children under 8 years old through a crowded subway or on the bus when you need to go somewhere? just the logistical challenge, forget about how neurotic about safety that makes people
"abusing children" as Adam Jentleson's new thing post divorce after "anti-trans policies for the win" after his partner transitioned... man just go to therapy
Adam Jentleson on the Ezra Klein pod this morning listing ways dems can signal values that will appeal in a surprising way and he included: “being open to spanking.”
.@AJentleson: “i think this is yet another teachable moment for lefties on twitter to engage in some introspection and realize that they are not the average voter! they may think spanking is wrong, but three-quarters of americans don’t” including half of Dems. [he cites below]
Nope. The correct take is that Chinese green industrial policy, and energy policy more generally, saved the world from an energy crisis, while helping most places go greener. The lesson is that planning and green investment work.
I think environmentalists should try to take seriously the fact that Donald Trump has implemented the most aggressive "supply-side" climate policy in a generation and everyone agrees it's economically destructive and politically unsustainable.
nytimes.com/2026/11/09/clima…