For someone who started a war with Iran with destructive international consequences, who calls the Iranians scum and a cancer and wants to bomb them back to the Stone Age, supported Israel in its destruction of Gaza, still participates in a proxy war on Russia, kidnapped the serving head of state of a sovereign country and grabbed its oil, wants Greenland, the territory of an ally etc, to claim he is the most eligible candidate ever for receiving the Nobel Peace Prize is a parody.
He implicitly endorses Pakistan’s threat to use nuclear weapons against India by repeating Shehbaz Sharif’s claim Trump saved 30 to 50 million lives in Pakistan’s conflict with India.
This means Pakistan was ready to use nuclear weapons, had worked out targets in India and estimated the casualties.
Sharif has now officially in a message to Trump on the 250th anniversary of the US applauded him for saving hundreds of millions of lives. The figure has ballooned.
India has a No First Use doctrine which Pakistan rejects despite India proposing an agreement on this. India would not have used nuclear weapons first.
Instead of deploring Pakistan’s nuclear threat inherent in Sharif’s statements, Trump is legitimising it politically.
No concern about millions of Indian lives lost because of Pakistan’s nuclear madness.
Instead, Trump capitalises on Sharif’s pandering to his vanity to lay claim to the Nobel Peace Prize.
U.S. President Trump on India and Pakistan:
I should have won the Nobel Peace Prize more than anyone who has ever won the award. The India-Pakistan war was raging. 11 planes were shot down. The Pakistan PM said President Trump saved 30 to 50 million lives.
Happy Birthday, dear Ambassador Kanwal! I always enjoy our conversations on X and in person. I wish you many more years of health, productivity and blessings!
Happy Birthday, dear Ambassador Kanwal! I always enjoy our conversations on X and in person. I wish you many more years of health, productivity and blessings!
Xi was reciprocating Trump’s gesture. If he hadn’t it would have been construed as a diplomatic snub and spoiled the atmosphere.
It would have made Trump look small.
Xi and Putin meet very often.
Donald Trump arrived in Shenzhen for the APEC summit and was personally greeted by Chinese President Xi Jinping.
But when Putin arrived, Xi apparently had more important things to attend to. The Russian leader was instead welcomed by Cai Qi, head of the General Office of the Communist Party of China’s Central Committee.
China’s main geopolitical rival received the highest-level reception, unlike its closest ally.
Not convincing.
On what issues will they cooperate with success?
A sustained three way dialogue is needed at diplomatic to pursue whatever is broadly outlined.
Will they be able to create a mechanism for this?
What international initiatives of Trump based on cooperation, not unilateral actions, have succeeded?
After mid-terms he has lost more credibility.
Both China and Russia will humour him.
The three countries have no really shared agenda.
Jeremy Bowen is a British national. His company does data analytics etc.
While there is no evidence of his company’s links with intelligence agencies, the idea could well be to generate a controversy in India with the opposition already on the war path by endorsing the US narrative about our air losses during Op Sindoor.
This seeming mischief needs to be scotched .
RAFALE COUNT AT 32?
A report by Cirium Aviation Analytics and Flight International says the Indian Air Force has 32 Rafale aircraft in its fleet.
Questions are being raised over the report, as it does not explain the basis for counting only 32 aircraft instead of 36.
The report states: “The information contained in this report was prepared using Cirium fleets data. While reasonable care has been taken to ensure accuracy, the information is supplied on the understanding that no legal liability whatsoever shall attach to FlightGlobal, its officers or employees in respect of any error or omission that may have occurred.”
I had a fascinating conversation with Rahul Gandhi at Columbia University this afternoon. We talked about youth movements, the fragility of democracy and what India needs now.
How does India replicate the Chinese governance system in a democratic, decentralised, hugely diverse India?
Ban all foreign social media? Create a firewall? No political parties? No dissent?
Please advise.
INDIA SHOULD TAKE A CLOSER LOOK AT CHINA
I think there are important lessons India could learn from China's development over the past four decades.
Deng Xiaoping understood something that many leaders still fail to grasp: opening your economy to the world does not mean handing over control of your country's future.
China attracted foreign investment, learned from foreign technology and built its own industrial base. Shenzhen is probably the best example of what this approach can achieve.
India has enormous potential, but it needs to turn that potential into manufacturing strength, technological capabilities and greater economic independence.
I am not suggesting India should copy China.
But I think it would be a mistake not to study what China got right.
Most important is always about SOVEREIGNTY
India to define its own DESTINY
MY NEW ARTICLE:
WHAT INDIA COULD LEARN FROM CHINA
angelogiuliano.substack.com/…
You need to do some honest introspection.
Problems in ties are not one sided.
India may have made mistakes but Nepal too.
Name a few instances where Nepal has shown good neighbourliness.
Always played the China card against India.
Refused water resources cooperation with India. arguing Nepal did not want to be “ Bhutanised”.
Oli’s agenda was to dilute even the deep religious and cultural ties with India.
एयर रुटको विषयमा नेपालप्रति भारतको रवैया निकृष्ट तहको बेइमानी हो। अहिले भारत आफैँलाई नेपालको आकाश चाहिएपछि फेरि यो एजेन्डा उठेछ।
भौगोलिक, सामाजिक, सांस्कृतिक, राजनीतिक लगायतका सबै पक्षलाई हेर्दा नेपाल–भारत सम्बन्ध आदर्श छिमेकी सम्बन्धको उदाहरण हुनुपर्ने हो। तर भारतीय पक्षको सानो चित्त, बेलाबेलाका बेकामी ‘टिडिक’ र नेपाली राजनीतिको कमजोरीले गर्दा यसो हुन सकेको छैन।
अब चाहिँ नेपाल–भारत सम्बन्ध जगैदेखि सुध्रियोस्!
Islamised Turkey continues to play political mischief against India.
No other set of countries have forged an international platform based on religion.
Exclusive. Rejects inclusivity.
This is in itself constitutes intolerance towards those who are not Muslims.
This is Islamic power play by activists like Turkey .
Turkey is ruthless towards its own Muslims and those in neighbouring countries- the Kurds.
Time India publicly called out Turkey’s illegal occupation of Northern Cyprus and persecution of its Kurdish minority. x.com/itskhurramabbas/status…
Most inappropriate to bad mouth the elected government on foreign soil.
It ends up by damaging the country’s image and is not confined to the image of the ruling leadership.
Why not focus on the global issues of the day and how India should navigate them?
Rahul Gandhi is sitting at Columbia University and telling a foreign audience that India needs to “restore the electoral system,” that he has “a lot of proof on electoral malpractice,” and that people in the system are “very scared” and speaking to him.
He then warns that if pressure increases, the government will “react nastily” and “violently and aggressively.” The Leader of Opposition is once again painting India as a failing democracy on foreign soil while offering zero proof.
Ahead of the Trump–Xi–Putin trilateral at APEC Shenzhen: this will be the clearest test yet of my concept of "Triangle of Happiness", the functional triumvirate of realpolitik between the three nuclear powers with the deepest fingerprints on the two proxy wars, Ukraine and Iran.
First takeaway: We are not in WW3 and this is not Yalta 2.0: no carve-up into strategic spheres of interest (Western Hemisphere for the US, Europe for Russia, the South and East China Seas for China). We are at the very beginning of this new strategic competition, not its end. And we know that the US wants to emerge victorious, so do China and Russia.
Second takeaway: This is not 19th concert of global powers either. Middle powers bridge the two systems (security with the US, economy with China), hedge against all (India) or balance as hubs through geography, tech leverage or raw materials as they do not accept the bifurcation of the global system and do not want to get caught in a new binary world.
Third takeaway: It is a new Cold War of global grayzone warfare. The US wants to win the AI-steered 4IR and establish a Pax Americana 2.0. China and Russia want to prevent it and build an order on their own terms, structures and formats. Most of the competition takes place below the treshhold of a conventional and nuclear exchange between the US and the DragonBear as the modus operandi of strategic coordination between China and Russia.
Fourth takeaway: Iran is the most acute file as it has triggered a fourth systemic risk-driven global crisis through the destruction of the critical infrastructure in the Gulf and the closure of Hormuz. China and Russia sustain Tehran, so any durable deal runs through them. Two proxy wars plus the greatest chokepoint disruption - this might result in this fourth systemic risk after 2007, 2020 and 2022, what I define as a Global System Rupture, a possible fourth systemic global crisis. The Iran war can flare again within weeks.
Fifth takeaway: Russia’s logic is unchanged. In December 2021 I outlined the three dimensions of Russia’s comprehensive war: subjugating Ukraine, destroying the European security order, and taking pole position as the wild card in the US–China rivalry. Putin went to war precisely to put Russia on the same level as Washington and Beijing. A three-way photo in Shenzhen is part of that payoff, even though Ukraine is officially off the trilateral agenda.
Sixth takeaway: Each side comes to Shenzhen for something different:
- Russia drives the format. It wants global status and the image of strategic parity with Washington and Beijing.
- China hosts and gains prestige. It sets the terms, avoids owning any failure, and still rejects three-way nuclear limits.
- The US wants an opening on arms control now that New START has expired, and it wants help on Iran. Trump arrives weakened by the midterms and in a hurry to make deals before the new Congress sits in January
- Unexpected wild card could be Korea talks and setting the stage for a political settlement of the armistice between North and South Korea within the Triangle of Happiness.
Seventh takeaway: The triumvirate’s task is minimal: agree on transparent rules of engagement that prevent kinetic or nuclear war (CSBMs, direct channels of communication, etc.), keep the global system afloat, and manage the cascading risks. Other files can’t be ignored either: the AI revolution (openly a front of the new Cold War since the Nvidia affair), nuclear proliferation, and keeping humans in control of nuclear weapons.
Bottomline: Managed confrontation for the sake of the strategic stability amid MAD 2.0, not any grand bargain, separation of spheres of influcence or Yalta 2.0. Stay tuned.