
The official preprint of "Metaphysical Symmetry and the Modal Ontological Argument" is now available (open access!) from Religious Studies: doi.org/10.1017/S00344125261…

I read old books and am confused about God. Philosophy Prof, @JMU_Phil_Rel (formerly @TCDPhilosophy). Latest book: Is There a God?, bit.ly/2QrnJxl

The official preprint of "Metaphysical Symmetry and the Modal Ontological Argument" is now available (open access!) from Religious Studies: doi.org/10.1017/S00344125261…

Learnt a new term today :- “metaphysical oomph”, thanks to Dr. Pearce (@KennethLPearce) Will be using it in the future to avoid difficult situations :-)

To my mind the argument instead makes vivid the extent to which we unavoidably participate in, and give a kind of consent to, various forms of injustice just by participating in the economy. 5/5

Locke apparently thinks this shows that there’s nothing morally problematic about economic inequality—if poor people want more money, then, just by wanting money, they have consented to the system of inequality. 4/5

If we didn’t value money, then wealth would be limited by various constraints—you can’t effectively hoard enough apples or wool or beef without spoilage to make you a billionaire. 3/

You can’t eat money, it won’t keep you warm in winter (well, I guess you could burn dollar bills, maybe), etc., but we’re willing to exchange our goods and labor for it. 2/

At the end of the discussion of property in the 2nd Treatise, Locke makes an interesting argument that we have all consented to significant wealth inequality by valuing money. 🧵

I've been contemplating whether to come out with this very hot take for days. I'll let Phil push me over the edge. Here it is: 'Fear and Trembling' is not a great book, and Kierkegaard is not a great philosopher.
What's everyone's most controversial book take?

If nothing really matters then the fact that nothing matters doesn’t matter

In fact, this is another case that supports my claim: in Thoughts on Education, Locke argues that people are much too quick to use corporal punishment (violence) against children because they wrongly believe that it's not possible to reason with young children.

In Locke's view, if religion is not based on reason then religious conflict must lead to violence. Locke also argues that people who do injustice 'renounce reason' & thereby choose violence. This is why violence against them is justified.

An underappreciated theme in Locke is that there are only two ways of dealing with conflict: reason and violence. This is why Locke sees religious ‘enthusiasm’ as a threat. It also underlies his theory of just war and punishment.

Proof is a very high standard. Most of our beliefs are held on the basis of reasons or evidence that fall short of proof.
If nobody has ever proven God exists, what logical reason do I have for believing God is real?

The moral of the story is, it's totally worth taking time away from talking about course requirements and career prospects to do some more philosophy!

At a recruitment event today, one of the prospective students asked my views on free will. Students and parents stayed 15 minutes passed the scheduled length of the info session talking philosophy. A student excitedly asked me, "is this what your classes are like?!"

Good morning! God made you special, and he loves you very much. That’s it. That’s the tweet.