
TL:DR comparing Republicans to Nazis is antithetical to the prophet’s call for peacemaking. Put that on a Deseret Voices podcast.
Because Tyler Robinson wrote “Hey Fascist, Catch” on the bullets he used to kill Charlie Kirk. Comparisons to Nazis kill civil discourse, stoke fear and paranoia, and stir deep emotional reactions that create mass psychosis. Nothing has done more to stir contention, discord, division, and hate in the last 10 years than comparing Donald Trump to Hitler. If that hadn’t been done, our politics would be much more sane. When the prophet calls for peacemaking, he’s calling for this kind of rhetoric to end. So stop doing it and stop defending it. That goes for William, the Deseret News, Democrats, everyone. If you compare anyone to Hitler, you’re usually not actually comparing them to Hitler. You’re comparing them to something Hitler did, ignoring the fact that Hitler did lots of things—things that have nothing to do with why he was an evil dictator. Nationalism, for example. Something that isn’t inherently bad … until you connect it to Hitler’s nationalism. Or criticizing the press … something that is warranted a lot of the time in America, and that presidents have done throughout history, but when Trump does it suddenly it’s “Hitler-esque.” Comparisons to Hitler are, by design, intended to shut down conversation and create “us vs them” mindsets in the audience. It’s rhetorical purpose is to identify the subject with something so evil, so vile, that surely nobody would want anything to do with it. That accomplishes nothing. It’s irrational, despicable behavior. And William, I’m disgusted that you defend it. It’s designed to mislead, it’s designed to malign. If you don’t agree with Trump’s deportation policy, make a case for why it’s bad. Don’t compare it to Hitler—the two aren’t remotely the same except on the most surface level. And let me add one more concept to this rebuttal of your idiotic standard. When you compare Trump to Hitler, you can’t avoid the natural tendency for people to think to themselves, “Well, Trump lowered my taxes and secured the border and is reversing DEI policies and doing all these things I like … so maybe, if he’s Hitler like they say, maybe Hitler wasn’t so bad.” And all of the sudden, you have a new generation of Hitler apologists wondering what else they’ve been “lied to” about. This is my warning to all the “enlightened centrists” and anti-Trump conservatives out there: this kind of rhetoric only leads to more extremism. If you keep it up, you’re practically chiseling out the stumbling block that will bring you down in the future. Knock it off. Be rational. If you compare Trump to Hitler, you’re retarded and should never be taken seriously again.



















