“The canons of narrative in any medium cannot be wholly different; and the failure of poor films is often precisely in exaggeration, and in the intrusion of unwarranted matter owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies.” - J.R.R. Tolkien
#RespectForTolkien
That isn't how his shape shifting works.
Never did Sauron impersonate someone else, ever, nor could he. When an Ainu “clothes itself,” the form is a manifestation of its own thought and nature, not an impersonation. This has no canonical precedent. (Retards will try and cite Beren and Lúthien taking the forms of Draugluin and Thuringwethil. HOWEVER, they used the actual wolf-hame of Draugluin and the bat-fell of Thuringwethil, and combined with Lúthien’s arts, they became LIKE those creatures in appearance.)
We do however have precedent of Sauron using someone's loved one as a means to trick them. When Gorlim was tricked into getting captured. Newsflash: Sauron didn't pretend to be Gorlim's wife, nor did he swap spit with Gorlim.
This whole scene is bullshit.
I get that this scene never happened in Tolkien’s books, and I know a lot of fans feel like the show crossed a line here, but I honestly see it differently. If you know Sauron’s story, you know his greatest weapon has always been deception, manipulation, and his ability to take on different forms to get what he wants. Using Galadriel’s appearance, and even a kiss, to deceive someone doesn’t necessarily go against who he is. If anything, it shows just how twisted and manipulative he can be. Tolkien didn’t call him the Lord of Deceit for nothing. We can disagree with some of the show’s creative choices while still admitting that this kind of cruelty is pretty much in character for Sauron.
#TheRingsOfPower
I don't need to point this out, but I'm going to anyway.
There is no such thing as homosexuality in Arda. Tolkien never wrote any gay characters.
Rings of Power needs to die.
Poor audience score was a given. Show is awful.
The "fan division" was actually a blessing in disguise. It separated the real fans of Tolkien from the blind consumers.
I'm struggling to see why they're doing this lmao
The show's viewership has been on a steep decline since its debut. Who the hell is going to leave the comfort of home and PAY to watch this garbage?
See the forging of the One Ring early on the big screen. Click the link here for global screening listings, and buy your concession voucher to save your seat. bit.ly/TheRingsofPowerTicket…
Among the many exposed, blatant attempts by Amazon to copy Peter Jackson's homework, one managed to slip under the radar.
They repurposed the name "Haleth". Jackson did this when he gave the name to the son of Hama at Helm's Deep.
In the canon, there have been two characters named Haleth. The first is Haleth, lady of the Haladin, an incredibly brave woman who held her people strong against an onslaught of orcs after her father and brother were butchered by the orcs.
The second is Haleth, the son of Helm Hammerhand, who died defending Edoras against the men of Dunland.
Art by Yidan portraying Haleth, lady of the Haladin.
I need to address something.
I've received a few DMs from individuals who I think are just trying to stir up drama, showing me that some Rings of Power fans are "attacking" me on a personal basis. I honestly could not care less. Please stop. Unless it's something serious like doxxing or threats, it's not a big deal. Let people talk shit. If that makes them feel better, God bless em. And honestly, from the stuff I've been shown, what's been said isn't really all that terrible. I've been called worse.
A little over two years ago, my friend @MiddleearthMixr had a kind of come to Jesus talk with me about all the drama that I was embroiled in with Rings of Power fans at the time, and told me that I needed to, and I'm paraphrasing, pull the plug on the drama shit and just talk about the things I'm passionate about.
Since I've done that, I've had an explosion of wonderful new followers, healthy conversations, fun debates, made some wonderful friends, and I've been able to speak with some of my favorite content creators about Middle-earth.
I wish to continue along this path. So, I'm sorry if some people want to see me get into shit slinging with Rings of Power fans, but that isn't going to happen. I'm going to talk lore, I'm going to have healthy, good faith discussions, and I'm going to continue to shit all over Rings of Power.
I hope all of you are have a wonderful day. God bless.
"bUt tOLkiEn sTrugGLeD WiTh tHe oRCs bEiNg rEdEEmAbLe"
True. No one is arguing against that. His Catholicism made it difficult for him.
Tolkien, and by extension his son Christopher, more or less solved this dilemma.
First: The orcs are not born evil, at least not at first. They are captured elves, tormented and twisted by Morgoth into the hideous race of the Orc.
Second: Their "redemption" is in death, being slain, or slaying themselves.
The following part from The Lord of the Rings buries any and all bullshit that idiots are going to say about "muh redeemable orc":
"As when death smites the swollen brooding thing that inhabits their crawling hill and holds them all in sway, ants will wander witless and purposeless and then feebly die, so the creatures of Sauron, orc or troll or beast spell-enslaved, ran hither and thither mindless; and some slew themselves, or cast themselves in pits, or fled wailing back to hide in holes and dark lightless places far from hope."
Would you all like to know what the Nazgul did when they encountered one the Noldor?
They fled.
Twice.
Tolkien explicitly states that no force of evil other than Sauron himself at full strength could (in theory) take Lothlorien because the power that resided there (Galadriel) was too great.
Any single descendant of Finwë, with little effort could easily body all nine of the Nazgûl. The difference in power is simply far too wide. That scene from Rings of Power is pure nonsense, which summarizes the whole show to be honest.
Art by Yidan
نزگول بکشن ؟
حتی یکی
خب این یعنی کشکی نبوده دیگه
یعنی این افراد، حتی گندالف که یک مایا بود و از نظر قدرت هم تراز سائرون بود و حلقه ی قدرت داشت نتونست یکنزگولبکشه
نه حتی گالادریل
خب
پس چرا باید از دیدن همچین سکانسی تعجب کرد؟
Tolkien regarded the universe of Eä to be a secondary world, a fictional universe apart from our own. He also considered Eru Ilúvatar to be the "author" or creator of that universe (See letter 192).
As such, we must approach the world by the rules that are established therein. When elves kill other elves unjustly, it is considered abhorrent. When men kill other men unjustly, it is considered abhorrent.
But wouldn't you know it, there isn't a single instance, not one, of an orc being killed unjustly. Elves, Dwarves and Men all casually stack orc bodies, millions of dead orcs for over 7000 years (rough estimate of time between the Dagor-nuin-Giliath and the Battle of the Morannon), and nowhere is this regarded as a negative.
Furthermore, there isn't a single instance of an orc showing any kind of sympathetic quality. They are brutal, savage, and utterly cruel. There's a ton of examples, but the one I like to cite the most is the fate of Gelmir at the hands of the orcs during the Nirnaeth Arnoediad, where they dismembered him while he was still alive, in front of his own brother, Gwindor.
The only argument that can be made, that sounds remotely reasonable, is that orcs find "redemption" in their own demise. Otherwise, during their miserable lives, orcs are evil. Period.
Your stance is anti-Catholic, anti-Christian, and anti-Tolkien (who in various places not only laid the conceptual spiritual groundwork for redemptive orcs, but also admittedly wrestled with this exact question). And that's all assuming that the orc is not a double agent