
Emerging evidence indicates that you don’t need to train to failure to maximize resistance training adaptations; however, it's essential to train in close proximity to failure or gains will be compromised. But does every set need to be performed close to failure, or can varying proximity to failure over time produce comparable results? Our recent study, led by my colleagues at Jyväskylä University, investigated this question in 31 resistance-trained men and women over 10 weeks (doi: 10.1007/s42978-025-00338-8). Participants were randomly assigned to either use a constant high level of effort, with all sets performed at RIR of 1, or a variable effort where they progressively reduced their target RIR from 4 to 1 across successive weeks. Both groups performed the same exercises over a four day/wk resistance training program. Results showed no statistically significant differences between groups in muscle hypertrophy or strength gains. Importantly, the variable RIR group reported significantly lower perceived exertion across the training program, despite achieving similar muscular adaptations. We also found that participants were reasonably accurate at estimating RIR before training, and accuracy at estimating 3 RIR improved in the variable RIR group. The takeaway: Our findings suggest that consistently training very close to failure across all sets may not be necessary to maximize short-term muscular adaptations. Periodically training further from failure appears to be a viable strategy for promoting muscle growth and strength while reducing perceived training effort. Bottom line: You don't necessarily need to push every set to the limit. Varying proximity to failure may allow you to achieve comparable gains with less perceived effort, potentially making training more manageable over time. link.springer.com/article/10…




















