Founder at Biometrology. Nanobiologist, scanning probe microscopist. Frmr research scientist: US Dept of Energy, Digital Instruments, Univ of Chicago faculty.
The writer surmises that it's BETTER we were misled about "lab leak" being a conspiracy theory. Otherwise the truth may have led to WW3. No! What the truth would've led to is a definitive answer on origin &tighter global biosafety/security regulations.
nytimes.com/2025/05/21/opini…
I felt PO’s conclusions were poorly supported by the avail evidence, w political pressure seemingly playing a role. Of the original 5 authors, only 1 or 2 remain staunch defenders. Still, getting the science or expert opinion wrong is not fraud; proving intent to mislead tricky.
What Politico fails to acknowledge is that those of us calling for a retraction of 'Proximal Origin' are not doing it because we want the lab leak theory to be true. We are doing it because we believe the paper is a serious violation of scientific and ethical standards. Ensuring the integrity of the scientific system is one of the most important and challenging tasks of our time. Furthermore, the paper has been instrumental in the discrediting of an entirely legitimate hypothesis, thus preventing an open and objective search for Covid origins (the answer to which is still not determined). Huge thanks to @NIHDirector_Jay and his colleagues at NIH for pressing for a review what really happened behind the scenes when this paper was written. Any attempt to frame this as partisan politics is doing the whole scientific community a major disservice.
politico.com/news/2026/11/18…
4 still viable leak scenarios, no independent investigation:
1- Wild virus modified during research,
2- Unidentified wild virus collected &brought into lab,
3- Virus under study accidentally released from lab,
4- Researcher infected by naturally occurring virus during fieldwork.
It s/b noted that pointing out the insanity of risky research operating internationally w no mechanism in place to properly investigate the origin of any outbreak pathogen was not welcome news to a certain grp of risky virologists. Some smeared (esp Dr Rasmussen), all blocked me.
When the world needs a genuine investigation w independent forensic testing (as it did in Wuhan). We now know it'll get a delayed negotiated study lacking the access req'd to adequately investigate. Leaving critical evidence unavailable &an outbreak pathogen's origin unresolved.
RBaric "complete & truthful", 22Jan'24:
*Mar'18, Wuhan sought wild covs w spikes 20-25% from SC1, fcs, &ACE2 binding, r "highly variable" features of SC2
*This virus leaking from BSL2 in Wuhan had unacceptably hi risk
*Woroby-Pekar papers suffer uncertainties &r not conclusive
"Lab leak" was never eliminated by the ambitious Worobey-Pekar 2-jump Market SO theory. Never delivering on its promise of "dispositive" "slam dunk" evidence where the public could finally "know". But this was the big PR/media push from the usual Market enthusiasts back in '22.
Blocked, why?
1- Most agreement has formed around the avail origin evidence being inconclusive
2- Research-assoc leak is an excellent scientifically-sound hypothesis never properly tested
3- Wuhan &Irkusk were not properly investigated as no regulatory mechanism to do so exists.
3/3
5. Mistook repeated agreement betw relative few influential scientists for scientific/ evidentiary consensus.
6. Reacted haughty &hyperdefensive to facts of a plausible scientifically-sound LLH w no regulatory mechanism in place for proper investigation.
2/3
3. Treated LL as an attack on science rather than a valid scientific hypothesis warranting proper investigation.
4. Discounted possibilities that exposed uncomfortable questions including re: COI, research practices, biosafety/security, funding, institutional responsibility.
1/3
6 Sins of Ardent Market Proponents
1. Favored circumstantial evidence for natural zoonosis while more aggressively scrutinizing the untested lab leak hypothesis (LLH).
2. Settled on a preferred Market conclusion ignoring critical evidence never properly collected or examined.
A single piece of forensic evidence is all it'd take to break the origin case wide open. Eg, a sample, sequence, medical record, lab log, exposure reprt. But no regulatory mechanism exists allowing the independent access needed to actually solve any such case. Failure assured.
Yes, more published evidence supports Market theory, but quantity does not add to quality or confidence here. As Irkutsk, evidence needed to establish what really happened in Wuhan remains missing. Therefore virologists are premature to claim origin clearly solved at the Market.
The same gaps badly botched origin investigation in Wuhan- leaving these 2 civilian cases intolerably unsolved. How to close the gap is known, immediate independent onsite forensic audits. W/out this implemented, in this day &age, best option is a moratorium on risky bioresearch.
10Jan'20 nCoV seq makes LL alarmingly plausible to Dr Daszak. So what did he do? Orchestrate Lancet letter calling LL "conspiracy theory"; via media label LL "pure baloney"; join the WHO origin team; etc. AFAIK no virologist ever calls out the blatant COI, instead supporting him.