←
M.L.S. Weech25,101 posts
M.L.S. Weech avatar

M.L.S. Weech

@MLSWeech

M.L.S. Weech is a science fiction and fantasy author.

◷ Joined April 2015▧ 1,671 Photos and videos
Draft To The Future avatar
⟳ M.L.S. Weech retweeted
Draft To The Future@Draft2theFuture·20h

On the left is what we think SHOULD happen and on the right is what we think WILL happen. How dumb are we? Tell us in the comments. Not sure about the trades? Miami now has Lamar in one!

Post attachmentPost attachment
M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 17

I’d take Utah against both Mississippi State and A & M. I’d like my chances against LSU. I would take Wake or Miami against them. Same UCLA and Indiana. Comparing mid and mid is pointless. You take the top teams from each conference and let players on a field prove it.

Don’t chant, but these three blowouts over the middle class from other leagues are carrying the SOS in all of the various computer polls. Remember, we’re told that all of these winning teams are trash. LSU 51, Clemson 10 Miss St 38, Minnesota 13 Texas A&M 48, Arizona St 20

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 17

Any effort of intellectual debate is entirely undermined when your last point is a base insult. Playoffs are NOT about what you COULD or MIGHT do. Playoffs & their rankings should be about what was earned. Power rankings are relevant for betting, but meaningless on a field.

If anyone whines tonight about Alabama's ranking (or any SEC team) with multiple losses, consider what the AP Top 25 would look like if win-loss record mattered above all else. I'm putting my power rankings in parentheses to show how far off some of these would be: 1. Utah (10-0; my No. 11) 2. UCLA (10-0; No. 12) 3. Georgia (9-1; No. 1) 4. Notre Dame (9-1; No. 2) 5. Miami (9-1; No. 5) 6. Indiana (9-1; No. 6) 7. Wake Forest (9-1; No. 13) 8. Texas Tech (9-1; No. 16) 9. Boise State (9-1; No. 38) 10. Liberty (9-1; No. 50) 11. Alabama (8-2; No. 3) 12. Texas (8-2; No. 4) 13. Tennessee (8-2; No. 9) 14. BYU (8-2; No. 18) 15. Iowa (8-2; No. 15) 16. Memphis (8-2; No. 54) 17. UTSA (8-2; No. 73) 18. New Mexico (8-2; No. 45) 19. Louisiana Tech (8-2; No. 72) 20. North Dakota State (8-2; No. 64) 21. Air Force (8-2; No. 77) 22. Toledo (8-2; No. 80) 23. Oregon (7-3; No. 10) 24. Ohio State (7-3; No. 8) 25. Kentucky (7-3; No. 35) At one point in time, even one loss risked disqualifying you from winning a national title. Yes, college football can boast about the most meaningful regular season. But in the world of superconferences with nine-game conference schedules and the parity of the NIL + rev share era, that's an antiquated standard. The College Football Playoff committee finally stopped overindexing on wins and losses and started properly weighting them. They matter but they should be put into proper context based on schedule and other factors. If fewer losses was the ultimate determiner, you'd have to rank Liberty (my No. 50) ahead of Bama (my No. 3). According to Sagarin, Liberty has played the 140th-toughest schedule ... there are only 138 FBS teams, btw. And Bama has played the seventh-toughest schedule. Whenever someone's entire argument is based on total losses, just know they're using simpleton logic.

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 17

I can't discuss this because I can't understand it. Can @CFPResumeRanks explain what we're seeing?

Week 11 Conference Strength Ratings The Big Ten and Big 12 are really starting to converge not only in mean rating but in shape as well In the G6 ranks, the Mountain West has overtaken the Sun Belt to move up to 3rd in the G6 hierarchy The 2nd tier of SEC is a meat grinder...

Post attachment
M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 17

I do that in my own rankings. To be fair though, my rankings and AP's aren't very different. I think anyone arguing rankings should provide their own. Mine are @Draft2theFuture

Good Morning. Can we agree that “ranked wins” should be based on END-OF-SEASON rankings? Beat #10 in Week 2, but they finish unranked? Ranked win. Beat an unranked team that finishes #10? This system completely backwards?

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

Been saying the same thing.

The SEC loves that 10-2 vs the P4. The 10 teams they beat: 53-47 combined CFP-ranked wins: 1 (#20 Ohio State) Wins by 4 or less: 4 Wins by 1 point: 2 The 2 they lost to: 15-5 Lost by 33 to #2 Utah Lost by 7 to 5-5 Michigan Beating a bunch of 6-4 teams isn't the flex yall think it is

Post attachment
M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

“Top half” = 7/16 ASU, 5/16 Baylor, 7/17 FSU, 3/17 Louisville, 4/18 OSU, 6/17 Clemson. Are you seriously trying to hang your hat on those wins? OSU is the only team you played other than Utah, who murdered you.

Reminder: the SEC beat 10 P4 teams OOC this season. Of those P4 teams, 6 are in the top half of their respective conferences. But go off about how those wins "aren't impressive" or they were against "bad teams". 🏈

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

I fully agree with this statement. The production is nowhere near good enough, but the tools are the tools. The data says production wins more often. Of course there are exceptions, but the data says 1/10 QBs actually win a SB.

NFL teams have proven two things throughout draft history: They draft quarterbacks HIGH, and they bet on TRAITS. Arch Manning had a brutal night vs LSU (4 sacks, 3 INTs), but the arm talent, athleticism, and upside aren’t going anywhere. He’s still going to hear his name called in Round 1. Whether the tape is worthy of it or not, just the lay of the land in NFL Front Offices and the NFL Draft.

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

Assuming they all win out, they've earned it. I'd even consider a 3-loss Texas depending on what the teams below them do.

Georgia, Alabama, Texas & Tennessee are the 4 SEC teams in the playoff somehow, someway

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

Actually, the ACC because they've played twice as many P4 teams, and they've played as many 7 & 8 win P4 teams as the SEC total, oh, and they only played 5 & 6 win teams. So they've actually played teams. SEC just took on mid teams to pretend they're playing the same game.

NON-CONF P4 RECORDS: SEC 10-2 Big 12 6-7 ACC 6-13 Big Ten 4-10 So until proven otherwise, who should get the benefit of the doubt.

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 16

Our complaint wasn’t in drafting him. It never was. It was WHERE they drafted him. Again, if someone can give me on the record proof he wouldn’t have been there in round 5, THEN I would admit I’m wrong. Still waiting on that proof.

The internet can be very judgy about opinions they don’t agree with (or so I hear).

M.L.S. Weech avatar
M.L.S. Weech@MLSWeech·Nov 15

Gonna wait for the Ole Miss game before giving my full rankings, but regardless of that game, here are my #CFBPlayoff teams in order: Utah Georgia UCLA Texas Notre Dame Miami Indiana Tennessee Alabama Texas Tech Wake Forest Boise State I have BYU out. BYU/Wake the arguemnt.