←
Marc Edelman15,513 posts
Marc Edelman avatar

Marc Edelman

@MarcEdelman

Tenured Law Professor. Fulbright Scholar. Sports Ethics Director. Attorney. Former Skadden. I write on Antitrust, IP, Higher Ed and Sports. Marc@MarcEdelman.com

◷ Joined June 2009▧ 286 Photos and videos
Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·1h

Adding to my upcoming speaking engagements: on Wednesday March 31, 2027, this double Wolverine New Yorker is coming to Columbus, Ohio to speak to the Ohio Bar Association for a CLE on sports antitrust.

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·6h

I am beginning to believe there is a strong inverse relationship between one’s intellectual depth and their use of PowerPoint slides. PowerPoint, in its essence, reduces complexities into bullet points, removes shades of gray, features buzzwords and curtails careful reasoning.

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·8h

The absence of an explanation to the below question is your answer. And, it is the real story about yesterday’s Knight Commission talk at the Ritz Carlton. 🍾🥂

I challenge any person affiliated with the @NCAA or @KnightAthletics — and I will settle for absolutely any one — to explain on the record why you believe limiting pay from third-party collectives to college athletes helps to prevent colleges from losing money. Game on!

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·17h

I challenge any person affiliated with the @NCAA or @KnightAthletics — and I will settle for absolutely any one — to explain on the record why you believe limiting pay from third-party collectives to college athletes helps to prevent colleges from losing money. Game on!

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·23h

My growing conclusion: the Knight Commission is actually *worse* than all of the rest. They send pretty press releases, have pretty PowerPoints, and do a pretty good job of pretending neutrality. But, spoiler alert: they are not the revenue-generating college athlete’s friend.

Two things stand out to me here: 1. Just like in the college sports bill's drafting process, the Knight Commission event has multiple #NCAA voices. None represent revenue-generating college athletes. 2. And laughably, the event is held at the Ritz-Carlton. The Ritz Carlton. Is this where robber barons always go to cry poverty?

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·Nov 17

This is consistent with the argument that I've been making about college sports for well over a decade: when we don't allow free markets, we get black markets (e.g., underground payments) and dirty markets (e.g., Gator Getters, Louisville recruiting w/ sex and strippers, etc.)

It’s not really money laundering, $ from illegal activities isn’t being cleaned. But what Pollard is complaining about is a byproduct of a model that (1) refuses to acknowledge most $ being paid to athletes is for playing, and (2) tries to cap athlete pay below market rates.

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·Nov 17

Every once and awhile I write something in legalese and realize the “caveman” style reads better. Forgive my retweet of the f-bomb. I always tell my students to convert legalese into plain English, and the gentleman (not my student) below did a pretty awesome job of it:

caveman terms MLB owners: “No deal? No baseball.” Players: “Fine. We ditch our union and sue you for antitrust violations” MLB: “WAIT, WHAT?” Players: “Curt Flood Act.” Plot twist: A Yankees executive helped write that law, which expanded players’ rights Owners: “Oh fuck.”

Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·Nov 17

Having listened to the first 30 minutes of the Knight Commission talk, it helps to close the lines between them, the #NCAA, and the targeting of Democrats in Congress. Their panelists speak well, but they only come across so well absent the dissenting voice’s pushback.

Presenting a very different working theory on the relevant business interests and economic incentives of the parties working on the #NCAA Protect College Sports Act. If anything seems off here, please let me know. I still cannot figure out the Cantwell piece.

Post attachment
Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·Nov 17

Two things stand out to me here: 1. Just like in the college sports bill's drafting process, the Knight Commission event has multiple #NCAA voices. None represent revenue-generating college athletes. 2. And laughably, the event is held at the Ritz-Carlton. The Ritz Carlton. Is this where robber barons always go to cry poverty?

Register to watch our public session at 9:15 am today (11-17): bit.ly/November17session This public session with #NCAA, conference, & campus #collegesports leaders examines possible enactment of #PCSA by #Congress to increased conference self-governance. #HigherEd #TitleIX #CFP

Post attachment
Marc Edelman avatar
Marc Edelman@MarcEdelman·Nov 17

When we think about organizations that the media quotes on college sports, the Knight Commission appears often. To me, this organization is a wolf in sheep's clothing--claiming, especially to Democrats, to support "reform," while in reality just promoting a subset of the #NCAA voice. This morning, at 9:15 AM ET, I invite you to come listen to the Knight Commission in what I presume will be one final effort to push the Trump/Levine/Cruz/Cantwell bill that primarily serves to strip the antitrust rights of revenue-generating college athletes (but also has some obscuring sprinkles). My guess: the playbook will be to highlight the sprinkles, and not the repression of athlete voices in the bill's development process. Let's see if I am right. Here is the link: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/regi…