Nagel: “There’s no mental life there in the ordinary sense. It’s not a mind. It’s not somebody that we have to care about. It’s a machine. Here are some of the smartest people on the planet being completely idiotic”
Thomas Nagel has done landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans; this week, he won the million-dollar Berggruen Prize for his contributions to the field. And he has a lot of thoughts on AI. buff.ly/qf8Mls0
I can live with a protagonist who has reasonable and justified self-doubt. That is realistic and believable. But when every hero has a full-blown existential crisis, it becomes a bit much.
Therapy culture has ruined contemporary fiction.
We don't need every character to process his trauma, identify her attachment style, and articulate his emotional boundaries.
The most interesting literary characters often don't understand themselves.
Paul Feyerabend: "The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on. But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth" (quoted in Lakatos and Feyerabend, For and Against Method).
What Feyerabend said about that generation goes double for the current crop of pop science dorks (apart from the "may be more intelligent" bit, LOL).
"The internal crisis, whether it precede or follow the political, is inevitable in a society that multiplies means without ends. Man is a creature that in the long run has got to believe in order to know, and to know in order to do."—Allen Tate, Essays of Four Decades, p. 6-7.
#CharacteristicsOfLiteraryModernism #5: "Nature ceases to be a central subject or setting of literature." "...[N]ature is transformed from an organic setting into a summoned or remembered idea. Nature ceases to be natural."—Irving Howe, Literary Modernism
“If my mental processes are determined wholly by the motions of atoms in my brain, I have no reason to suppose that my beliefs are true...and hence I have no reason for supposing my brain to be composed of atoms.”—J. B. S. Haldane
Nowhere in this statement is an 'ought' derived from an 'is'. Just placing words or examples of oughts and ises in close proximity does not constitute a derivation.
Yes, in the chapter on Moral Truths in my latest book, Truth, I claim that one can derive an ought from is. Here is how:
It is my hypothesis that in the same way that Galileo and Newton discovered physical laws and principles about the natural world that really are out there, so too have social scientists discovered moral laws and principles about human nature and society that really do exist.
Just as it was inevitable that the astronomer Johannes Kepler would discover that planets have elliptical orbits—given that he was making accurate astronomical measurements, and given that planets really do travel in elliptical orbits, he could hardly have discovered anything else—scientists studying political, economic, social, and moral subjects will discover certain things that are true in these fields of inquiry.
For example, that democracies are better than autocracies, that market economies are superior to command economies, that torture and the death penalty do not curb crime, that burning women as witches is a fallacious idea, that women are not too weak and emotional to run companies or countries, and, most poignantly here, that blacks do not like being enslaved and that the Jews do not want to be exterminated.
Why do blacks not want to be enslaved? Why do Jews not want to be exterminated? The answer is in my moral starting point of the survival and flourishing of individual sentient beings. Any organism subject to natural selection will by necessity have this drive to survive and flourish. If it didn’t, it would not live long enough to reproduce and would no longer be subject to natural selection. Why?
The answer is found in the deepest purpose of life: to push back against the entropy of nature, as described by the Second Law of Thermodynamics, which is the first law of life. If you do nothing, entropy will take its course and you will move toward a higher state of disorder (ultimately causing your demise). So the most basic purpose in life is to combat entropy by doing something extropic—expending energy to survive, reproduce, and flourish.
I suppose it is possible that one day scientists may discover that humans do not have an instinct to survive and flourish, that most people do not want freedom, autonomy, and prosperity, that they don’t mind starving and being disease ridden and in pain, that they prefer ignorance to education and illiteracy to literacy, that women want to be lorded over by men, that some people like being enslaved, and that large populations of people don’t object to being liquidated in gas chambers.
But I doubt it.
We have an epidemic of students turning in essays they didn’t write about books they haven’t read, and if teachers are now using AI to grade assignments en masse we may as well shut down the schools because no one here is teaching and no one is learning.
The college admissions essay is in a very weird place. It's impossible to say just how many of them are now written by AI, but at this point, experts agree that it's a lot of them. And while colleges generally frown upon that practice, they're using AI to evaluate the essays, too. cnn.com/2026/11/15/tech/ai-s…
I sent a DM to @CBradleyThomps1, founder of Clemson University’s Lyceum Program (one of the most selective academic programs in America)
My question: Would he recommend sending one of my own children to a small classical high school that doesn’t offer a single College Board Advanced Placement (AP) course?
His response speaks volumes.
———————-
Hi Jeremy: Good to hear from you.
Your son sounds like the kind of young man, who seems destined for Clemson!
In our experience, we have found that AP classes are not particularly rigorous and certainly don't prepare students for the Lyceum Program. In fact, we don't even look at the applicants transcripts and the courses they've taken, and we're not particularly interested in their high school GPA, which we find to be mostly usesless. We also rate the CLT higher than the SAT or ACT.
What's most important for the Lyceum application are the essays, and, more particularly, a good account by the student of the books that have been most influential in their lives. We want students who can think and talk about the most important questions in human life.
We accept a disproportionally high number of students into Lyceum who have received a classical education, either from a charter or private school. In our experience, classically educated homeschool kids are typically our best students.
We've also found that true-blue Great Books schools such as the Chesterton Academies and the Great Hearts schools tend to produce better students and precisely the kind we're looking for. We want our Lyceum students to have read not a good book or two in high school but dozens of great books in the Western tradition. Schools like Chesterton tend to do that better than most.
Bottom line: my advice would be to send your son to the school where he will get the best classical education and not worry about schools with AP courses, which mean nothing to us.
I hope that you and family will be able to come down sometime for a visit.
Please let me know if I can help in any way.
Best,
Brad
The Classical Seven-Step Thinking Skills Program: grammar, logic, rhetoric, arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music. In other words, the Liberal Arts.
"I would like to see fewer biographies of great individuals and more biographies of great families or villages. We tend to overrate the singular man of original genius, while ignoring the slow accumulation of culture built up layer upon layer, century upon century, that makes the individual man of genius possible in the first place." memoriacollege.org/the-culti…
Our politics suffers from the modern penchant to "immanentize the eschaton", as William F. Buckley once put it (summarizing Eric Voegelin): the idea that, with just the right social or political prescriptions, we can bring about a heavenly utopia here in the temporal world.
On the Death of Simone Weil:
"She lies inert upon the bed’s white sheet,
And lets the last breath rattle from her throat.
Her living flesh becoming hunger’s meat,
While dancing on the light, she sees a mote, ..." memoriacollege.org/on-the-de…
#CharacteristicsOfLiteraryModernism #4: "The Idea of esthetic order is abandoned or radically modified." Modernism rejects the "traditional criteria of unity, order, and coherence" and replaces it with "a jagged and fragmented expressiveness."—Irving Howe, Literary Modernism