←
Max Anderson3,529 posts
Max Anderson avatar

Max Anderson

@MaxAnderson

Bootstrapped SaaS co to 8-fig ARR. Helped take another from 0 to 9-fig rev & NASDAQ IPO. Lucky husband and dad of 2

◷ Joined November 2011▧ 597 Photos and videos
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Nov 8

I am one of these young Americans I was living paycheck to paycheck I bought a 20yr old used car for $3000 using money I saved up from mowing lawns in high school. Drove it for a decade When that broke down I replaced it with another $3000 car which I drove for another decade Only did oil changes, no other maintenance costs. Total cost of ownership worked out to ~ $30 / mo over 20 years Everyone starts out living paycheck to paycheck You break free of that by being frugal, investing every penny you can and outworking everyone else around you Not by being entitled, bitching about boomers, or whining about the $8400 / yr car payment you chose being too expensive Take ownership of your situation Stop being a victim Realize the only person who can fix your finances is you Be more frugal than your peers Work harder than your peers (including 2nd jobs and side hustles — whatever it takes) Invest the difference every month That’s how you break free Not by being a whiny bitch

My boomer uncle just said something that genuinely made me furious. “If you have a $700 car payment, don’t complain about living paycheck to paycheck. And don’t forget your $9 daily latte and $150 monthly phone bill.” This is exactly the problem. Why is this generation constantly being told to give up every little comfort just to afford a decent life? What does a morning coffee have to do with being able to afford a home, build a future, and get ahead financially? We’re dealing with a generation of people in positions of power who still don’t understand the financial reality younger Americans are living through. And somehow, we’re the ones being blamed.

Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Nov 7

There’s a parcel for sale in Phoenix that would incredible for this

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment

Billion dollar idea: Install an amphitheater like this in your town. Great for concerts, events and will stimulate the local economy. What’s stopping you?

0:08
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Nov 6

Anyone who has ever done conversion optimization or A/B testing on a website can tell you with certainty: For any process that involves humans filling out a form, you will always see a normal “bell curve” distribution of how quickly vs carefully people fill out that form Some will go slow, read all the fine print, and triple check before making their choice Others will rush, scan quickly and just tick the first option that appears right at first glance Most people do something in between So if you want to artificially suppress the rate at which a given option gets selected, it’s remarkably easy to do You simply target the folks on that far left tail of that quickly vs carefully distribution There’s a time-tested method for how to do that. Namely: 1) place the option you want to suppress at the bottom of the list 2) insert a superfluous option that looks similar above it 3) place the option you want people to select above both You don’t have trick everyone (or even a majority) of people filling out the form The median voter will see right through your trick, and that’s fine You’re only targeting a few % of the most rushed people on the far left tail of the curve All that was required to swing the AK senate seat race was 0.6% They got 3% 97% of voters went slow and read carefully enough to notice and side-step the trick 3% did not That’s not surprising It’s exactly what you’d expect from a normal distribution of any set of humans filling out this form But it was more the enough to decide who gets a seat in the US senate

Post attachmentPost attachment

Democrats recruited a fake Dan Sullivan to defraud Alaska voters It worked

Post attachment
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Nov 1

If you have young kids highly recommend getting one of these btw

0:36
0:20
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Nov 1

Pumpkins in the trash Christmas tree went up at 12:01am last night It’s officially THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME OF THE YEAR My house will be waking up to peppermint hot chocolate and Mariah Carey Christmas at obnoxiously high volume every morning this week

Post attachment
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 30

> be reddit > foster culture of rampant anti-capitalist woke circlejerking on the platform > advertisers can’t make $ from ads b/c reddit users are commies who think all businesses are evil > realize only way to profit is to license content to AI labs for training > AI labs already scraped all the content > require login to prevent future scraping > SEO traffic goes to zero > usage drops 90% > die a slow unremarkable death

Reddit is getting rid of logged out browsing. They want to require everyone to be logged in to access the site. They’re claiming it’s to protect against scraping which is hilarious because the site has already been scraped. End of an era. No more googling “question + Reddit”

Post attachment
Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 29

The spread between how much value a business creates vs. how much value it captures is stored-up potential energy for the future earnings growth of that business It's a pool of easily available incremental earnings the business can capture essentially any time it wants to Capturing that potential does not require the business to create any new value in the world Which is important because creating new value in the world is: a) hard b) not entirely in the business's control c) must be done against market forces + competitors who push back d) highly uncertain Whereas a business simply increasing its take rate on the value it already created is: a) comparatively easy b) often entirely within the business's control c) generally cannot be impeded by competitors or other outside forces d) highly certain overall For these reasons, a large potential energy justifies a large multiple atop a company's current earnings For Google, for most of its life up until recently, this spread was MASSIVE Google created orders of magnitude more value than it captured in Search for the better part of two decades This (quite reasonably) justified a high a multiple That spread is now closing fast Google has been rapidly driving its value capture / value creation ratio in Search towards (and even through) 100% The vast majority of Search advertisers today already operate the channel at breakeven or a loss In most segments of Search, Google already captures near 100% of the value it creates. And in many segments >100% Google stored up an enormous potential energy in Search over 20+ yrs, and is torching the entirety of it to fund its AI capex today This is not necessarily good nor bad strategy. It's simply a statement of fact And it is clearly an intentional strategic choice by Google Only time will tell whether that strategy was correct But one thing is already settled: The spread that justified a high multiple on Google's Search business is no longer there And it's not coming back

As someone who has personally spent $500k / mo+ on Google Ads for years, I can tell you with certainty: This revenue growth in Search is artificial & extremely unhealthy for Google’s business long term Search volumes are declining as legacy search is being increasingly cannibalized by non-monetized LLM queries Google’s response? Manufacture revenue growth via short-sighted, highly extractive, customer-hostile tactics. I.e. charge advertisers more for lower quality clicks, including clicks they do not want and explicitly did not approve Google to charge them for A few examples to illustrate: For all of its history until recently, Google operated on a 2nd price auction model I.e. if you bid $5 CPC and the next highest bidder bids $1 CPC, Google charged you $1.01 for the click (one penny more than the 2nd highest bidder) rather than the $5 you bid This was a genius move by Google early on as it incentivizes advertisers to input their true maximum willingness to pay rather than trying to play the game of bidding low and constantly adjusting to try to stay just ahead of the next highest bidder while still not paying too much However recently, Google silently deprecated the 2nd price auction and began charging advertisers as much as their bid and budget caps allow, regardless of what anyone else is bidding It’s a short-sighted cash grab at the expense of the long term health of the advertiser ecosystem Making thing worse, Google also recently nerfed keyword targeting precision Google previously had precise keyword targeting settings that allowed advertisers pick individual search phrases to bid on, defined down to the character w/ exact match or phrase match targeting This was one of the core features that made search advertising magic, enabling advertisers to run extremely precise campaigns based on exactly what their target customer typed But now, even if you bid on a specific term or phrase using the strictest exact -match targeting settings, Google will show your ad across 1000’s of unrelated keywords, labeling them as as “exact match (close variant)” The definition of “close variant” means whatever they want it to and changes constantly. The result is advertisers get billed for clicks that are totally irrelevant to their business and that their targeting settings explicitly forbid Google from targeting. Google does it anyway and there’s no ability to turn this off So now exact match is broad match, and broad match is just meaningless spam This is all very bad for advertisers, but for Google, it allows them to show your ad and bill you for clicks across 1000x more searches that were previously going unmonetized (mainly because they’re garbage queries no one wants) This is how you grow revenue atop declining search volumes Lastly, and perhaps most egregiously, Google quietly stopped respecting budget caps by a factor of 2x. For example campaigns we’ve been running for years with $1000 daily budget caps suddenly began spending $2000+ per day And the extra spend is entirely on the garbage keywords Google arbitrarily throws in as “exact match (close variants)” which have no value to our business, but can’t be turned off Google offers no refunds nor any recourse for overspend or spend on keywords you explicitly did not target These are not the actions of a healthy business. These are the actions of company whose core business is in decline but desperately needs to pump quarterly earnings so Wall Street will continue to fund insane capex while hopefully looking through their rapidly deteriorating negative free cash flow Google operated a benevolent monopoly for the better part of 25 yrs Meaning the value Google captured from Search was but a small fraction of the value it created, and that spread produced a potential energy that justified expectations of high earnings growth far, far into the future This is now no longer the case At the alter of AI capex, Google is sacrificing the golden goose

Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 29

I’m just a tiny minnow trying to run a family business… earlier this year @Google robbed me of close to $1,000 in unauthorized ad spend by 4xing my daily spend budget without my knowledge. I didn’t notice until I saw the charges on my credit card. I contacted them, used their AI and it looked at it and was basically like “yeah you totally got ripped off and here’s how” then proceeded to give me ALL the evidence I needed to prove their “automated system tricked me by offering me a ‘creative’ adjustment to my ad wording that would produce better results… but buried deep in that one click ‘creative optimization’ they 4x’d my daily spending… I contacted their customer support time after time for several weeks, each time simply to be told it was my fault and there’s nothing I could do. Finally after a month of the telling me ‘tough luck’ I filed a dispute with @Chase Business Ink credit card and after another month of going back and forth with them providing all the evidence, they essentially told me Google is to valuable a customer to us and it’s your word against theirs so we’re going to side with them. As much as I look forward to the day google goes bankrupt and has to shut down, the sad reality is the only winners will be the scum management who put all this in motion - they’ll just move on to infect and plunder other companies, while the google shareholders get stuck with the losses.

Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 29

3 months later Google is still doing all these same shenanigans to artificially inflate search rev at the expense of the long term health of the search business (and to the extreme detriment of their advertisers) Google is not slowing down on this at all If anything they’re getting more aggressive with the same highly-extractive, customer-hostile tactics As Google wastes a higher % of each advertiser’s budget on garbage traffic, and makes it harder for the advertiser to stop them from doing that, ROI on ad spend for advertisers mechanically declines What you’re seeing in the data now is simply an increasing % of Google’s advertisers doing the math on their ad spend ROI, and pulling back on spend partially or entirely in response

Post attachment

As someone who has personally spent $500k / mo+ on Google Ads for years, I can tell you with certainty: This revenue growth in Search is artificial & extremely unhealthy for Google’s business long term Search volumes are declining as legacy search is being increasingly cannibalized by non-monetized LLM queries Google’s response? Manufacture revenue growth via short-sighted, highly extractive, customer-hostile tactics. I.e. charge advertisers more for lower quality clicks, including clicks they do not want and explicitly did not approve Google to charge them for A few examples to illustrate: For all of its history until recently, Google operated on a 2nd price auction model I.e. if you bid $5 CPC and the next highest bidder bids $1 CPC, Google charged you $1.01 for the click (one penny more than the 2nd highest bidder) rather than the $5 you bid This was a genius move by Google early on as it incentivizes advertisers to input their true maximum willingness to pay rather than trying to play the game of bidding low and constantly adjusting to try to stay just ahead of the next highest bidder while still not paying too much However recently, Google silently deprecated the 2nd price auction and began charging advertisers as much as their bid and budget caps allow, regardless of what anyone else is bidding It’s a short-sighted cash grab at the expense of the long term health of the advertiser ecosystem Making thing worse, Google also recently nerfed keyword targeting precision Google previously had precise keyword targeting settings that allowed advertisers pick individual search phrases to bid on, defined down to the character w/ exact match or phrase match targeting This was one of the core features that made search advertising magic, enabling advertisers to run extremely precise campaigns based on exactly what their target customer typed But now, even if you bid on a specific term or phrase using the strictest exact -match targeting settings, Google will show your ad across 1000’s of unrelated keywords, labeling them as as “exact match (close variant)” The definition of “close variant” means whatever they want it to and changes constantly. The result is advertisers get billed for clicks that are totally irrelevant to their business and that their targeting settings explicitly forbid Google from targeting. Google does it anyway and there’s no ability to turn this off So now exact match is broad match, and broad match is just meaningless spam This is all very bad for advertisers, but for Google, it allows them to show your ad and bill you for clicks across 1000x more searches that were previously going unmonetized (mainly because they’re garbage queries no one wants) This is how you grow revenue atop declining search volumes Lastly, and perhaps most egregiously, Google quietly stopped respecting budget caps by a factor of 2x. For example campaigns we’ve been running for years with $1000 daily budget caps suddenly began spending $2000+ per day And the extra spend is entirely on the garbage keywords Google arbitrarily throws in as “exact match (close variants)” which have no value to our business, but can’t be turned off Google offers no refunds nor any recourse for overspend or spend on keywords you explicitly did not target These are not the actions of a healthy business. These are the actions of company whose core business is in decline but desperately needs to pump quarterly earnings so Wall Street will continue to fund insane capex while hopefully looking through their rapidly deteriorating negative free cash flow Google operated a benevolent monopoly for the better part of 25 yrs Meaning the value Google captured from Search was but a small fraction of the value it created, and that spread produced a potential energy that justified expectations of high earnings growth far, far into the future This is now no longer the case At the alter of AI capex, Google is sacrificing the golden goose

Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 29

I tried to warn you

Post attachment

As someone who has personally spent $500k / mo+ on Google Ads for years, I can tell you with certainty: This revenue growth in Search is artificial & extremely unhealthy for Google’s business long term Search volumes are declining as legacy search is being increasingly cannibalized by non-monetized LLM queries Google’s response? Manufacture revenue growth via short-sighted, highly extractive, customer-hostile tactics. I.e. charge advertisers more for lower quality clicks, including clicks they do not want and explicitly did not approve Google to charge them for A few examples to illustrate: For all of its history until recently, Google operated on a 2nd price auction model I.e. if you bid $5 CPC and the next highest bidder bids $1 CPC, Google charged you $1.01 for the click (one penny more than the 2nd highest bidder) rather than the $5 you bid This was a genius move by Google early on as it incentivizes advertisers to input their true maximum willingness to pay rather than trying to play the game of bidding low and constantly adjusting to try to stay just ahead of the next highest bidder while still not paying too much However recently, Google silently deprecated the 2nd price auction and began charging advertisers as much as their bid and budget caps allow, regardless of what anyone else is bidding It’s a short-sighted cash grab at the expense of the long term health of the advertiser ecosystem Making thing worse, Google also recently nerfed keyword targeting precision Google previously had precise keyword targeting settings that allowed advertisers pick individual search phrases to bid on, defined down to the character w/ exact match or phrase match targeting This was one of the core features that made search advertising magic, enabling advertisers to run extremely precise campaigns based on exactly what their target customer typed But now, even if you bid on a specific term or phrase using the strictest exact -match targeting settings, Google will show your ad across 1000’s of unrelated keywords, labeling them as as “exact match (close variant)” The definition of “close variant” means whatever they want it to and changes constantly. The result is advertisers get billed for clicks that are totally irrelevant to their business and that their targeting settings explicitly forbid Google from targeting. Google does it anyway and there’s no ability to turn this off So now exact match is broad match, and broad match is just meaningless spam This is all very bad for advertisers, but for Google, it allows them to show your ad and bill you for clicks across 1000x more searches that were previously going unmonetized (mainly because they’re garbage queries no one wants) This is how you grow revenue atop declining search volumes Lastly, and perhaps most egregiously, Google quietly stopped respecting budget caps by a factor of 2x. For example campaigns we’ve been running for years with $1000 daily budget caps suddenly began spending $2000+ per day And the extra spend is entirely on the garbage keywords Google arbitrarily throws in as “exact match (close variants)” which have no value to our business, but can’t be turned off Google offers no refunds nor any recourse for overspend or spend on keywords you explicitly did not target These are not the actions of a healthy business. These are the actions of company whose core business is in decline but desperately needs to pump quarterly earnings so Wall Street will continue to fund insane capex while hopefully looking through their rapidly deteriorating negative free cash flow Google operated a benevolent monopoly for the better part of 25 yrs Meaning the value Google captured from Search was but a small fraction of the value it created, and that spread produced a potential energy that justified expectations of high earnings growth far, far into the future This is now no longer the case At the alter of AI capex, Google is sacrificing the golden goose

Max Anderson avatar
Max Anderson@MaxAnderson·Oct 29

1000% this. Even with competitor names in a negative list I was being charged crazy cost per click for terms that were clearly seeking contact details for that competitor. They were all triggered by exact match and labelled “close variant”. I’ve gave up on google now.