
Melbourne, Australia — Her Honour Vice President Judge Tran held that Mr Tayeh’s initiation of the chant “All Zionists are terrorists” incited hatred against Jewish people on the grounds of race and religious belief

Menachem Vorchheimer is a husband and father of four. He is a passionate advocate for human rights & equality at law for all.

Melbourne, Australia — Her Honour Vice President Judge Tran held that Mr Tayeh’s initiation of the chant “All Zionists are terrorists” incited hatred against Jewish people on the grounds of race and religious belief

WHY I’M IN PREMIER BEN CARROLL’S ELECTORATE I never imagined I’d have to take legal action against my own government to ensure existing laws against antisemitism are enforced Every Victorian deserves to feel safe And when governments fail to protect their citizens, they must be held accountable VICTORIA, IT’S TIME FOR CHANGE

WHY I’M INVESTING MY TIME & MONEY IN CHANGING VICTORIA’S GOVERNMENT As a husband, a father, an eighth-generation Australian & a proud Jew, I never imagined I would have to spend years litigating to secure the protection of laws that already exist Yet that is the reality I face Labor has failed to effectively enforce existing laws against antisemitism. Even after the Bondi massacre, it has failed to adequately confront left-wing extremism & Islamist extremism So I have a choice I can continue spending my time, energy & money litigating against a government & its agencies that fail to enforce existing laws, or I can invest those same resources in changing the government That is why I am spending thousands of dollars of my own money & dedicating significant time to campaigning for change My fight is not just for the Jewish community. It is for ALL Australians, for our collective safety & for the future of our children No Australian should have to resort to litigation to secure the protection of the law. Protecting its citizens is a fundamental responsibility of government I look forward to working constructively with a government that takes that responsibility seriously On 28 November, Victorians have an opportunity to change the direction of our state TOGETHER, we can build a safer Victoria for all. Our collective future is worth standing up for

ELLEN SANDELL & THE GREENS Victorian Greens leader Ellen Sandell pictured alongside Ihab Al Azhari, a Hamas terrorist supporter Al Azhari told a Jewish woman in Melbourne: “7 October is just the bloody beginning of it.” October 7, 2023, was the deadliest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust THE GREENS: A PARTY OF DIVISION, NOT TOLERANCE

VCAT: ANTISEMITIC & PRO-VIOLENT CONDUCT AT RALLIES WAS “OPEN & EXPECTED” WHY DIDN’T POLICE ACT ? In Vorchheimer v Tayeh [2026] VCAT 134, Vice President Judge Tran found that the chant “All Zionists are terrorists” contravened Victoria’s Racial & Religious Tolerance Act 2001. But the significance of the judgment extends beyond the rally on 23 March 2025. At paragraph [117], Judge Tran found: “There was an observable antisemitic and pro-violent presence at the Rally.” Her Honour continued: “Their conduct at this and previous rallies was open and expected.” This is a significant judicial finding. The antisemitic & pro-violent presence was not confined to a single rally The Tribunal also examined statements by Nasser Mashni, President of the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network (APAN), who was MC of the rally At paragraph [91], Judge Tran identified language used by Mr Mashni & Mr Tayeh that may have reinforced antisemitic viewpoints, including longstanding conspiracy theories about Jews These findings raise serious questions about Victoria Police’s repeated decisions to facilitate protests where antisemitic & pro-violent conduct was foreseeable If such conduct was open & expected, why did Victoria Police continue facilitating these protests without effectively enforcing existing laws against unlawful vilification ? That question sits at the heart of my ongoing legal proceedings against Victoria Police - Vorchheimer v Victoria Police (H358/2025) Freedom of protest is fundamental. But it is not a licence to incite hatred The laws existed. Why weren’t they enforced ?

CAULFIELD RIOTS: MEDIATION WITH VICTORIA POLICE FAILS More than three years after approximately 150 Jewish worshippers were forced to evacuate Central Synagogue during Friday night Shabbat prayers, I am still fighting for accountability. Mediation in my VCAT proceeding against Victoria Police (H358/2025 – Vorchheimer v Victoria Police) has broken down. The proceeding concerns allegations that Victoria Police authorised & assisted breaches of Victoria’s Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001. Central to the proceeding is Victoria Police’s role in the events of 10 November 2023, when a pro-Palestinian protest outside Central Synagogue in Caulfield descended into a riot. The settlement of an earlier VCAT proceeding I brought against a protest organiser confirmed that Victoria Police had directed protesters to assemble at Princes Park, directly outside Central Synagogue, & that the protesters had complied with that direction. This was publicly reported by The Australian Jewish News in May 2025. In July 2025, Victoria Police, through its lawyers, made undertakings. Those undertakings have not been honoured. Premier @BenCarrollMP was informed of @VictoriaPolice’s failure to honour those undertakings before mediation broke down. I have seen no evidence that the Premier took steps to ensure Victoria Police kept its word. Three years on, where is the accountability? No Victorian should have to spend years litigating to secure the protection of existing laws. The Jewish community deserves answers. Victoria Police must be held accountable. My pursuit of justice continues @theage @theheraldsun @australian @3AW693 @abcmelbourne

JOHN GANDEL AC: A PROUD JEW. AN EXTRAORDINARY AUSTRALIAN. AN ENDURING LEGACY The son of Polish Jewish immigrants who came to Australia seeking a better life, John Gandel's story is a remarkable example of the opportunities Australia has offered successive generations of migrants & the extraordinary contributions they have made in return Born in Melbourne in 1935, Gandel built upon the modest retail business established by his parents, Sam & Fay Gandel Together with his brother-in-law Marc Besen, he transformed Sussan into one of Australia's leading fashion retail chains In 1983, he acquired Chadstone Shopping Centre for $37 million, transforming it over subsequent decades into Australia's largest shopping centre & one of the world's great retail destinations His achievements in business are extraordinary. But his contribution to Australia extends far beyond his business acumen Together with his wife Pauline, John has helped build one of Australia's most significant family philanthropic foundations, distributing more than $250 million to charitable causes Their generosity has touched the lives of Australians from every background From the Alfred Hospital & medical research to the National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne Museum & State Library Victoria, their philanthropy has strengthened institutions that serve millions of Australians Their support for children's education, disadvantaged communities & Indigenous opportunities, including scholarships honouring Aboriginal activist William Cooper, reflects a deep commitment to building a better Australia for everyone At the same time, their unwavering commitment to Jewish identity, education & Holocaust remembrance has helped preserve the history & traditions of Australian Jewry, while educating future generations about the consequences of hatred & intolerance There is something profoundly Australian about that legacy John & Pauline have demonstrated that pride in one's Jewish heritage & devotion to Australia are not competing identities. They are complementary, enriching both the Jewish community & Australian society as a whole Their generosity transcends religion, ethnicity & background. It reflects the Jewish tradition of tzedakah - the responsibility to help others - expressed through a lifelong commitment to the country they call home John Gandel's legacy is not simply measured by the businesses he built or the wealth he created, but by the institutions he has strengthened, the opportunities he has opened & the countless lives he & Pauline have enriched A proud Jew. An extraordinary Australian A powerful example of how immigrant families, while preserving their heritage & identity, can enrich the nation they call home & help build a stronger, more generous & more inclusive Australia for generations to come

FROM ST KILDA TO FRANKSTON: VICTORIANS HAVE HAD ENOUGH I’ve spent the week speaking with people across Melbourne From antisemitism to youth crime, I keep hearing the same message: the government has failed to enforce existing laws & Victorians are paying the price Every Victorian deserves to feel safe On 28 November, Victorians have the power to force change @theage @theheraldsun @australian @3AW693 @abcmelbourne

WHAT HAPPENED TO HONEST & TRANSPARENT GOVERNMENT? Government decisions affect our safety, our families & our cost of living Freedom of information laws help us scrutinise those decisions The law generally requires a decision within 30 days Yet the Office of the Victorian Information Commissioner recorded breaches across 48 Victorian agencies Victoria Police was among the worst offenders. In the delayed cases examined by OVIC, the average time taken to provide a decision was 455 days 30 DAYS REQUIRED BY LAW. 455 DAYS IN REALITY. How can the Government claim to be honest & transparent when the public is left waiting for answers ? @theage @theheraldsun @australian @3AW693 @abcmelbourne

WHAT IS BEN CARROLL TRYING TO HIDE? I sought government briefings on antisemitism, the racist chant “All Zionists are Terrorists” & enforcement of Victoria’s vilification laws. 30 relevant documents identified. 21 withheld entirely. Just ONE released in full. Antisemitism surged in Victoria under Labor. The public deserves to know what advice the government received & how it responded. @BenCarrollMP, Victorians deserve answers @theheraldsun @theage @aus_jewishnews @australian

.@ellensandell @BenCarrollMP care to comment
“DEATH TO AUSTRALIA”: LABOR MUST CONDEMN LEFT-WING EXTREMISM “Death to Australia.” “Death to One Nation.” “Die Pauline.” These are the chants in the accompanying footage from a protest in Melbourne Whatever your opinion of Pauline Hanson or One Nation, calls for death directed at political opponents should appal anyone who believes in democracy Labor, the Greens & Socialists must unequivocally condemn these chants & confront left-wing extremism wherever it appears - including within their own ranks Political loyalty must never come before the responsibility to challenge threats & intimidation The standard cannot depend on who is chanting or who is being targeted

MY FOI REQUEST TO VICTORIA’S DEPARTMENT OF PREMIER & CABINET: 30 RELEVANT DOCUMENTS IDENTIFIED. JUST ONE RELEASED IN FULL. IS THIS LABOR’S TRANSPARENCY ? I asked the Department of Premier & Cabinet for briefings about antisemitism, protest activity, the racist chant “All Zionists are Terrorists” & the enforcement of Victoria’s racial & religious vilification laws The department identified 30 relevant documents: • 21 withheld entirely • Eight released only in part • Just ONE released in full The material supplied contains extensive redactions, including entire blocks of pages. These are matters of public safety, government accountability & the protection of Jewish Victorians. The public deserves to understand what advice the government received & how it responded. Premier @BenCarrollMP how does withholding so much information square with honest, transparent government ? Victorians deserve answers

VICTORIA’S FUTURE IS WORTH SHOWING UP FOR I’m investing my time, energy & money in helping build a safer, stronger Victoria Yesterday I was out in Elsternwick, Ormond, Bentleigh & Caulfield, doing my part I believe democracy works best when we participate - when we speak up, contribute & hold those in power accountable My choice is to turn concern into constructive action. Every Australian deserves safety, honest government & respect for their hard-earned money We each have a voice & a vote. Together, we can make a difference If you’d like brochures or stickers to help spread the message, DM me for a pack

“DEATH TO AUSTRALIA”: LABOR MUST CONDEMN LEFT-WING EXTREMISM “Death to Australia.” “Death to One Nation.” “Die Pauline.” These are the chants in the accompanying footage from a protest in Melbourne Whatever your opinion of Pauline Hanson or One Nation, calls for death directed at political opponents should appal anyone who believes in democracy Labor, the Greens & Socialists must unequivocally condemn these chants & confront left-wing extremism wherever it appears - including within their own ranks Political loyalty must never come before the responsibility to challenge threats & intimidation The standard cannot depend on who is chanting or who is being targeted

Lest we forget
Today I joined @SouthwickMP & our community at Caulfield RSL to mark Remembrance Day. We paused to honour all Australians who served our nation & remember those who gave their lives For me, remembrance is also personal. Members of my own family & the wider Jewish community served Australia with dedication & pride. Their service forms part of our shared Australian story We honour their sacrifice, remember the families who bore its cost & carry their memory forward Lest we forget

BIG BUILD SCANDAL: SHOULD ALLAN LOSE HER PENSION? The royal commission has heard claims the CFMEU boasted of a “direct line” to @JacintaAllan’s office Her reported taxpayer-funded pension exceeds $300,000 a year - for life Corporate executives can face clawbacks & personal liability for serious misconduct. Should the same principle apply to politicians ? If Allan & other @VictorianLabor ministers are found to have enabled the misuse of taxpayer funds, should they be forced to repay Victorians & forfeit their pensions & other taxpayer-funded benefits ? Public office should carry personal accountability @theheraldsun @theage @australian @3AW693 @abcmelbourne @DHughesy