←
Gautam Menon20,306 posts
Gautam Menon avatar

Gautam Menon

@MenonBioPhysics

Prof. Physics & Biology | Biophysics, epidemiology, sci-comm, climate change | Cats | Music | He/Him | Ashoka U | Lancet Comm| My views, not my employers

◷ Joined September 2018▧ 535 Photos and videos
Media Lens avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Media Lens@medialens·8h

The @SkyNews interviewer @WilfredFrost says here that the ICC (he presumably means the ICJ) has not definitely concluded that Israel is committing genocide. As noted by @FranceskAlbs, the UN Special Rapporteur on Palestine, this point is regularly misrepresented by establishment media. In January 2024, in response to a detailed submission from South Africa, the International Court of Justice issued a landmark preliminary ruling that there was a ‘plausible risk’ of genocide. Albanese has consistently explained that the 1948 Genocide Convention establishes three obligations that derive from such a ruling: to prevent, halt and prosecute the crime of genocide. In other words, states must *immediately* take all measures possible to stop genocide from occurring on receiving notice of the risk that it is happening. medialens.substack.com/p/med…

.@ZackPolanski says the word genocide Frost intervenes & later in the interview he intervenes again So Zack says: "We do say Russias committing war crimes, we say that all the time & no-one pushes back.." According to Frost thats because Russia has been more closely monitored

0:51
Ashoka University avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Ashoka University@AshokaUniv·12h

India’s higher education ambitions will be decided by who it can attract to teach. Ashish Dhawan (@AshishDhawanTCF) and Pramath Raj Sinha (@PramathSinha), Founders, Ashoka University, argue that while world-class institutions need infrastructure and capital, the limiting factor is exceptional faculty. ‘India’s ambition rests on the institutions it builds, and those institutions rest on the people inside them. That talent exists. Some of it is here, some of it is abroad, and all of it has to be sought out. We have to venture out, find them, and offer an environment that meets what they fairly expect and what we can with total conviction deliver,’ they write. Read more: hindustantimes.com/opinion/w… (@htTweets) #AshokaUniversity

Ghida Fakhry avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Ghida Fakhry@ghida_fakhry·Nov 17

A question from @CaroleCadwalladr that deserves much more attention: ‘the absolutely baffling lack of solidarity’ among journalists with their colleagues in Gaza and Lebanon who have been ‘targeted and killed’. The explanation offered is ‘fear’. Maybe. But that doesn’t make the silence any less damning. Journalists are being killed for doing their jobs and bearing witness. This should matter to all of us in this profession. It goes to the heart of journalism: reporting without fear or favour. And without discrimination.

Former BBC HARDtalk presenter Stephen Sackur told Carole Cadwalladr that the fear of Israeli messaging influences the Western media's silence on the killings of Palestinian journalists. Citing +972 Magazine’s investigations, Sackur pointed out evidence that Israeli intelligence has planted false narratives linking Palestinian journalists in Gaza to Hamas to “justify their killings,” adding that this manipulation has significantly affected how the Western media has covered the genocide in Gaza.

1:51
S.R.Praveen avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
S.R.Praveen@myopiclenses·Nov 16

Banana republic, where you are forced to eat banana...for all meat is banned. For nearly four decades, a cluster of licensed restaurants along the Veraval–Una state highway in Gujarat’s Gir Somnath district quietly cooked, plated and sold meat, fish and eggs to local fishermen, industrial workers, and passing travelers. Their kitchens were tucked behind closed doors, their municipal trade permits were in order and their food safety registrations were valid. Then, on August 10, 2026, the district magistrate decided that the mere existence of these menus constituted an intolerable assault on the religious sensibilities of pilgrims visiting the Somnath Temple. By administrative fiat, he banned the preparation, storage and sale of all non-vegetarian food within 500 metres of the shrine and across six major arterial stretches, reaching restaurants located nearly 2 km away from the shrine. The episode lays bare a peculiar transformation in Indian governance. A pilgrim’s personal dietary preference has been elevated into a public order mandate, enforced by police statutes and rubber-stamped by courts reluctant to stand in the way of majoritarian comfort. barandbench.com/columns/liti…

Gautam Menon avatar
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·Nov 16

Indeed, a very important point.

An academic journal's purpose is not a validation system for hiring, promotions & research funding, but the means to communicate science or ideas; the pursuit of knowledge knows no borders. Institutions must make their own quality assessments of the research, of those they judge

Jonathan Cook avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Jonathan Cook@Jonathan_K_Cook·Nov 16

How western broadcasters did Israel's dirty work after Oct 2023, laundering its genocide by suggesting the mass slaughter of Palestinians we were all watching might not be happening. Read more here: newscord.org/editorials/hama…

Post attachment
Outbreak Updates avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Outbreak Updates@outbreakupdates·Nov 16

India went from nearly zero to overtaking the United States in measles vaccination. America went from leading the world to debating whether preventing measles is a good idea.

Post attachment
Dr. Ezzideen avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Dr. Ezzideen@ezzingaza·Nov 15

During World War II, American aircraft bombed civilian neighborhoods in Germany, killing nearly half a million German civilians. Later, in defending these attacks, the United States justified the bombing of civilian populations as a means of breaking German society’s morale. Another argument used to justify such attacks was that the German people’s silence under Hitler amounted to approval of his policies, and that they therefore deserved to be punished. Yet many historians have challenged this reasoning. Not everyone who lived under Hitler was a Nazi, and not everyone who remained silent supported him. Still, that distinction did nothing to protect civilians from the bombs. And yesterday, former German Chancellor Angela Merkel revived this same line of reasoning while defending Israel’s policies toward civilians in Gaza, pointing to the lack of widespread public opposition to Hamas within Gaza in the context of her remarks about Israel’s war. And here is my question: What exactly is a civilian supposed to do to deserve protection? Must he take to the streets and confront an armed authority? Must he publicly declare his opposition in front of cameras? Must he prove to the world that he resisted hard enough before his death becomes worthy of condemnation? I am from Gaza, and I know that opposing Hamas is not an abstract political position. I know that expressing such opposition publicly can carry very real risks. I also know that Palestinians have criticized Hamas, both before and during the war. Some have even paid with their lives for doing so, even if their voices never reached Mrs. Merkel. But more importantly, I cannot understand why we should have to pass this test in the first place. A German child should never have had to prove that he opposed Hitler to avoid being killed beneath the rubble of his home. And a Palestinian child should not have to prove that his family opposed Hamas in order to deserve to live. We can discuss the responsibility of governments and armed groups. We can criticize them, condemn their actions, and demand that they be held accountable. But the moment we begin measuring civilians’ right to life by how much they resisted those who governed them, we cross a dangerous line: we stop holding those in power accountable and begin holding their victims responsible for the violence inflicted upon them. And what pains me most is hearing this reasoning, even by implication, from a German political figure who, of all people, should understand where the idea of treating an entire population as collectively guilty can lead. A civilian should not need a certificate of political good conduct to deserve protection from bombs.

Gautam Menon avatar
Gautam Menon@MenonBioPhysics·Nov 15

The level of outright evil is disconcerting.

Daniella Weiss Tells Piers Morgan that Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza Belongs Only to Jews, Citing Biblical Joshua on Palestinians' Fate. Piers Morgan: But actually, actually what's happening is you want to take their land, isn't it? Daniella Weiss: Okay, so you make your position I make mine and the world will judge. And uh I mean you know, it's interesting that uh when there are historical facts that can be proven and then you still you cling to what? I really don't understand what history you represent. Piers Morgan: Well, just taking you well, taking taking well, Ms. Weiss, taking your argument to its logical extension, then you believe that that Israelis and Jewish people should be entitled to all of the West Bank and all of Gaza. If it's your land as you say. Daniella Weiss: Not just all of the West Bank. It's not bank. Bank is a narrow place. It's the major part of the area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. Piers Morgan: So you would like just to be clear. Just to be clear, you would like all of the land from the river to the sea, to be Israeli Jewish, yeah? Daniella Weiss: I want on the land, all the land from the Euphrates to the Nile. What do you mean? Why hide the Piers Morgan: I'm just curious what you I'm curious what you intend to do with all the Palestinians who currently live there? Daniella Weiss: Those, you see, I have, I trust, in God I trust. And I live by faith, by emunah and by the Bible. Piers Morgan: Yeah, what are you going to do with all the millions of Palestinians? What what happens Daniella Weiss: I'm telling you what Joshua, what Joshua, Joshua, the first settlers, he gave me the the Piers Morgan: I don't need a history lesson, I'm just asking you, what do you intend to do with the millions of Palestinians who currently live in Gaza and the West Bank? Daniella Weiss: Exactly what Joshua did

1:49
Soutik Biswas avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Soutik Biswas@soutikBBC·Nov 14

.@pbmehta: Rather than asking the question — what would it take to live in an environment where burning firecrackers did not badly affect our health — we think of the ban itself as a kind of curse that will destroy our civilisation. indianexpress.com/article/op…

Alex Crawford avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Alex Crawford@AlexCrawfordSky·Nov 15

Points ignored in the Israeli Foreign ministry statement: Israel as the occupying power is responsible for the welfare of the population of Gaza under international law. The EU, the UN and aid agencies are all saying humanitarian supplies of sufficient numbers are not being allowed in by Israel which controls all entry points into Gaza. The number of trucks doesn’t differentiate between commercial and aid trucks which the UN points out are only a fraction. About 3.6 million people in Gaza need help. Israeli bombing has destroyed sewage and drainage works and 90% of the territory’s health infrastructure. That’s the definition of unbalanced

The EU’s statement is completely unbalanced and rewards Hamas’s refusal to disarm, as mandated by the Peace Plan. The statement ignores the unprecedented humanitarian effort led by the Board of Peace and facilitated by Israel. So far, more than 93,000 tents and over 8,600 trucks carrying winter supplies and essential equipment have entered Gaza. It also ignores Hamas’s continuous abuse of hospitals for terror operations and its diversion of humanitarian aid to military infrastructure. The EU should demand that Hamas disarm immediately, so that Gaza is demilitarized and reconstruction can begin.

Jake Dunning avatar
⟳ Gautam Menon retweeted
Jake Dunning@OutbreakJake·Nov 15

This graph speaks volumes and should be cause for concern, globally.

Post attachment