
11/11 To be clear, we’re not saying all partisan disagreement is illusory. But our data suggest that the epic battle over “capitalism” vs. “socialism” is, to a large extent, a fight over labels.

Tweets from the labs of Joshua Greene and Fiery Cushman

11/11 To be clear, we’re not saying all partisan disagreement is illusory. But our data suggest that the epic battle over “capitalism” vs. “socialism” is, to a large extent, a fight over labels.

10/11 This isn’t just an American quirk. In Study 5, we replicated the core pattern in Brazil: both sides broadly liked the hybrid system, but self-described capitalists called it capitalist, and socialists called it socialist.

9/11 They also became more willing to support outparty candidates who back a safety net, public education, progressive taxes, and regulations that protect consumers and the environment. Effects held for both parties, and many lasted a month.

8/11 Does revealing this hidden agreement help? In Study 4, we told people about our previous findings. This made both Republicans and Democrats more likely to see the other party as sharing their economic goals.

7/11 People don’t realize this. Democrats estimated that ~39% of Republicans would like the hybrid system (actual: 69%). Republicans estimated that ~74% of Democrats would like it (actual: 97%).

6/11 So where’s the disagreement? In the labels. Both sides agreed on which extreme system was “capitalist” and which was “socialist.” But for the hybrid system, capitalists called it more capitalist, and socialists called it more socialist (or a mix).

5/11 We also described an extremely capitalist system (no safety net, no redistribution) and an extremely socialist one (the government controls production and decides where people live and work). Both sides preferred the hybrid over either extreme.

4/11 Both sides liked it: 97% of Democrats and 69% of Republicans approved. One Republican said it's “the closest thing to a democracy where a country succeeds economically.” A Democrat called it “as close to a perfect society as one could hope for.”

3/11 We showed Americans a hybrid economic system: a competitive free market, regulated to prevent monopolies and corruption; protections for consumers and the environment; and progressive taxes funding education and a safety net (food, clean water, basic healthcare, shelter).

2/11 Polls show a stark divide: most Democrats view socialism favorably; most Republicans view it unfavorably and prefer capitalism. Politicians on both sides fan the flames. But do Americans disagree about how the economy should work, or just what to call it?

New paper in @NatureComms by Lucas Woodley and Joshua Greene: Americans appear deeply divided over “capitalism” vs. “socialism.” But across a series of studies, we find that this divide is largely illusory. doi.org/10.1038/s41467-026-7… 🧵 1/11

New episode! Harvard's Josh Greene joins the show to talk about applying his moral psych research to change the real world, including @GiveMultiplier, a donation platform that encourages higher-impact giving. Plus: is Josh a moral realist?share.fireside.fm/episode/Ah…

J.Greene interviewed on Amanda Knox's "Hard Knox" podcast. Listen here: amandaknox.substack.com/p/ho…
🎙️ Our co-founder, Harvard psychologist Joshua Greene, joins Amanda Knox (@amandaknox) on the latest Hard Knox podcast. They cover the neuroscience of moral decision-making, bridging political divides, and the science behind Giving Multiplier. Link below👇

J.Greene interviewed on @WBUR's Here & Now (@hereandnow) about how an online trivia game he co-founded called "Tango" bridges political divides: wbur.org/hereandnow/2026/06/…

The Perverse Tyranny of a Perfect Transcript - In The Atlantic, my collague Josh Greene makes the case for why not every Harvard student should get an A in every course. theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/0…

New op-ed from J.Greene in @TheAtlantic today on Harvard's grade inflation problem: theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/0…
“Putting a perfect GPA in reach of so many students perversely deters them from taking classes that could threaten it,” Harvard professor Joshua Greene argues. “We should liberate our students from the tyranny of the impeccable transcript”: theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/0…