←
Nandini187,569 posts
Nandini avatar

Nandini

@NBDwrites

Traveler. Observer. Invested. Naam-Namak-Nishaan.

◷ Joined November 2013▧ 3,458 Photos and videos
Nandini avatar
Nandini@NBDwrites·Apr 27

Anatomy of An Indian Liberal Pre – 2014 ~ Class~ Privileged ~First Language~ English ~Religious Denomination~ Convenient Atheist... Except Grihaparveshs, Naamkarans, Weddings, Cremations. when every ceremony old & forgotten is dredged out, flaunted. ~Celebrations~ Eid, Easter, Christmas, Diwali, Holi… ~Food Habits~ Private ~ Personal Statement ~Ram Guha thinks. Therefore, I am. Romilla Thapar thought. Therefore, I was. The Mughals gave us art, culture, architecture, cuisine & the Brits gave us English, railways & Nehru. ~ The Beauty of Poverty ~Knowledge of India extends to 4 people in the servant quarters, Goa which tragically is losing its Portuguese flavour & our hills which no longer remind one of Scotland. ~ Syncretic Culture ~Bound by single malt, kababs at Karim’s, Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Joy to the World … ~ Social Register ~Ticked off as ARRIVED if nephew’s wife’s brother connected to the NAC and/or runs a NGO. ~ Lexicon ~The vulgar includes a few French terms with Fcuk. Never the vernacular even at the most vilest. ~ Mission Statement ~People Like Us Are In Charge. So, The World Is Beautiful.…

Amit Kumar Sindhi avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Amit Kumar Sindhi@AMIT_GUJJU·10h

Rahul Gandhi really needs to stop pretending to be a philosopher. The more he tries to sound deep, the more ridiculous he sounds. Does he even understand what he's saying? 😂

1:16
Prachi Bora avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Prachi Bora@HokiePrachi·9h

You think it’s family pressure? I used to, I no longer do…

Prachi Bora @HokiePrachi Mar 16 Article Lost causes have a way of pulling at the wise and weary In my younger days, I was convinced RG was trapped in politics purely under family pressure. As so often happens in Indian households: the weight of legacy, parental expectations, the unspoken rules

Eli Afriat 🇮🇱 avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Eli Afriat 🇮🇱@EliAfriatISR·Nov 16

Very Powerful. Listen to Fauda actor and writer Lior Raz—this is a must-watch.

2:10
Nandini avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Nandini@NBDwrites·16h

This morning, I woke up at night to discover that the Gandhi acolytes are still translating English into English, pushing increasingly wilder interpretations, broad-brushing cultures, people and understanding, also desperately throwing in celestial examples for good measure. The point isn’t that a 56-year-old man, who also happens to be the LoP, revealed this ‘cute’ little titbit about his Mamma and Papa. It is *where* he chose to do so. And once he did, he opened himself up to opinion, criticism, horror, amusement - and everything in between. But koi na. The Translator Brigade is ready to make it worse.

Nandini avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Nandini@NBDwrites·Nov 17

Every time Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra invoke their grandmother Indira Gandhi’s assassination, they should remember that theirs was not the only family to suffer. Thousands of Hindus and Sikhs lost their lives in the violence that preceded and followed it. They should also remember the soldiers who entered the Golden Temple with one hand tied behind their backs, conscious of the sanctity of this hallowed space, desecrated by the very Bhindranwale and his armed followers whom their grandmother’s political choices had helped create, and whom the soldiers were eventually sent in to confront. Every time they speak of the trauma of their father Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination, they should spare a thought for the children who lost their fathers in the ill-fated IPKF mission in Sri Lanka, and for the families whose loved ones were killed in the suicide bombing that took his life. They have spoken of forgiveness for the killers and conspirators. But did they ever seek to understand the trauma of others who lost their loved ones? Did their grief matter as much? Did their children deserve the same acknowledgement? The appropriation of grief, as though suffering were unique to their family, is deeply insensitive to the countless other families who continue to live with these losses. And when that grief is repeatedly invoked as political capital, it becomes even harder to accept. The Gandhi family was not the only one that paid a price. Surely, that too is worth remembering.

Dinesh Bakshi🇮🇳 avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Dinesh Bakshi🇮🇳@Dinesh_Bakshi·Nov 17

Spot on @NBDwrites . Every single point here nails the state of our prime-time media ecosystem. Across almost every major network—whether it’s NDTV, CNN-News18, or Times Now—there is a predictable pattern. You can almost always count on one or two anchors on every channel who function as the exact equivalents of Rajdeep Sardesai or Preeti Choudhry of India Today: essentially covert Congress spokespersons masquerading as neutral journalists with a common hatred for PM Narendra Modi ji! (can name some across channels, but don't need to, people know) Instead of asking tough questions about accountability, governance, or the parallel power structures run through the #NAC during the #UPA decade, they pivot straight to soft-focus nostalgia. Reducing a decade of unchecked political influence to harmless stories about family recipes and personal aesthetics isn't just lazy journalism—it’s deliberate image management. When anchors spend more time romanticising a political dynasty’s lifestyle than interrogating their actual record in power, it proves how deeply entrenched that old ecosystem still is in our newsrooms. And you’re completely right about the panel chaos, when the moderators themselves lack the discipline or intent to hold power to account, shouting matches are the inevitable result and it's in these editor panels that the divide of Bhakt (Godi) vs Darbaari (Chamcha) media becomes so starkly obvious!

Now, having watched anchors from @NDTV @CNNnews18 @TimesNow discuss Sonia Gandhi’s Belonging, here are a few takeaways. 1. There is at least one anchor on every channel’s panel who seems positively dazzled by the Gandhi family’s food, tastes, sensibilities and domestic anecdotes. Far too enamoured of the people to examine their politics. 2. Most struggle to explain away glaring omissions by taking refuge in that supposedly subtle distinction between a memoir and an autobiography. These ‘political’ journalists seem to overlook one rather important fact: Sonia Gandhi was, for a decade, arguably the most powerful *extra-constitutional* authority in this country. She presided over a government that was ostensibly a parliamentary democracy, while exercising enormous influence through an extra-constitutional body, the NAC. Power without direct accountability. Influence without constitutional responsibility. She was not merely a bahu who found herself having to run a household in the aftermath of tragic circumstances. She was a political actor who consciously assumed the reins of power, without holding constitutional office, and exercised extraordinary influence over the governance of a country of over a billion people. The country’s future was, in many ways, treated as though it were hers to shape and dispense with. 3. To dismiss this book as her ‘prerogative’, reduce it to a simple narrative of a love story, family and personal experiences, is precisely the problem. It is this very framing that helps explain how she could exercise such extraordinary power while remaining largely insulated from scrutiny. Yes, the Gandhis occupy a unique space in our political landscape. But perhaps the more uncomfortable question is: why? Is it because, even decades after Independence, we remain mentally shackled? Still colonised in our imagination? Still predisposed to treating one political family as royalty, whose private world deserves reverence rather than scrutiny? And I think I now understand why panelists are allowed to overspeak and interrupt one another. Left to themselves, these anchors do exactly the same thing.

Nandini avatar
Nandini@NBDwrites·Nov 17

It seems handles with 1-30 followers have been activated to respond to my posts. All begin with Auntyjee, have Gobar in the next sentence and Your Paw-Paw after that… with that limited vocabulary they are defending a book.

Nandini avatar
Nandini@NBDwrites·Nov 17

Everything was going pretty okay till he got up to speak 🤦🏻‍♀️😅🤦🏻‍♀️

Nandini avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Nandini@NBDwrites·Nov 17

God! What sort of homes must you have grown up in for every idiotic anecdote from Rahul to require such an impassioned defence?

If Rahul Gandhi had said his father made sure his mother served him food, cleared his plates, or ate off his used plate, and occasionally yelled at her for cooking bad food, I guess all these people would have happy and celebrated family values. 🙌

Manoj Kilam avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Manoj Kilam@kilammanoj·Nov 17

Well said. With Sonia Gandhi’s new book hitting the shelves, it’s the exact same script—turning decades of political blunders and the collateral damage suffered by soldiers and civilians into a curated personal love story. Selective memory at its finest.

Sunny Pullambil avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Sunny Pullambil@sunnybawachi·Nov 17

Yes. Tragedies like their assassinations were tied to specific domestic&foreign policy decisions (such as handling of Punjab crisis or intervention in Sri Lanka) rather than acts of intentional martyrdom,& that personal grief should not be substituted for political accountability

Akshay avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
Akshay@Ank_Akshay·Nov 17

They knew they were going out of power in 2014 but they probably expected that people would come right back to them eventually. But that hope as a plan isn’t working so they keep dipping their fingers in Nostalgia and still hope people will come back like the old days They are so disconnected from the aspirational India of today they think playing nostalgic videos n talking about their glory days will bring them back somehow. Not realising the point you just made about how rest of India experienced those days

JAYANTH 🇮🇳 ಜಯಂತ್ avatar
⟳ Nandini retweeted
JAYANTH 🇮🇳 ಜಯಂತ್@JAYANTH_66·Nov 17

In India, political families become symbols. Their personal loss becomes national memory.For families who lost someone in the same events, that can feel like erasure.A soldier who died in Jaffna or a Sikh shopkeeper killed in Trilokpuri in 84 doesn't get a foundation in his name.