The Priests, the Witch and the Wardrobe (John S. Daly)
Is Christian allegory a problem in literature – and can Catholics read C.S. Lewis’ ‘Chronicles of Narnia’?
wmreview.org/p/priests-witch…
Everyone thought Bionicle would lead to the Fourth Reich whilst they slept on Gender Bent Draco Malfoy. The true return of national socialism. Malfoid will usher in Hitler 2.
Rockstar: "No you can't hire prostitutes anymore - that's gross. But you can manually paint walls - that's neat!"
Gamers: "What in the woke is this?"
Me:
I've been in the creative industry, I know exactly why this is. Most writers are nepobabies with no life experience or interest in genre fiction whatsoever. But they keep getting given science fiction and fantasy jobs. Then they get annoyed they have to respect continuity. Because all they wanted to write was an oscar-bait film about someone in the real world doing real world things. And they think they're the greatest writers in the world who are denigrating themselves doing genre fiction.
Honestly it’s insane seeing how little writers care about world building and cohesive plot/character progression. You take one look at modern main stream media and if you don’t just turn your brain off and watch colors on the screen you see how far and few between the genuinely good stories there are.
I promise you guys faithfully, Hermione will have gone through an incredible amount of character development and will in fact find real love beyond her obsession with Harry.
I want to write an actual story with growth, yearning, and romance. You just want moments of anime inspired drama with no understanding of first, second or third order effects on that story and characters. Because you aren't an author and you aren't writing a book to understand why an out of character moment is wrong. And how wrong it'd be by book 6 of a 7 book saga. Regardless of anything I could write. It's creepy and weird to demand that the turning point of a relationship be an act of horrific violence that somehow leads to romance. Relationships are defined by love. Not pain and abuse. And this becomes incredibly obvious if you've ever had sex. Let alone a romantic relationship with a woman. Ask your wife/girlfriend if you don't believe me. You have one, right?
Also if I was only tangentally interested in Malfoid I wouldn't have committed myself to a 7 book rewrite for free when I'm otherwise a professional writer IRL. But saying what you've said, where's your seven book rewrite that holds more faithfully to Rowling's canon? I'm posting Chapter 5 of Book 4 today. What about you?
It is not surprising that this is a point on which two who have… a very tangential interest in the extant canon and fitting Malfoid into it (despite that being the whole thing, one change that adds mythic romance and redemption to the saga)… agree on.
And yes sectumsempra has to happen just like John and Jane Smith had to nearly kill each other
I'm on the side of including Sectumsempra, ONLY for when Harry has NO IDEA what it does, and is desperate enough to use any spell to stop Dracina from fighting.
And those who favor the plot of her "Scars" rendering her infertile are fucking retarded for many reasons.