
Interesting as ever from Joe. I’d add that in the ‘PDEL’ world the Treasury should insist that actual savings numbers are baked into departmental settlements now. Otherwise this just becomes a ratchet. OBR will also need to agree with estimates on ‘fiscal offsets’
It's going to be interesting to see the Treasury handling of these recommendations, and this is a great case study of how spending decisions are made. Every reform package promises upfront costs and future savings - this one is no exception. I worked on several in government. But HMT civil servants know that often the savings never manifest as planned, after they've already committed to the extra spending - the nightmare scenario. A few options they have to control the impact on the public finances (not mutually exclusive): - Expect a greater cost-saving ration than 1:1 - given the state of the public finances, the Government should be trying to extract significant net savings vs the forecast. Of course, the approach to getting there will likely involve cycling some of the AME savings into DEL spending, but it being cost neutral is a bad outcome - it heaps all the financial risk on the Government, they only face downside. - Make clear in the response that the new spending won't be committed until the changes have been legislated for in their entirety - and hold this line throughout the passage through Parliament. - Dig in and say no to the 'guarantee' parts of the scheme - these considerably exacerbate the spending risk, and get us into dangerous new legal territory where NEETs and campaigners could challenge the government in the courts for a whole set of new entitlements. - Demand ironclad commitments on a specific and robust gating and eligibility for the additional Cost Allowance, the Severe and Complex Needs Insurance and the Health and Disability Funds, set out in the response and then protected through Parliament. A big risk to the Milburn recommendations is that these pots just replace PIP and UC health, and in the case of the SDI (where it's briefed that entitlements will be much higher) actually increase spending on net. - Require all assessments to be done face to face. There's evidence that the move to remote assessments has driven up benefits spending. - Set clear incentives for locally run Youth Opportunity Services. If I was still working in Horse Guards Road I'd be worried that different regions will follow poorly-evidenced approaches to getting young people into work, showing they've met the 'guarantee' but not actually delivering results, piling more pressure onto DWP's AME budget. This would be the worst kind of devolution - much more new funding to spend on local schemes, with all the risk of those going wrong held in Whitehall.












