←
Sammy14,870 posts
Sammy avatar

Sammy

@NeuroSGS

Neuroscientist (PhD). Research interests include sex differences, dementia, sleep/circadian rhythms, and neuroimmunology.

◷ Joined March 2009▧ 1,024 Photos and videos
Sammy avatar
Sammy@NeuroSGS·24 Jul 2022

My pinned thread of threads, primarily containing citations and explanations about neurological/ psychological sex differences, sexuality, gender dysphoria, and other academic research interests of mine:

Sammy avatar
Sammy@NeuroSGS·3h

For those who answered ‘No’: Do you think someone without a scientific degree or formal research experience can develop the technical expertise necessary to critically evaluate scientific literature, and get into the nitty gritty of the methodology, techniques, types of analysis, and why/how these can effect results?

Micah G. Allen avatar
⟳ Sammy retweeted
Micah G. Allen@micahgallen·7h

A meta-analysis of 912 neuroimaging studies finds no single core brain region or network underlying the self, challenging the prevailing view of a shared cortical midline or insular anchor. Instead, self-related processing emerges from contextually determined, shifting coalitions of distributed brain systems, suggesting that selfhood is defined by dynamic configuration rather than a fixed neural substrate. biorxiv.org/content/10.64898…

Post attachment
Sammy avatar
Sammy@NeuroSGS·3h

Do you think someone needs a scientific degree or formal research experience to have a valid opinion on a scientific topic? (Answer based on your qualification status)

Sammy avatar
Sammy@NeuroSGS·Nov 17

The data on the biological/genetic mechanisms for gender dysphoria are NOT well understood. The data we do have are confounded, un-replicable, small in scope, and low-quality.

Jk Rowling is wrong. Being transgender is biological. Ask google- ask AI even ask a biologist. Get them to explain to you why and then come back to me. It’s the same reason men have nipples. Fetus developed with hormones from the mother.

Sammy avatar
Sammy@NeuroSGS·Nov 17

Just got accepted for my first post-doc at the University of Cambridge 🥳🥳🥳 So happy 😃

Sammy avatar
⟳ Sammy retweeted
Sammy@NeuroSGS·Nov 14

I watched this debate with @BillboardChris and wanted to address the first persons concern regarding the “androgen receptor polymorphism” being the absolute cause of gender dysphoria (GD), in which they state “this was found in every trans person they’ve tested ever” (see full video linked below). Firstly, what are they talking about? The androgen receptor (AR) mediates the downstream effects of testosterone (T). The AR gene contains a variable-length CAG repeat sequence, with longer (more) repeats generally associated with reduced AR transcriptional activity (ability to regulate other genes). As T is evident in brain masculinisation, researchers have investigated CAG repeat sequences in GD. Some studies (as those mentioned in the video) have reported longer CAG repeats in trans women, suggesting reduced androgen sensitivity. According to this model, we’d see longer CAG repeats, less AR activity in utero, less brain masculinisation, and thus an adult “female gender identity”. However, there are many issues with this model (and how the person in the video describes the data). Firstly, the association itself is massively inconsistent. While some studies report longer CAG repeats in trans women (Hare et al., 2009), others find no significant difference (Fernández et al., 2014; Foreman et al., 2019). Even the meta-analyses disagree on whether an association exists (not a great starting point). Perhaps more intriguing is that a recent meta-analysis reported longer CAG repeats in both trans women AND trans men compared to control men. This is extremely difficult to reconcile with a model in which reduced AR activity specifically contributes to the development of a female gender identity. Why would less AR activity (i.e., less masculinisation) promote a “male gender identity”. Secondly, even if we take the significant group differences at face value, how well does CAG repeat length actually discriminate GD status? If you extract the pooled effect sizes from both meta analysis into estimated AUCs, you get around 0.537 - 0.565 for trans women and 0.542 for trans men. For context, 0.50 is chance… For even more context from my own personal field (biomarkers in dementia), the plasma biomarker, p-tau217, can achieve AUCs of roughly 0.92–0.96 for detecting Alzheimer’s from other dementias (that’s proper predictive power). Using CAG repeats does NOT predict GD, which would be unexpected if “this was found in every trans person they’ve tested ever”. Lastly, AR activity is not determined solely by CAG repeat length, nor is the relationship confirmed to be linear (in vivo). It depends on a whole host of other factors, including receptor abundance, circulating and local T & DHT concentrations, transcriptional co-activators/co-repressors (which increase/decrease AR activity), and tissue-specific receptor expression and localisation. Moreover, T can be aromatised into estrogen, acting through ERs rather than ARs. Thus, longer CAG repeats do not necessarily translate into proportionally reduced androgen signalling, particularly in the developing brain, where the hormonal environment, receptor expression and timing of exposure all matter, not just the number of CAGs (which also vary in the general population anyways). Here’s the full video: youtu.be/ME1WVdWB5xk?is=8TjG…