←
Nicholas Kitchen3,843 posts
Nicholas Kitchen avatar

Nicholas Kitchen

@NickKitchen1

Associate Prof @SurreyPolitics. Director @CGPC_surrey. Visiting Fellow @LSEIDEAS. Power analysis, strategy, and neoclassical realist nerdiness.

◷ Joined January 2011▧ 155 Photos and videos
Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·14 Aug 2025

Just no evidence NATO enlargement debate was about military security. It’s about the reason why the Cold War was lost - the economic consequences of defeat. Once E Europe was part of the transatlantic financial system its prosperity would advance too fast for Russia’s comfort.

I struggle with the NATO enlargement debate for the following reasons. -- The prima facie case is "we ignored Russia at our peril; if we only took their concerns into account--i.e. did not enlarge NATO to the East--then things would have turned out better. Didn't they tell us, time and again, that this was unacceptable." -- But then in comes the counterargument: "If we did not find a safe anchoring for these countries in NATO, they'd be much less secure than they are today. In effect, there would be many more Moldovas and Ukraines." Also: "Why should we have indulged Russia with its imperialist fantasies; we should have actually been straightforward with the Russians, so they'd face the reality that they had lost the Cold War. Tough love. Instead we tried to humor them." -- Then comes in the other counterargument: "Then, why should we be surprised that a resurgent Russia is trying to screw us over. Tough love. And as for Eastern Europe, are they more secure today, with an aggressive Russia at their doorstep, and Art. 5 little better than make-believe?" -- The counterargument to that is: "Absolutely, they are better off, just look at Ukraine." -- "But Ukraine would not have happened if..." -- "Of course, it would..." This is a conversation one is bound to have in one's head. Arguments on both sides have merit, yet they can't all be true, can they? Unfortunately, when it comes to this whole topic, I am like Isiah Berlin's fox, jumping here and there, because each position--when taken to its logical conclusion--leads to absurdity. In any case, the evidence is pretty thin for much of this on-going argument. What we do have mounting evidence for is that throughout the 1990s the Russians incessantly complained about NATO's eastern enlargement. It wasn't something Putin suddenly came up with in 2007. Make of it what you will.

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·9 Apr 2025

We isolate three pathways: renewing and redirecting existing infrastructure; building alternatives to existing infrastructure; and developing and deploying new infrastructures at the leading edge of technological development. (4/)

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·9 Apr 2025

In a system defined by the nuclear defense dilemma, we argue that infrastructure provision represents the least costly and most likely pathway to hegemonic transition. (3/)

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·9 Apr 2025

For baseball fans, there's actually no Ray Kinsella in it, but the main point we make is that the building of systemic infrastructure creates structural power by generating path dependencies and imposing switching costs. (2/)

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·9 Apr 2025

New Article Alert! “If You Build It, They Will Come.” Infrastructure, Hegemonic Transition, and Peaceful Change, with Simon Curtis is out in @GSQ_Journal. Thanks to the team there for a really smooth review process. doi.org/10.1093/isagsq/ksaf0…

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·17 Mar 2025

Very timely stuff: I would expect a different diagnosis of Europe's challenges than @JDVance presented at Munich, but if the point of that particular intervention was to encourage great European autonomy, that discussion will certainly be prominent.

📢 Join us in Surrey, UK, for the "Challenges to Europe – European Challenges" Conference, exploring the forces shaping politics, society, and democracy across the continent 🇪🇺 📅 28-29 May 2025 | 📍University of Surrey 🔗 Free registration: 2025cbeeuropeanchallenges.ev…

Post attachment
Sergey Radchenko avatar
⟳ Nicholas Kitchen retweeted
Sergey Radchenko@DrRadchenko·6 Mar 2025

This is so true. There’s a gigantic credibility gap.

People are getting excited about Macron's offer "to open a strategic debate" on how France could protect Europe with its nuclear weapons. But I don't see how this debate can come to any conclusion other than that it cannot. Let's take a closer look... 1/

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·20 Dec 2024

Roll up! Great opportunity to present work on all things Europe - from populist politics to the Western alliance. I'll be giving a keynote entitled 'Sleeping with a stricken elephant' but don't let that particular imagery put you off - get your abstracts in!

✳️CALL FOR PAPERS✳️ The CBE, with @PolStudiesAssoc German, Italian & Greek Specialists, invites you to the Challenges to Europe - European Challenges Conference at the @UniOfSurrey, 28-29 May 2025. Submit your abstract by 20 Jan 2025! Details: surrey.ac.uk/news/call-paper…

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·24 Oct 2024

As long as he didn’t use the word liberalist he’s fine by me

Seva@SevaUT23 Oct 2024

guys I've seen the video and it's a bombshell that will end the campaign. Trump actually confuses structural realism for neoclassical realism

Nicholas Kitchen avatar
Nicholas Kitchen@NickKitchen1·13 Sep 2024

I was a discussant for an earlier version of this paper back @MYBISA in Glasgow last year, and it's really good to see it out. Trump's particular brand of masculinity and his declinism are clear, what Clara does really nicely is to connect the two.

This is finally out ! “A gendered analysis of US decline: a cautionary tale” available Open Access in International Relations journal 💥 @LSBU_LSS #trumpism #USdecline #hybridmasculinity #UShegemony #FeministIR journals.sagepub.com/doi/ful…