←
Colin Smith7,739 posts
Colin Smith avatar

Colin Smith

@NoteTaker_X

Grand Lodge aesthetic

◷ Joined July 2026▧ 323 Photos and videos
Colin Smith avatar
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Oct 1

This is a masterclass in statistical lying to manufacture a constitutional grievance. You claim the Prime Minister is taking “up to £4bn from Scotland's pensioners to pay for social care in England”, but your own Deputy First Minister’s letter admits that £4bn figure is an unadjusted cash-terms extrapolation for 2049–50, nearly a quarter of a century away. Terrifying pensioners today with compounding spreadsheet projections for 24 years in the future is cynical politics. More importantly, the claim that Scottish money is going south to fund English care is completely fabricated. Social care is fully devolved. If the UK Government invests money into an English National Care Service, the Barnett formula automatically triggers massive, proportional block grant windfalls straight into Holyrood's bank account. Scotland doesn't pay for English care; Holyrood gets a cash payout because of it. The ultimate irony is that Scotland’s population is ageing faster than the rest of the UK. Scottish pensions are currently underwritten by a 68-million-strong UK tax base and an annual £25.3bn UK Treasury fiscal transfer. If Scotland were independent, facing a 10% structural deficit without a central bank, you couldn't maintain existing state pensions on Day 1, let alone in 2050. Honest John?😂

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·4h

Laura, attempting to farm engagement from this CAF story by tweeting “Big breaking story... be interesting to see how ScotGov responds” is incredibly disingenuous, even by your standards. You act like this is a sudden, shocking revelation that the SNP has been caught out by. In reality, the Scottish Government has known about CAF’s involvement in the Jerusalem Light Rail system for months. The Scottish Greens hauled John Swinney over the coals about this exact contract bid during First Minister's Questions weeks ago. Trade unions like ASLEF and RMT have been demanding CAF's removal from the shortlist for months warning the SNP that they would refuse to drive the trains. The Scottish Government doesn't need to formulate a new response to this “breaking” news from Spain; their response has already been to quietly keep CAF on the procurement shortlist while hiding behind “legal requirements” and “procurement procedures”. It is frankly embarrassing that you are pretending this is a new crisis rather than an established, ongoing SNP policy decision to continue dealing with this company.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·5h

Fatima, your desperate amnesia is showing. You claim Scotland “never wanted to leave” the EU, conveniently forgetting that the SNP spent years campaigning for a policy that would have immediately dragged Scotland out of it. The European Commission and EU leadership made it crystal clear during the 2014 referendum that under Article 49 of the EU Treaty, a newly independent Scotland would not inherit membership. It would instantly become a third country outside the EU and would have to undergo an accession process to apply. A “Yes” vote in 2014 was a vote to leave the European Union. The only reason your party didn't rip Scotland out of the EU years before Brexit even happened is because the Scottish public voted “No” and stopped you. Tweeting about a “democratic deficit” when the SNP's flagship policy was the original Scottish Brexit is the height of hypocrisy.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·14h

Lucy, you have just produced a lesson in accidental self-sabotage. You are desperately trying to frame the UK-wide concern over youth economic inactivity as an “abhorrent” media narrative, claiming that only a “tiny proportion” of young people actually receive these benefits. But then you published the actual data, which completely destroys your own argument. According to your own article, 5.11% of all 16-to-24-year-olds in Scotland are claiming Adult Disability Payment (ADP). That is more than 1 in 20 young people sitting on a disability benefit at the very dawn of their working lives. That is a massive socioeconomic crisis, not a statistical rounding error to be thrown away. It gets even worse for the SNP when you scroll down to your Universal Credit chart. Your own data proves that 4.27% of 16-to-24-year-olds in Scotland claim the health element of UC, compared to just 3.42% in England. You have published proof that Scotland has a significantly higher rate of young people trapped on health-related Universal Credit than England, yet your only takeaway is to attack the media for talking about it. The only thing “abhorrent” here is a nationalist paper trying to downplay a youth inactivity crisis just to protect the SNP’s 19-year record of failure in health and education.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·14h

You really have to admire the sheer brass neck of cropping the x-axis off an official government graph just to force a partisan narrative. The data in the 2025 Scottish Health Survey starts in 2008, a full year after the Labour era ended. You intentionally sliced the bottom off the image so you could pretend this was a perfectly timed SNP-led decline. But the real tragedy here is your desperation to use a self-reported survey data to claim a “massive fall” in hazardous drinking, while completely ignoring the actual body count. Yes, fewer people might be admitting to heavy drinking on government surveys, but the reality is that Scotland still has the highest rate of alcohol-specific deaths in the entire UK. You are bragging about a statistical survey while the actual death rate remains a serious national crisis. Another thick as mince post yet again from you.

Colin Smith avatar
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·17h

Spot on, Steve. This is exactly the economic data that causes the average nationalist to stick their fingers in their ears and claim “GERS is a myth!” It is the Scottish Government's own official data, and it completely contradicts the SNP's “seamless EU accession” lie. You cannot walk up to Brussels with a £25.3 billion structural deficit (10.9% of GDP) when the EU's strict, non-negotiable entry requirement is 3%. To close that massive gap, an independent Scotland would have to gut public services and hike taxes so aggressively that it would make a decade of Westminster austerity look like a socialist utopia.

Any Scottish voter who thinks the process of leaving our UK & potentially joining the EU would be easy, is living in cloud cuckoo land:-

Post attachmentPost attachment
Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 17

John, if the First Minister is going to base his communications strategy around a 27-year-old video game franchise just to desperately look relatable to the youth, you should probably ask your advisors to fact-check your script first. The telephone was absolutely not “invented in Scotland”. Alexander Graham Bell was born in Edinburgh, but he invented and patented the telephone in Boston, USA. He had to leave Scotland to find the economic environment, infrastructure, and investment needed to change the world, a historical reality of “brain drain” that your government is currently speed-running with punitive tax rates and stagnant growth. Furthermore, clinging to 19th-century inventors to boast about Scottish genius is a remarkably bold strategy when your own government has spent the last 19 years tanking Scotland's PISA scores and dragging our once-world-leading education system down the international league tables. We used to invent the modern world; now the SNP just invents excuses for Holyrood's failures.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 17

The absolute cringe of a party that has been in government for 19 years desperately using Grand Theft Auto memes to farm grievance. Let's look at the actual reality behind your desperate graphics. You complain that “England repeatedly voted for the Tories”, conveniently ignoring the massive elephant in the room: we literally have a Labour UK government right now because the English electorate comprehensively voted the Tories out. You claim powers were “taken off the Scottish Parliament”, completely ignoring the 2016 Scotland Act which handed Holyrood sweeping new tax and welfare powers; powers your party has also used to create the highest tax burden in the UK. And fearmongering that Nigel Farage is “very likely” to be PM? Nothing more than desperate fiction designed to terrify your sheep. But the masterpiece of this thread is the timeline itself: In the entire 13-year gap between the release of GTA V and GTA VI, the SNP has been the sole government in Holyrood, overseeing a domestic record of failing schools, NHS wait times, and scandal after scandal. Your final “Ah shit, here we go again” meme is incredibly accurate because that's exactly how the Scottish public feels every single time you launch another independence drive to distract from your own catastrophic domestic failures😂

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 17

Peter, attempting to apply the First Law of Thermodynamics to macroeconomics to sound deep is extreme pseudo-intellectualism😂 Claiming that “wealth is energy” and therefore “can be neither created nor destroyed” is an embarrassingly fundamental misunderstanding of what wealth actually is. Wealth is not a fixed lump of physical matter; it is the creation of value through human ingenuity, labour, and technology. If “wealth creation” was physically impossible and purely an “extractive process”, human civilisation and global GDP would still be at the exact same level it was during the Stone Age. Furthermore, your desperate fearmongering about “inward investment” leaving Scotland with less than it had before completely ignores the basic reality of infrastructure development, high-skilled job creation, and the multiplier effect on local supply chains. But the absolute funniest part of your rant is that you are moaning about the “extractive” evils of AI data centres while completely ignoring that it is your own nationalist politicians and Scottish councils actively and secretly promoting this exact investment. You are writing zero-sum thermodynamic fantasy stories just to accidentally attack your own side's economic policy.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 17

Laura, pitching The National as a brave, radical paper that “challenges the status-quo” is absolutely hilarious when your entire editorial model operates as the self-serving PR wing for a nationalist party that has been the establishment government in Holyrood for 19 years. But the timing of this Black Friday sale is a genuine masterpiece of zero self-awareness😂 You are bragging about jetting off to Barcelona for a conference on Palestine 24 hours after your paper printed a completely fabricated manipulative front page complaining about “winter strikes” in Gaza when the actual forecast was a dry, sunny 24°C. And why on earth would anyone pay £20 for “full access” to your digital journalism when your website is so heavily infested with sketchy, incorrectly configured ad-tech trackers that antivirus software blocks the site to protect the reader's data? You aren't selling “expert analysis” from Owen Jones; you are selling fact-free propaganda wrapped in a digital malware risk.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 17

Sam, you admit you “never knew too much about this”, which is painfully obvious because you clearly didn't even read the Wikipedia page you just linked. The Radical War of 1820 wasn't “the English... doing us dirty”. As the very first sentence of your own source states, it was a result of demands for “reform in the United Kingdom”. This was a struggle for electoral reform and more responsive government driven by artisan workers and Scottish weavers. It was part of the exact same radical movement that sparked protest demonstrations across Britain following the Peterloo Massacre in England a year earlier. The Scottish radicals were fighting the British Government for voting rights and economic relief, not fighting an ethnic war against England for Scottish independence. Trying to shoehorn a 19th-century UK-wide class struggle into your modern anti-English grievance narrative is simply ignorant. Next time, try reading past the headline before you post.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 16

Xander, watching you sneer at families waving Union flags to welcome home submariners who just spent 217 days underwater protecting the entire UK, including Scotland, is nothing more than nationalist pettiness. You are trying to spin the dedication of 140 Royal Navy personnel into a “crisis” while conveniently omitting the massive £26 billion investment already underway to upgrade Faslane and build the new Dreadnought-class replacements. But the funniest part of your “analysis” is you asking what a nuclear deterrent actually deters that “conventional weaponry... would not combat more effectively”, right after quoting Defence Secretary Wes Streeting warning that Russian spy submarine and naval activity in UK waters is up 41% this year. You answered your own question in the very next paragraph. You don't deter a nuclear-armed superpower mapping our undersea cables with conventional popguns; you deter them with an unassailable, continuous at-sea nuclear deterrent. Mocking the men and women who sacrifice seven months of daylight to keep you safe from Russian aggression isn't edgy journalism, it's just pathetic.

Colin Smith avatar
⟳ Colin Smith retweeted
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 16

Jim, reading comprehension is clearly not your strong point. In my very first tweet, I asked why a pitiful 20% of “registered voters” backed independence. In my follow-up, I broke down the numbers using the “registered electorate”. At absolutely no point did I base my figures on the total population. But the funniest part of your desperate claim that I based my figures on “population” is that you haven't thought it through. If I had based my figures on Scotland's total population of around 5.4 million instead of the roughly 4 million registered voters, the SNP's share wouldn't be 20% it would drop to a humiliating 15%😂 You just tried to “correct” me by inventing a metric that makes your own party's mandate look even worse. You have mathematically humiliated yourself twice in one thread just to blindly defend the SNP.

Colin Smith avatar
Colin Smith@NoteTaker_X·Nov 16

Unbelievable blocks me then replies twice😂

Post attachment

Condescendingly calling me “son” while confidently promoting absolute illiteracy is a typical nationalist arrogance. First of all, 1707 wasn't a “clear annexation”; it was a political union negotiated and voted for by the Scottish Parliament after the Scottish elite bankrupted the country with their own failed colonial project at Darien. But the absolute masterpiece of your reply is the claim that “Englands did not” end. The English Parliament was abolished by the Acts of Union. BOTH the Scottish and English parliaments were legally extinguished in 1707 and replaced by the brand-new Parliament of Great Britain. Just because the new parliament sat in the same building in Westminster does not mean the English Parliament survived. My “evidence” is the primary text of the Treaty of Union, which you clearly haven't read. It's embarrassing to be this loud and this wrong about your own country's history. An absolute thick as mince reply.