←
@OpenJusticeIE2,080 posts
@OpenJusticeIE avatar

@OpenJusticeIE

@OpenJusticeIE

Mr P Public-interest Court of Appeal Case 🇮🇪 P v DPP – 2025/295 Forensic linguistic analysis of 83 statements identifies shared authorship patterns across 51

◷ Joined May 2014▧ 353 Photos and videos
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Sep 30

THE MR P CASE — 51 MINUTES For the first time, Mr P’s case is being discussed openly in public. Even this 51-minute conversation touches on only some of the issues placed before the High Court and Court of Appeal. For years, Mr P has faced these proceedings in extraordinary isolation, while serious questions concerning the court record, documentary material and forensic evidence have remained largely outside public scrutiny. That is why this matters far beyond one individual. Public confidence in justice depends on difficult questions being capable of open examination....... not silence. Thank you @MegaEire for providing the space for this discussion to begin. Watch it. Listen carefully. Share it. Ask questions. This is only part of the story. More will follow.

51:00
Susanne Delaney avatar
⟳ @OpenJusticeIE retweeted
Susanne Delaney@SuzieD755164·Nov 12

If you follow me and feel my posts are important and informative, drop me a hi and comment to boost my page algorithmically. I have noticed a sharp drop in engagement in the 72 hours or so since I had a major go at Simon Harris and Helen McEntee. It always happens after I post about Fine Gael. Alternatively, please like share bookmark or comment on other posts. I do what I do to keep truth available in a dangerous time of deception. Unfortunately they can make you unseen and unheard very easily. Thank you!

GP avatar
⟳ @OpenJusticeIE retweeted
GP@Graham_dePenros·Oct 25

Dear Meda, ​I completely agree with you. It is entirely atrocious that this is happening deliberately. ​The lack of accountability is staggering, and you are right, there needs to be a massive clear-out of those involved. ​We have to keep pushing for transparency until they are forced to answer for this. It is a complex, labyrinthine mess of an enigma wrapped in a mystery surrounded by a puzzle which they have constructed. But they are undone by their own eagerness to commit a crime at such a scale that they have been sloppy, and it is in that sloppiness that they shall be exposed. ​All the best, Graham.

Bríain Ó Éire avatar
⟳ @OpenJusticeIE retweeted
Bríain Ó Éire@Eirinn76·Oct 25

A man reports alleged misconduct by a serving Garda (his ex wife) and within weeks faces a harassment prosecution built on 83 statements. Independent forensic linguist Dr Natalie Schilling finds shared authorship across 51 or more of them, including every one of the seven alleged victim statements; her second report identifies the Garda herself as the central author. The Court of Appeal refuses to admit that report, key Pulse and court records are claimed to be missing, and neither the Gardaí, DPP nor any other body has launched an independent investigation into the authorship, the metadata changes after charge, or the vanished records. The DPP’s own rules require reliable evidence capable of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt, yet the prosecution rolls on while these glaring integrity failures are ignored.

J.K. Lunden avatar
⟳ @OpenJusticeIE retweeted
J.K. Lunden@Jklunden·Oct 21

Ireland Under Pressure: The Triple Lock, Gender Politics, Border Chaos & a Country at Breaking Point.

4:03
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 20

Minister @OCallaghanJim, any update on Dr Natalie Schilling’s forensic findings in Mr P’s prosecution? Evidence of potential co-authorship across at least 51 witness statements, including all seven alleged victims. Have the Garda members involved been questioned, investigated or arrested? Has an independent criminal investigation commenced? Or will you continue to look the other way?

Another deportation flight left Dublin today and has now landed safely in Bucharest. There were 24 Romanian nationals on board, all of whom had been convicted of crimes in Ireland. As EU citizens, they were removed under the Free Movement Directive.

@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 16

.@IrishMissionUN Does Ireland’s condemnation of torture extend to psychological torture, coercion and degrading treatment allegedly inflicted by its own State authorities? Consider the case of Mr P: a man alleging a coerced guilty plea, serious Garda misconduct, manipulation of witness evidence, prolonged restrictive bail conditions and years of devastating psychological suffering. Independent forensic linguistic findings have raised serious questions about the authorship of witness statements in his prosecution. Who independently investigates allegations of this gravity when the very State institutions accused are responsible for administering justice? Human rights cannot be principles Ireland champions internationally while allegations of serious abuses within its own justice system remain unexamined. Will Ireland apply the same standards to Mr P that it demands of other nations?

Today at #UNGA81 3C, Ireland strongly condemned all instances of torture and other inhumane or degrading treatment. Torture can never be justified. It is a grievous violation of human rights and undermines individuals’ humanity and dignity.

Post attachment
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 15

Senator McDowell @SenatorMcDowell , I welcome your intervention and the call for an independent inquiry. But what about civilian whistleblowers — ordinary citizens who expose alleged Garda wrongdoing and subsequently face intimidation, retaliation or even criminal prosecution? Will you insist that the inquiry’s terms of reference expressly include these individuals, allow them to submit evidence and examine allegations of reprisals by State actors? Surely protection from State wrongdoing cannot depend on whether someone wears a Garda uniform. Those outside the organisation may be the most vulnerable and the least protected. They must not be excluded from any investigation into Garda accountability.

In the Seanad today I raised the ongoing issues for Garda whistleblowers. The Irish Council for Civil Liberties has called for an independent inquiry.

4:08
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 15

Taoiseach @MichealMartinTD, how can Ireland speak of a strong, free and FAIR Europe when serious questions concerning the integrity of criminal prosecutions in our own country remain unanswered? Consider Mr P, an Irish citizen facing criminal proceedings after reporting alleged Garda wrongdoing. AI-assisted examination of 83 prosecution witness statements initially identified extraordinary linguistic similarities. Independent forensic linguist Dr Natalie Schilling subsequently identified evidence of shared authorship across at least 51 statements attributed to 39 individuals, including all seven alleged victims. Original Microsoft Word files also contain metadata indicating modifications AFTER the prosecution file was forwarded for DPP directions and AFTER criminal charges were brought. What was changed, by whom and why remains unresolved. Despite these findings, there has been no independent forensic investigation establishing how these statements were produced or whether their integrity was compromised. This goes far beyond one man’s prosecution. How many other Irish citizens have been accused, prosecuted or imprisoned on the strength of evidence that could reveal similar irregularities if independently examined? What protection exists for those who lack the knowledge, money or resources to uncover such anomalies? You speak about a Europe that delivers for its citizens. Surely that must include protecting citizens against potential miscarriages of justice, ensuring accountability within State institutions and investigating credible evidence of wrongdoing, regardless of how politically uncomfortable the findings may be. Mr P is not asking for special treatment. He is asking for an independent investigation into evidence that raises fundamental questions about the administration of justice in Ireland. Taoiseach, you have been made aware of his concerns. Will you personally seek answers, or must an Irish citizen continue fighting alone for the very justice and fairness you are promoting on the European stage?

A positive start to the day at the @RenewEurope Leaders Summit. Our focus is on a strong, free and fair Europe that delivers for its citizens.

Post attachment
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 14

Paul @RTENewsPaulC, here is an extraordinary Irish AI story worthy of RTÉ investigation. In Mr P’s criminal prosecution, AI-assisted analysis initially exposed striking linguistic similarities across 83 witness statements attributed to 66 individuals, raising serious questions about independent authorship. Independent forensic linguist Dr Natalie Schilling subsequently examined the statements WITHOUT relying on the AI findings and identified authorship connections across at least 51 statements, including those of all 7 alleged victims. Separately, examination of original Microsoft Word files revealed metadata indicating modifications AFTER the prosecution file was sent to the DPP and AFTER criminal charges were brought. The nature and purpose of those modifications remain unverified. Consider the implications for every person accused of a crime, or already convicted, potentially on the strength of evidence whose authorship and integrity have never been independently scrutinised. How many other criminal cases could benefit from similar AI-assisted examination? Ireland is celebrating AI innovation. Surely one of its most important applications must be protecting citizens from miscarriages of justice. Will RTÉ investigate what AI has uncovered in Mr P’s case, and ask why these serious evidential concerns have not received an independent forensic investigation?

Podcast: AI summit special - podcasts.apple.com/ie/podcas…

@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 14

Commissioner @HennaVirkkunen, will Europe also put AI to work exposing potential miscarriages of justice? In Ireland, AI-assisted examination of 83 witness statements in Mr P’s criminal prosecution raised extraordinary concerns about authorship. Forensic linguistics expert Dr Natalie Schilling subsequently identified evidence of potential co-authorship across at least 51 statements, including those attributed to all seven alleged victims. These findings raise serious questions about the integrity of criminal evidence. Who investigates when AI exposes potential State misconduct? Will the European Commission examine Mr P’s case, or is AI accountability only a priority when it serves economic interests?

At the AI Summit in Dublin today, my message was clear: Europe must build its own AI capabilities, keep AI under human control and put it to work across our economy. With the Irish Presidency we launched the European AI Innovation Month: nearly 100 events across Europe. 🚀

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 14

Taoiseach @MichealMartinTD, will Mr P’s prosecution be examined as a case study at your AI Summit? AI-assisted analysis raised serious questions about authorship across 83 statements in an Irish criminal prosecution. Forensic linguistics expert Dr Natalie Schilling subsequently identified evidence suggesting common authorship or co-authorship across at least 51 statements, including those attributed to all seven alleged victims. How many other people’s witness statements could be subjected to the same forensic scrutiny? AI has the potential to transform criminal justice by exposing evidential irregularities that might otherwise go undetected. But what happens when AI uncovers evidence that raises serious questions about the integrity of a State prosecution? Who investigates — and who is accountable? Mr P’s case deserves answers.

I warmly welcome OpenAI’s announcement of 200 new jobs in Ireland. It is a further vote of confidence in our people, economy and ecosystem. These factors combine to make us a leading destination for applied AI, and we are determined to build on this success in the years ahead.

Post attachment
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 14

Taoiseach @MichealMartinTD, will Mr P’s prosecution be examined as a case study at your AI Summit? AI-assisted analysis raised serious questions about authorship across 83 statements in an Irish criminal prosecution. Forensic linguistics expert Dr Natalie Schilling subsequently identified evidence suggesting common authorship or co-authorship across at least 51 statements, including those attributed to all seven alleged victims. How many other people’s witness statements could be subjected to the same forensic scrutiny? AI has the potential to transform criminal justice by exposing evidential irregularities that might otherwise go undetected. But what happens when AI uncovers evidence that raises serious questions about the integrity of a State prosecution? Who investigates — and who is accountable? Mr P’s case deserves answers.

AI will be one of the defining opportunities of our time. Ireland will work hand-in-hand with our European partners to ensure we seize it. That’s why today’s AI Summit is a key event in our EU Presidency.

1:00
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 14

If only the member states of the UN Human Rights Council knew what was happening behind Ireland’s carefully polished international image. Missing Garda and court records, serious questions over witness statements, forensic evidence raising concerns about the integrity of criminal proceedings, and a man fighting for accountability. @dfatirl , how can Ireland claim to champion human rights internationally when such fundamental concerns remain unanswered at home? Who protects the citizen when it is the State itself whose conduct is being challenged?

Ireland has been elected to the UN Human Rights Council for 2027-2029! Throughout our campaign, Ireland promised to be a consistent voice & committed partner for human rights. That commitment remains unchanged as we prepare to begin our term on the Council. #IrelandHRC

0:05
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 13

If only the member states of the UN Human Rights Council knew what was happening behind Ireland’s carefully polished international image. Missing Garda and court records, serious questions over witness statements, forensic evidence raising concerns about the integrity of criminal proceedings, and a man fighting for accountability. Minister @HMcEntee , how can Ireland claim to champion human rights internationally when such fundamental concerns remain unanswered at home? Who protects the citizen when it is the State itself whose conduct is being challenged?

Minister @HMcEntee has welcomed Ireland’s election to the United Nations Human Rights Council. Human rights remain at the heart of our foreign policy and our commitment to supporting people’s fundamental freedoms is unwavering.

1:16
@OpenJusticeIE avatar
@OpenJusticeIE@OpenJusticeIE·Oct 12

Taoiseach @MichealMartinTD , you welcome 200 new AI jobs in Ireland. But do you welcome what AI-assisted stylometric and metadata analysis can reveal about our justice system? In Mr P’s prosecution, analysis has raised serious questions about the authorship of 83 statements and post-charge alterations to evidence. Independent forensic linguist Professor Natalie Schilling identified authorship connections across at least 51 statements attributed to different signatories. These findings have been brought to the attention of State authorities. Will you support an independent investigation into these findings, or is AI only celebrated when it delivers positive headlines?

I warmly welcome OpenAI’s announcement of 200 new jobs in Ireland. It is a further vote of confidence in our people, economy and ecosystem. These factors combine to make us a leading destination for applied AI, and we are determined to build on this success in the years ahead.

Post attachment