
My allegorical fable⬇️seems to be confusing some people There are actually three main points 1. sex is a great way to spread innovation to lineages that never evolved them That's understood. But what many evolutionary biologists don't get is: 2. Mutation speeds up when a population is under strong selective pressure 3. Sexual selection - focusing on particular traits such as peacocks' tails, birdsong in songbirds, migration, or (in humans) beautiful faces, athleticism and cleverness - can restore accurate replication Those traits need to be complex - ie the product of many genes - and everyone needs to agree on what is important, so that recent mutations can be picked up _____________________ At the end of the last ice age, sea levels rose by 120 meters. As the water rose, about 1,000 humans were marooned on the Fantasian Islands, about 40 miles off the coast of West Africa (at least, I feel that’s where they ought to be). Within decades, people had wiped out all the large mammals on the islands, and they lived on gourds, fruit, and the eggs of blue-footed boobies. However, there was a kind of bean on the islands that could be eaten in small quantities – in larger quantities, it was toxic. There was one family on the island that was particularly stupid and ugly, avoided by the other islanders. This was because both parents had high mutation rates – they had DNA polymerases that couldn’t replicate DNA quite as accurately as others could - their polymerases made slightly more mistakes. Instead of about 100 new mutations per child (mutations the parents didn’t have, that is), their children had about 800. By the third generation, there were a lot of illnesses in the family, but there was one boy who could eat the beans without any ill effects (scientists now believe he had three new mutations that allowed him to tolerate both tannins and lectins). All his siblings died at young ages, but he and his children were strong - although stupid - and his sons mated with the most beautiful girls on the island. These girls had DNA polymerases with very low error rates, so fidelity was restored. After 300 years, everyone on the island was descended from this particular individual, and they were all perfectly healthy and intelligent, with beans forming 60% of their diet. By the way, it was crucial that the young men sought out the most beautiful girls - as we still do today. That’s because they were subconsciously looking for accurate polymerases. The story is allegorical, but I think this kind of thing happens all the time with animals, plants, fungi, and microbes – whenever a species is subjected to strong natural selection. For example, when they invade new terrain, an ice age begins, or they infect a new host. That’s why sexual reproduction is so universal – scientists don’t have a good explanation right now for why it’s so popular (check out the Wikipedia article). I think sexual reproduction a general adaptation to unstable environments and a mechanism to restore replicative fidelity – which is often lost. Prokaryotes have similar mechanisms, but sex is the most complex and effective Preprint: vixra.org/pdf/2303.0056v3.pd… (I've since changed the name back to The Everest Hypothesis btw)















