←
Peter Clack11,384 posts
Peter Clack avatar

Peter Clack

@PeterDClack

Beautiful description of the living soil and our plant and trees growing in this live rich environment. Climate doomsdayers have no clue about our living earth.

◷ Joined May 2024▧ 3,107 Photos and videos
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·12h

New Delhi's Ghazipur landfill mountain is so tall, that India’s Supreme Court has ruled it must carry aircraft warning lights. Imagine the smell, the methane fires, the citywide summer smell of municipal waste towering 20 storeys into the sky (65 metres). Imagine a childhood under its shadow. Yet, even as Indian cities strain under this immense weight, they are already overwhelmed by their own domestic refuse. Wealthy Western nations are still green dumping tens of thousands of tonnes of municipal garbage overseas, often disguised as legitimate recyclable paper and plastic. The United Kingdom, like many other industrial Western nations, generates millions of tonnes of packaging and industrial refuse that domestic recycling systems have no ability to absorb. A significant quantity of Western household waste has traditionally been quietly shipped out to these poorer developing nations (the Global South). They are still dumping their own garbage mess in countries that are already struggling with chronic landfill overload. When British householders separate their plastics and paper into curbside recycling bins, they are led to believe they are closing an environmental loop. But investigators have tracked household receipts, crisp packets and packaging - all getting dumped in countries like India and Pakistan. Most of it bypasses recycling altogether. Instead, it ends up being tossed into local ecosystems, riverways and coastal strips, or added to immense local pollution overload because importing regions simply lack the capacity to process any of it. Western governments lecture the world on carbon footprints and environmental virtue at high-profile international summits, yet their own cargo ships drop off mountain loads of single-use packaging on these distant shores. Environmental responsibility should begin at home — not shipping out cargo vessel packed with household rubbish, so it is out of sight, out of mind. youtu.be/e-DPMovBD-8?si=WXFX…

Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·15h

While Australians grapple with choking domestic cost-of-living pressures and high energy bills, Climate Change and Energy Minister Chris Bowen is spending nearly $200 million of public money on a two-week climate summit in Türkiye. Having failed to win hosting rights outright last year, Bowen agreed to a power-sharing arrangement to serve as 'President of Negotiations' for COP31 on Türkiye's behalf. While the government frames this as Pacific 'diplomacy', the price tag for Australian taxpayers is staggering: $147.8 million allocated toward COP31 engagement and Pacific initiatives, on top of a preliminary 'Pre-COP' meeting in Fiji that blew out to $34.6 million. Rather than focusing on reliable, affordable energy at home, Bowen has flown half a world away to broker international deals for a summit Australia isn't even hosting. Australia also registered one of the largest delegations at the event — 835 people, behind only five other nations — with taxpayers funding a massive contingent of officials and diplomats. The government even spent roughly $32,000 of public money on a Turkish espresso contract to serve free coffee to international delegates, alongside another $71,000 on private limousines. Unsurprisingly, voters are unimpressed. A Compass Polling survey of 1,043 voters published today (18 November) found that 84 per cent of respondents believed the $150 million-plus spent on the summit would be better directed toward reducing electricity bills back in Australia. Furthermore, 82 per cent of respondents said Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and 'climate czar' Bowen should spend more time dealing with actual domestic problems, while 68 per cent believed Bowen should now be replaced as Energy Minister. This international spending splash follows a pattern of costly domestic subsidies. Under Bowen’s direction, billions of taxpayer dollars have been committed to green hydrogen initiatives — including $2.25 billion for the Hydrogen Headstart program, $6.7 billion allocated for production tax incentives, and $500 million for regional hubs. Despite this massive public investment, key regional hubs in Townsville, Gladstone and Kwinana have collapsed, leaving taxpayers out of pocket for projects that have struggled to stack up commercially. All of this is being pursued despite Australia’s vast landmass, substantial natural carbon sinks, and negligible share of global emissions compared with major industrial emitters like China. Moreover, the sense of perpetual crisis used to justify these expenditures ignores both the Earth's long-term natural recovery from the 180 ppm CO2 lows of the Last Glacial Maximum, plus the fact that extreme, worst-case climate modelling scenarios have now been walked back by researchers. Australians deserve an Energy Minister who puts the nation’s economic and energy security first. Instead, Bowen is spending untold billions in public money on high-profile international summits and subsidies for unviable green projects.

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·22h

Are we still living on Easter Island? When I was a child, there was no plastic packaging, and there was no weekly garbage collection. Milk arrived on the doorstep in heavy glass bottles, meant to be washed and returned. At the local cooperative, food was weighed, prepared and wrapped in simple paper that could later be tossed onto the fire. We did not have a waste crisis because we did not create permanent waste. The system was circular, logical and quietly sustainable. Looking at the world today, it is hard to reconcile those memories with the scale of the unfolding ecological disaster around us. Our rivers are choked with pollutants, our seas are stagnating under the weight of synthetic debris, and our landfills are in a state of permanent crisis. Even more absurd is our selective blindness. In the West, we sneer at less developed Asian nations like India for the waste choking their waterways, comfortably pretending this is someone else’s failure. Yet we conveniently ignore the fact that our own industrial heartlands are just as guilty, with rivers like the Mississippi in the United States and the Sarno in Italy sitting right alongside them on the top 10 list of the world’s worst polluted riverways. We boast of human intelligence and technological mastery, yet when faced with mountains of mass-produced packaging and industrial runoff, our grand solution is still to dump it out of sight or dig a hole in the ground and bury it. It begs a deeply uncomfortable question: have we learned nothing from history? In many ways, our modern consumer culture feels like a global re-enactment of the tragedy of Easter Island. For centuries, the inhabitants of Rapa Nui thrived in isolation. Yet, driven by short-term competition and immediate needs, they felled their forests faster than the trees could grow back. One has to wonder what the person who cut down the very last palm tree was thinking. Did they not see the barren landscape around them? Did they not realise they were destroying the exact resource they needed to build canoes, to fish and survive? We are cutting down our own proverbial palm trees every single day. We traded the sensible, reusable systems of the corner shop for the cheap, fleeting convenience of single-use plastic. Worse still, even as the evidence of our failing systems washes up on every shoreline from the Gulf of Mexico to the Bay of Naples, we make almost no genuine effort to readjust or rethink the model. We point fingers at countries like India while hiding our own rubbish in landfills, treating the symptom while ignoring the disease of endless overproduction. Human intelligence is a strange thing. It is brilliant at inventing a material that lasts forever, yet seemingly blind to the folly of using it for ten minutes and throwing it away. Until we drop our arrogance and stop prioritising short-term convenience over long-term survival, we are no wiser than the last tree-feller on Easter Island — staring at the horizon, wondering where all the life has gone.

Post attachmentPost attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 16

Earth’s climate is governed by vast geological, oceanic, and astronomical forces — not a single trace gas. When German meteorologist Alfred Wegener proposed continental drift in 1912, he revealed the slow-motion engine behind planetary climate. Across time the assembly and fracture of supercontinents — from Rodinia and Gondwana to Pangaea, which began breaking apart around 200 million years ago — continually reshaped global wind patterns, ocean basins and the ice sheets. As tectonic plates shifted, they opened and closed critical oceanic choke points. The collision of the Indian plate with Eurasia uplifted the Himalayas, accelerating chemical weathering that steadily drew down atmospheric CO₂. Simultaneously, the opening of Drake Passage and the Tasman Gateway isolated Antarctica, allowing the frigid Antarctic Circumpolar Current to form and isolate the continent under glacial ice. Later, the closing of the Isthmus of Panama rerouted tropical currents, setting the stage for the massive Northern Hemisphere glaciation. Those shifting gateways directly govern the planet's primary heat-distribution system: the thermohaline circulation. Often called the global conveyor belt, this massive deep-ocean current carries warm tropical water toward the poles, where it cools, sinks, and returns along the abyssal floor — taking roughly 1,000 years to complete a single circuit. Once plate tectonics locked the continents into our current 'icehouse' state 2.58 million years ago, subtle gravitational shifts in Earth’s orbit — the Milankovitch cycles — took over as the pacemaker of Quaternary glaciation. Until roughly 1 million years ago, ice ages pulsed on 41,000-year cycles driven by Earth's axial tilt, before shifting during the Mid-Pleistocene Transition to 100,000-year cycles governed by orbital eccentricity. Placed against this planetary machinery, atmospheric CO₂ is a secondary passenger, not the driver. During the Cambrian period around 540 million years ago, CO₂ levels stood between 4,000 and 7,000 ppm, gradually dropping to roughly 180 ppm during the Last Glacial Maximum 20,000 years ago. That long-term drawdown was driven by geology and biology working together: silicate rock weathering, shell-building marine organisms locking carbon into limestone, and the rise of Carboniferous forests burying vast reserves of carbon as coal. Only continent-scale geological violence — the Large Igneous Provinces behind four of the 'Big Five' mass extinctions (End-Ordovician, Late Devonian, End-Permian, and End-Triassic) — ever disrupted that balance, as eruptions like the Siberian Traps poured staggering volumes of CO₂, sulfur dioxide and methane into the sky over hundreds of millennia. Today, we live in a cool icehouse world far below the Phanerozoic average, when dinosaurs roamed near the poles. Understanding that deep history puts modern climate debate in fresh perspective: the true levers of Earth's climate are tectonic, oceanic and celestial. Ii

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 16

The Mississippi and the Sarno routinely rank among the most polluted river systems on Earth. It is a damning indictment, exposing the hypocrisy of a $275 trillion global net-zero agenda that overlooks basic environmental stewardship in its own backyard. Unlike rivers in India and China choked with floating plastic and raw municipal sewage, the Mississippi suffers from invisible chemical overload. It drains roughly 40% of the continental United States — the industrial heartland and the Corn Belt. Every spring, vast amounts of synthetic nitrogen and phosphorus fertilisers wash off millions of acres of farmland into this watershed. By the time that water hits the Gulf, it triggers massive algal blooms that die, sink, and strip the water of oxygen, creating a recurring hypoxic 'dead zone' that spans thousands of square miles (averaging around 4,700–5,200 square miles in recent years, shifting with seasonal river flows). It is the direct byproduct of feeding an industrial food system at massive scale. Stretching around 24 kilometres through the fertile Campania region near Naples, the Sarno is short, slow-moving, and hemmed in by centuries-old agriculture, dense towns, and over 500 industrial facilities — particularly leather tanneries, canning factories and chemical plants. Because the river's volume is relatively small, untreated industrial effluents — including heavy metals like chromium — and municipal wastewater overwhelm its natural dilution capacity almost immediately, turning a historic Mediterranean waterway into Europe's most polluted river. Whether a nation is developing rapidly without sewage infrastructure or operating a high-output Western economy with intensive chemical agriculture and dense manufacturing, the outcome for the watershed is the same. In the West, it is simply hidden from sight. IMAGES: COP31 and the Mississippi River.

I don’t want to hear about my carbon footprint ever again.

1:16
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 16

When we look at the debate surrounding carbon dioxide and the climate, it is easy to get lost in technical jargon and alarming headlines. However, when we step back and look at the broader history of our planet, a very different picture emerges — one that suggests our current environment is far more stable, resilient and benign than we are often led to believe. To understand where we are today, we have to look at where the Earth has been. Across the vast timeline of complex life on Earth, our planet has typically been much warmer than it is right now — roughly 9°C warmer on average. Today, we are actually living in a relatively cool interglacial period within a broader ice age. Comparing our mild, predictable modern environment to catastrophic events like the end-Permian extinction simply does not hold up. Life on Earth did not just survive in warmer, higher-CO₂ eras; it thrived. We are thriving today in a world that is it faces climate doom scenario. While carbon dioxide gets almost all the attention, its a minor player in a massive, dynamic system. The world’s oceans hold the overwhelming majority of the Earth’s surface carbon, while the atmosphere holds only a tiny fraction — around one percent. Because of basic physics, as oceans warm and cool, they naturally release and absorb CO₂. More importantly, water vapor is the dominant greenhouse gas in our atmosphere, operating through clouds, storms and ocean currents. Yet in public discussions, the massive role of water vapor is routinely downplayed, while the influence of a trace gas like CO₂ is heavily overstated. Furthermore, because ice cores trap air bubbles slowly over 50 to 100 years, past temperature shifts are often smoothed out, making modern changes look uniquely abrupt when they may not be. Far from causing ecological collapse, modest warming and higher CO₂ levels have visibly benefited plant life. Coming out of the Little Ice Age — the coldest stretch in 10,000 years — the planet has experienced measurable global greening. Plants use CO₂ to grow, and a slightly warmer, CO₂-enriched atmosphere supports greater agricultural yields and healthier forests. Finally, we have to look at who is driving the alarm. Much of the modern 'climate crisis' narrative is promoted by massive, unelected international bureaucracies (the United Nations, for one) and political bodies that benefit from keeping the public in a state of fear. When complex, poorly understood natural systems are reduced to a single variable — human CO₂ emissions — it serves a political agenda rather than an open scientific inquiry. We live in a mild, adaptable world, and our climate policies should reflect reality rather than manufactured panic.

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 15

To understand Earth’s climate today, you have to look at deep geological time — not just the last few decades. Plate tectonics, ocean currents and orbital cycles are the true architects of global climate shifts, yet this long-term geological context is largely missing from today’s debate. Since Alfred Wegener mapped continental drift, we have seen how shifting crustal plates reshape the world. The uplift of the Himalayas, the closing of the Panama land bridge and the thermal isolation of Antarctica triggered the Late Cenozoic Ice Age 34 million years ago. These shifts altered the 1,000-year deep ocean conveyor belt, locking Earth into our current icehouse regime. Against this backdrop, today’s climate sits peacefully within a mild interglacial cycle — a brief warm spell inside a 2.58-million-year Quaternary glaciation. Compared with the broader Phanerozoic eon, modern Earth is remarkably cold at 15°C, sitting 9°C cooler than the 24°C average maintained over the past 540 million years of biological history. While ancient mass extinctions were driven by catastrophic events, like Large Igneous Provinces tearing through the crust with vast seas of boiling lava, our current era is defined by relative geological calm. The history of atmospheric CO₂ tells a similarly grounded story. Over the last 540 million years, CO₂ has dropped from roughly 7,000 ppm in the Cambrian to lows of 180 ppm during recent glacial peaks, drawn down by rock weathering, marine shells and Carboniferous forests. In geological terms, this long-term depletion is a far greater threat to biological life than a modest rebound. CO₂ has never acted as an imaginary thermostat for sudden climate control, and it has not become one overnight. Basing a fear campaign on the modest variables of the past few decades ignores how the planet has always worked. Attributing imminent catastrophe to a trace gas while sidelining natural, cyclical variability is simply unscientific. When the geological record is this clear, it becomes obvious that today’s alarmism is driven less by science and more by politics, economics and shifting power dynamics between the West and the Global South. What is presented as an environmental emergency has become a highly contrived public relations scheme — orchestrated in large part by the United Nations, the largest unelected bureaucracy in history, with 190,000 tax-exempt employees managing global wealth redistribution.

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 15

Coal ash is primarily seen as an industrial waste product and an environmental liability, yet it holds growing economic value through construction materials and rare earth element recovery. Every year, coal-fired power plants generate roughly 1 billion tons of coal ash worldwide, adding to massive legacy stockpiles stored in landfills and holding ponds. The largest volumes are concentrated in major coal-consuming nations — led by China, India, the United States, Russia and Australia. In the US alone, over 2 billion tons of legacy ash sit in storage, alongside roughly 70 to 80 million tons produced annually. Historically, coal was valued almost exclusively for heat, electricity and steelmaking. While it does not rival crude oil as the chemical building block for plastics and synthetic goods, coal ash similarly expands coal's industrial footprint by turning a disposal problem into raw inputs for other sectors. Fine fly ash is used in construction materials, as a pozzolanic substitute in green concrete, reducing cement emissions while increasing strength and durability. Coarser bottom ash is used as lightweight structural fill, road base material, or de-icing grit, typically valued around $5 to $30 per ton depending on processing. Driven largely by construction demand, the global coal ash market is projected to grow from roughly $13 billion to $23 billion by 2032. It is also a hidden mineral wealth. Research by institutions such as Monash University and the University of Texas at Austin shows that coal ash deposits contain all 17 rare earth elements — such as neodymium, dysprosium, and terbium — alongside aluminum, silicon, iron, lithium and gallium. Studies estimate that accessible US coal ash reserves alone contain up to 11 million tons of rare earth elements, valued at roughly $8.4 billion — nearly eight times the country's conventional domestic reserves. However, unlocking this value involves major economic and environmental hurdles. While raw mineral values are high, extraction technologies — such as hydrometallurgy and pyrometallurgy — remain in early, capital-intensive stages, meaning profitability depends heavily on processing costs and local ash chemistry. Furthermore, coal ash contains toxic heavy metals like arsenic, lead, mercury and cadmium, which can leach into groundwater if ponds are unlined or poorly managed. Like end-of-life management for solar panels or batteries, safely containing and cleaning up legacy ash dams remains a major financial responsibility for power providers.

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 14

The world is unprepared for the coming toxic avalanche of millions of solar panels hitting their end-of-life cycle - the ominous parallel to Alvin Toffler's 'future shock'. There are now several billion solar panels installed globally, spread-eagled across entire landscapes, yet still only producing intermittent power and relying on a vast global overbuild of unmatched ecological vandalism. By 2050, the International Renewable Energy Agency had projected up to 78 million metric tons of solar e-waste. But there is no longer any upper limit. The industry maintains that solar panels are '95% recyclable'. Technically, yes — because they are made largely of glass, aluminium and copper. Yet in Australia and the US, it costs roughly $20 to $28 to properly disassemble and recycle a single panel, compared to just $4 to dump it in landfill. Because there is no financial incentive, up to 90% of decommissioned panels are going straight into the ground. Each solar panel is a complex industrially laminated sandwich, bound tightly by heavy polymers. Extracting microscopic amounts of valuable silver and high-purity silicon requires energy-intensive chemical and thermal baking. When crushed or left to fracture in landfills, heavy metals like lead and cadmium can leach into the surrounding soil and groundwater, turning 'clean energy' into a multi-generational hazardous waste problem. The crisis is accelerating faster than models ever predicted because solar cells degrade and lose efficiency. When newer, cheaper panels hit the market, consumers and solar farms routinely rip out functional systems at least a decade early to upgrade. This compressed lifecycle destroys the narrative of a long-term, stable asset — creating a massive, endless loop of unrecyclable industrial trash.

Post attachment
Peter Clack avatar
Peter Clack@PeterDClack·Nov 14

Over millions of years, subtle shifts in Earth’s orbit, axial tilt and precession have guided the world into regular, repeating rhythms - known as the Milankovitch cycles. These orbital variations dictate the pacing of ice ages and interglacials, setting the solar baseline for everything that happens on the surface. Life continues to evolve alongside this astronomical heartbeat and ecosystems have spent hundreds of millions of years adapting to predictable, large-scale shifts. Attributing the modern observed temperature increase of 1.1°C to 1.4°C since the pre-industrial period exclusively to a trace gas overlooks a powerful array of natural climate drivers. Atmospheric CO₂ is not a danger for life; it is the driver of photosynthesis, primary plant productivity and oxygen regeneration. Current average global temperatures (estimated at around 15°C) reflect a global recovery from the 500-year Little Ice Age (1300–1850). This is not an emergency. The Earth is 9°C cooler in the modern era than the global average of 24°C throughout the last 540 million years of biological history. Plant and animal species do not rely on static temperatures either, as the planet drifts between cold glaciations and warm interglacials. Indeed, they flourish through resilience, migration and expansion. Life on land has survived at least five major extinction events, but life always recovered from these setbacks and new species emerged. Viewed through this dual lens - with orbital regularity above and biological adaptability below - planetary history has not been a sequence of sudden emergencies. It has evolved in natural, orderly progressions, where life readjusted itself to the rhythms of the solar system. IMAGE: Earth's long-term global average temperature has spent most of geological history fluctuating between 20°C and 35°C (Judd et al., 2024) — significantly higher than today's colder baseline of roughly 15°C.

Post attachment