
HOT POTATO 4 - THE PATIENT LIED. THE FAMILY KNEW THE TRUTH. WE ASKED THE PATIENT. In my last post I showed you the number: around one in three people who test positive for amphetamines deny using. If the person in the chair cannot be relied on to tell you the truth, there is an obvious question. Who can? The family. And they are the one source the system walks straight past. Think about what the family actually holds. Every professional gets a snapshot. The doctor gets five minutes. The hospital gets one bad night. The counsellor gets an hour a week, filtered through whatever the person chooses to say. The family gets years. They were there before the first using and after the last crisis. When researchers compare a family member's account against a patient's own, the family history method picks up substance problems and patterns the patient leaves out. They are often the more accurate record, precisely because they are not the one being assessed. And here is what makes them impossible to fool. The person performs for professionals because professionals hold something they want, a bed, a script, their freedom, a tick in a box. They cannot perform for the people who live with them, because those people have watched the act a thousand times. The family is the one source in the whole system that is not being managed and not being told what it wants to hear. So it is almost unbelievable what we do. A person is assessed in crisis, off a story they told to get through the night, and a diagnosis is written. Meanwhile the mother in the waiting room, who could say "he has been using meth for three months and was completely fine before that," is never properly asked. The most accurate information in the building is sitting in the corridor, treated as background noise. I know the objection, and it is fair. Confidentiality. And some families are not safe, some are part of the damage. That is real and it has to be handled with care. But there is a world of difference between protecting a person from a dangerous family and ignoring a loving one who holds the answer. Right now we too often do the second in the name of the first. The fix costs nothing. When the person in front of you cannot or will not tell it straight, you do not stake their whole future on a single interview with them. You pick up the phone. You ask the people who watched the whole thing unfold. You put their account next to his and you see where the two do not line up. The family is not in the way of the diagnosis. Most of the time, the family is the diagnosis. We just have to start asking them. Cold hard facts. Sourced. Corrected when wrong. What's your thoughts…? Peter Lyndon-James 🇦🇺 Sources: Murrie, Lappin et al, transition of substance-induced psychosis to schizophrenia, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 2020 (Australian-led NDARC meta-analysis, 50 studies); Wilcox et al, self-report vs urine drug screen concordance, Addictive Behaviors, 2013; Bramness et al, amphetamine-induced psychosis, BMC Psychiatry, 2012; Hong, psychosis in borderline personality disorder, The Hospitalist; Rice et al, family history method vs direct interview, 1995. The transition study is Australian; the remaining clinical figures are from international literature, the facts apply here but the research was done overseas.











