←
Phil Gordon1,001 posts
Phil Gordon avatar✓

Phil Gordon ✓

@PhilGordonDC

Sydney Stein, Jr., Scholar, Brookings. White House, NSC, and State Dept in Biden, Obama and Clinton admins. Author, Losing the Long Game.

◷ Joined January 2025▧ 5 Photos and videos
Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·2h

Hard to criticize the new UK sanctions for failing to distinguish between established blocs and illegal outposts or projects like E1 when Israel's foreign minister essentially says settlers can build wherever they want. If that’s the Israeli government's view, hard to blame the UK or others for imposing costs rather than acquiescing in de facto annexation. Also seems both reasonable and inevitable that some of the sanctions affect firms based inside the Green Line. It would be an odd sanctions policy to exempt companies that supported targeted activities so long as they were not based in the territory where such activities took place. The obvious way for companies to avoid sanctions for supporting settlement expansion is for them to stop supporting it.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·22h

As I told @yarotrof, Trump sees China’s and Russia’s attempts to bully their smaller neighbors as the perfectly normal behavior of great powers but resents it when smaller powers push back—hence the angry outbursts at Zelenskyy, Carney, Lula, and the NATO allies who rebuffed him on Greenland and Iran. This worldview helps explain why Trump has better relations with Xi and Putin than with most democratic leaders. The three summiteers also share a tendency to underestimate the determination of smaller nations to resist their bullying and aggression, as Ukraine has been demonstrating for more than four years. Far from being remembered as Yalta 2.0, the summit will most likely be remembered as one more sign of Trump's affinity for dictators, if it is remembered at all.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·22h

As I told @yarotrof, Trump sees China’s and Russia’s attempts to bully their smaller neighbors as the perfectly normal behavior of great powers but resents it when smaller powers push back—hence the angry outbursts at Zelenskyy, Carney, Lula, and the NATO allies who rebuffed him on Greenland and Iran. This worldview helps explain why Trump has better relations with Xi and Putin than with most democratic leaders. The three summiteers also share a tendency to underestimate the determination of smaller nations to resist their bullying and aggression, as Ukraine has been demonstrating for more than four years. Far from being remembered as Yalta 2.0, the summit will most likely be remembered as one more sign of Trump's affinity for dictators, if it is remembered at all.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Nov 9

Negotiations to end the war are welcome. But in the runup to these talks the Trump admin struck a deal to allow for the purchase of sanctioned diesel from Russia; waived the sanctions on Russian oil purchasers in the Lindsey Graham Act; berated Zelensky and called for new leadership in Ukraine; pressed Kyiv to halt attacks on Russian refineries; stalled the transfer of allied-funded Patriot interceptors to Ukraine; reportedly restricted Ukraine's access to satellite communications; and hosted and honored Putin envoy Dmitriev at the White House. For a president so obsessed with leverage, you would think these would be steps that could be floated as possible outcomes of a negotiation rather than unilateral concessions made ahead of them.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Nov 9

At a time of collapsing US and global support for Israel, the Israeli foreign ministry decides that what is needed is a flippant tweet about flooded tent camps in Gaza.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Nov 7

It also means Liberman would rather abandon his insistence on Haredi military service (central not just to the opposition's campaign but to the principle of equality) than join a government that relied even passively on the Arab parties that represent 20% of Israel's citizens. And if restoring the broken relationship with US Democrats is among Israel's goals, treating those citizens' elected representatives as illegitimate doesn't seem like a good way to get there.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Nov 7

Kushner's post is what you get when you put diplomatic negotiations in the hands of businessmen who have little experience with the issues, contempt for experts (and Europeans), potential financial incentives for deals with Russia, and a naive belief in the power of personal relationships with Russian leaders and officials. The problem with the post is less its description of perfectly reasonable objectives for European security than the apparent unawareness that the agreements, institutions, and mechanisms proposed to achieve them have been in place for decades and that Russia has repeatedly violated them. So long as Trump's diplomacy in Europe and Ukraine is based on the notion that Europe and Russia are equally responsible for the current state of affairs (or worse that Europe and Ukraine are more to blame than Moscow), it will only reinforce Russia's false hope that it can achieve its strategic and territorial ambitions in Europe.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Oct 29

If striking 11,000 targets and a months-long blockade failed to produce Iranian collapse or capitulation, what would a “short, intense” military campaign produce—other than Iranian and Houthi retaliation against shipping, pipelines, and airports, another oil price spike, more casualties, and further erosion of public and regional support for the war? If reports like this are just the umpteenth time since the April ceasefire that Trump has threatened escalation to get a “better deal,” more power to him. But if it’s an actual operational plan, it’s likely to prove as counterproductive as the previous rounds.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Oct 29

Rob, the hypocrisy is touting that Arab citizens can vote as a sign of democracy and inclusivity while treating their chosen representatives—even those who sat in the government only a few years ago—as unacceptable even as outside supporters of an alternative coalition…when the alternative is a government that includes racists and extremists and a national security minister who was convicted of supporting a terrorist organization; parties that want to annex the West Bank, settle Gaza, and expel Palestinians; and non-Zionist Haredi parties whose constituents largely refuse to serve in the military even in wartime. Obviously opposition leaders have every right to judge such a coalition as the “lesser evil”—but if that’s their choice, it is hard to point to Arab citizens’ right to vote as evidence of their meaningful political inclusion. I did not say this was an easy decision but if it's the one they make it would be a telling one.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Oct 28

All the proud declarations that Israel’s democracy gives 2 million Arab citizens the vote will ring increasingly hollow if the opposition refuses to govern with their support — even if that means leaving Netanyahu in power.

Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Oct 25

I spoke with @RavivDrucker about the debate over Netanyahu's role in the failure to secure a ceasefire/hostage deal before January 2025.

3:59
Phil Gordon avatar
Phil Gordon@PhilGordonDC·Oct 24

Quite the closing argument for Netanyahu to acknowledge his legacy is the end of US military aid and his re-election would mean sanctions, isolation and reliance on cryptocurrency. No illusions about opposition but they would at least try to avoid this future.