I reviewed NY's data-center "moratorium" so you don't have to. The bottom line: it's not just a one-year delay for the biggest facilities. It's an open-ended mess that would create permanent obstacles for building even relatively small data processors.
city-journal.org/article/new…
Taxing electricity the same way you tax everything else (4.5% NYC sales tax) is fine. But when you combine all 3 NYC taxes (ConEd prop tax, the GRT and sales tax), you're taxing delivery at over 36%. That's higher than the tax on weed!
I hear this concern often. The electricity generation is nice, but you can't bring a kilowatt-hour home on the subway or in a gas can. Electricity delivery (transmission to your area, distribution to your meter) is the most valuable part of the service.
As I explained in this @ManhattanInst report, NYC has been squeezing billions from the electric grid, mainly via property taxes (a cost passed directly to customers).
manhattan.institute/article/…
Con Edison's new proposed bill design is going to shock the senses. NYC residents are about to learn they're paying roughly as much in taxes as they are the electricity commodity itself.
“You don’t have to do a thing,” Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) said in September. “No application. No paperwork. No hoops to jump through — if you’re eligible, the check is coming to you.”
timesunion.com/capitol/artic…
On Friday, Hydro-Québec said it could suspend power deliveries to the United States for brief periods. Its reservoirs are low.
Québec’s dams run on rivers, and the rivers have been short for three years. In 2023, three northern rivers hit record lows. In 2024, four more did. This year the typical river is running 16 percent below normal. Hydro-Québec puts the three-year shortfall at 108 terawatt-hours, about two-thirds of what New York uses in a year.
For years Québec sent New York about 10,000 gigawatt-hours a year. In 2023 that fell by three quarters. In 2024 it reversed. Last year and again this year, New York has sent more power to Québec than it got back, even counting the new cable into New York City.
Since the cable opened in May, it has delivered about 1,100 gigawatt-hours to the city. Over the same months, the older lines upstate sent 2,600 north.
Where did the northbound power come from? About half from New York’s gas and oil plants. About half from more imports, mostly from Pennsylvania and New Jersey. Almost none from New York’s own dams.
New Yorkers were told for years that this cable would help replace Indian Point: by Riverkeeper in 2017, by Hydro-Québec and the developer in 2021, and by the governor’s office this June. When the grid operator studied the closure in 2017, it counted on three new gas plants. The cable is not in that study. For winter, grid planners count on zero megawatts from the cable, November through April.
Last Saturday the cable delivered about 790 megawatts to New York City. New York sent 800 back north.
Sources: NYISO interface flows and fuel mix; Hydro-Québec third-quarter bulletin, 2025 results and Supply Plan 2027–2041; Québec environment ministry river gauges; The Globe and Mail, Nov. 13, 2026; NYISO Indian Point deactivation assessment, Dec. 13, 2017. Satellite images: NASA, Copernicus Sentinel-2.
The New York GOP hasn't controlled the Assembly since 1974. For them to get to 76 seats, they'd need to win the sorts of seats where their candidates got ~31% this time around.
Possible in two years? No.
Impossible in two decades? No.
These are incomplete data but they give a sense of the hole the New York GOP must climb out of: they won 15/63 Senate seats. To win 32 (a majority), they'll need to win the sorts of seats where their candidates got 33% to 35% this cycle.
New: Join us @NYLawSchool on Dec. 8 for "Mamdani's Agenda in the Balance: The Path Ahead on Taxing & Spending," featuring 4 experts on New York fiscal policy, economic trends, & governance — hosted w/ @NYCPolicyForum.
RSVP: nyls.wufoo.com/forms/mamdani…
For federal taxpayers to kick in 20 percent of unionized labor costs to help workers who have priced themselves out of the market would be insane. And yes, this is the definition of a Hollywood subsidy