←
David Bernstein44,712 posts
David Bernstein avatar

David Bernstein

@ProfDBernstein

My views are my own and do not reflect the views of my university or the state of Virginia.

◷ Joined December 2013▧ 1,742 Photos and videos
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·1h

"This is what western activists call 'the Resistance.' They turn real tragedy and oppressive systems into a fantasy fiction. One that allows them to feel like heroes of a story they never have to live."

This is Sogand Sayadi, a 16 year old girl who was killed in Iran yesterday for her sexuality. The school summoned her father after a rumor began circulating that Sogand was a lesbian. He arrived, beat her, and repeatedly slammed her head against the wall in front of other students. Sogand begged the school to keep her, saying her father would kill her. The school sent her home with him anyway. She was thrown off a five story building and killed. Under the Islamic Penal Code, fathers are immune from retribution, “qisas,” for killing their own children, effectively permitting honor killings. This is what western activists call “the Resistance.” They turn real tragedy and oppressive systems into a fantasy fiction. One that allows them to feel like heroes of a story they never have to live.

Post attachment
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·1h

Short version: Moser knows very little about the history of Zionism and Israel, and most of what he knows is made up. But that's okay, because Israel is an illegitimate settler-colonial state, so truth is not important when it conflicts with the need to destroy it.

5/5 Enjoy the show... Our Interview with Benjamin Moser 0:00 Noam: "This interview did not go as I hoped" 2:16 "Moserism": the opening statement on Lincoln and Balfour 14:55 Herzl's "genitals" line: diary or letter? 22:41 Herzl's mass-conversion plan and the Penslar tape 31:01 "Did European Jews have the right to come to Palestine?" 49:56 Why did Iraq's Jews leave? Avi Shlaim and the Baghdad bombs 58:42 Who started the Six-Day War? 1:13:22 After Moser leaves: Dan and Periel weigh in

1:24:15
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·2h

Begin's autonomy plans were and are very underrated, and would have, if implemented, led to a better outcome on all sides than anything that's been proposed since.

Menachem Begin proposed giving the Palestinians a near-veto on future Israeli settlement activity in late 1980. So Likud would have given the Palestinians better terms than Oslo did and over a decade sooner. 🤷‍♂️

Post attachment
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·2h

"Jews and Muslims lived together in harmony before Israel" is very much analogous to "blacks and whites in the South lived together in harmony before civil rights agitators."

If critics of Zionism and Jewish self-determination didn’t want Jews to re-create a polity in the homeland that every one of our holidays and so much of our history is tied to, be it Tu Bishvat marking the blossoming of the trees **in Israel**, Sukkot celebrating the harvest **in Israel**, or Hanukkah celebrating the rededication of the Temple after the revolt against the Seleucids **in Israel**, then the correct solution, in both Europe **and** the Middle East, was to not treat Jews like second-class citizens on a good day and vermin on a bad one. Under the rule of the caliphs, Jews and Christians were categorized as dhimmi, or “protected” peoples. Under such terms, they paid a special tax, the jizya, and received the state’s “protection” in return. That “protection” entailed the following: they could not bear arms, ride horses, build new places of worship or repair existing ones, and they were required to dress in ways that set them apart. Some rulers made these restrictions into rituals of public humiliation. In Egypt, the Fatimid caliph al-Hakim, who ruled from 996 to 1021, forced Jews to wear black robes, to put on bells when entering bathhouses, and to hang a wooden calf around their necks whenever they appeared in public. Fez saw six thousand of its Jews slaughtered in 1033, and its Jewish community was attacked and massacred twice more, in 1276 and again in 1465. In Spain, Granada suffered a similar fate in 1066, when roughly three thousand Jews lost their lives. Moroccan Jews faced further killings in 1790, and in 1912 the Jewish quarter of Fez was basically wiped out. What happened to the Jews of Damascus in 1840 under the watch of Muhammad Ali's Egypt? Why were 63 Jewish children kidnapped and imprisoned? It was because the Egyptian authorities, encouraged by the French consul, thought the Jews had disappeared a friar and stolen his blood to make matzah for Passover. A blood libel to a T. How about Yemen? Jews were pressured to convert, and orphans were seized from their families and forced to give up their religion. The community had to smuggle those who had lost their parents to British-controlled Aden to prevent this from happening. The same thing happened in Mashhad, Iran, in 1839 - forcible conversions of 700 families under the threat of death. Maimonides wrote the following to the Jews of Yemen **in 1172** in what is known as the Epistle to Yemen. They had initially written to him for advice, as they were being pressured to convert by the local authorities: “God has hurled us in the midst of this people, who have persecuted us severely, and passed baneful and discriminatory legislation against us, as Scripture has forewarned us.… Never did a nation molest, degrade, debase and hate us as much as they.” Jews were murdered, confined, kidnapped, and forcibly converted across the entire Middle East, culminating in hundreds of thousands of them being ethnically cleansed from their home countries in the region after Israel was founded. There are barely any Jews left in any of the lands of the caliphs because they were expelled. Any attempt to whitewash this history under the notion that everything was kumbaya before Israel was founded is a total bastardization in the pursuit of a geopolitical objective: the destruction of the world's only Jewish state. The only way all of this can be reconciled is by trying to attack Israel's legitimacy by saying none of this ever happened and that the connective tissue between Jews and this particular place is ahistorical. It's a total farce, but that's the only the only card left to play, because not doing this means the entire house of cards comes tumbling down.

David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·20h

Also the case in the beginning of the war, the IDF reasonably feared full-scale Hezbollah and maybe even Iranian participation, something that Israel couldn't handle if it had a very active southern front. So Hamas had to be hit hard and fast. /end

David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·20h

It's easy to say "go much slower" when it's not your relatives who are being tortured in Hamas dungeons.

Senator Mark Kelly on Gaza: What Israel should have done in Gaza is they should have gone much slower. They should have used guided munitions and not a lot of unguided.

0:10
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·22h

Why is that almost to a person, no "Pro-Palestinian" activist or politician, in response to the humanitarian situation in Gaza, will say "we call on Israel to facilitate more aid to Gaza and for Hamas to relinquish its weapons so the war can end and reconstruction can begin?" It's almost as if they think it's more important to deny Israel a victory, even against the brutal terrorist dictatorship primarily responsible for Gazans' suffering, than to actually help Palestinians. (Actually, it's exactly like that!)

David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 17

"the most recent school year, approximately 73% of students were in poverty" Crazy stat. Poverty rate in NYC is 25%, so the vast majority of the non-poor either pay for private school or leave the city when they have kids.

Today my office has released a major new report on student enrollment in NYC. We found that k-12 enrollment in our public schools has fallen by 187k since 2013, with a projected decline of an additional 128k students by 2034. As total enrollment declines, NYCPS is serving a student population with growing needs. The number of students with disabilities is increasing. In the most recent school year, approximately 73% of students were in poverty and 14% were homeless or living in temporary housing. Our report finds the drop in enrollment is driven by declining births and families with children leaving NYC, with a particularly notable drop in public-school enrollment as students transition from elementary to middle school. These trends have massive implications for our schools that we have only barely begin to grapple with. My hope is that this report will spur a long overdue conversation about what the era of falling student enrollment means for NYC, and what we can do to reverse or slow it. 🧵

Post attachmentPost attachment
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 17

Can you guess who wrote this?: "I know a great many cultivated, highly educated and delightful Japanese. They have all told me that they would feel the same repugnance and objection to having thousands of Americans settle in Japan and intermarry with the Japanese as I would feel in having large numbers of Japanese come over here and intermarry with the American population. In this question, then, of Japanese exclusion from the United States, it is necessary only to advance the true reason – the undesirability of mixing the blood of the two peoples."

David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 17

I would say that having someone who is both a lawyer and generally honest would be beneficial in staffing such a course.

CANCEL CULTURE I was scheduled to teach my signature course, The Laws of War, at Brooklyn College in the upcoming Spring semester. The class was the first in the Political Science department to be closed out (fully enrolled). Last week I was informed that Dean Philip Napoli abruptly cancelled the course. If you wish to register your opinion of his action, you can reach him and Brooklyn College’s president here: Dean Philip Napoli pnapoli@brooklyn.cuny.edu 718.951.3136 President Michele Anderson bcpresident@brooklyn.cuny.edu 718.951.5671

David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 16

Living in tents when it sometimes rains and your Hamas government has dug up all the drainage pipes for military use has to be very unpleasant, but the coordinated tweets today about the "severe winter conditions in Gaza" is something.

Post attachment
David Bernstein avatar
⟳ David Bernstein retweeted
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 16

Reminder that "Hispanic" identity was made up by government bureaucrats in the 1970s.

Post attachment
David Bernstein avatar
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 16

In short, he is saying that there will be no armed police immediately on hand when violent (or potentially violent) protests break out in front of synagogues and other Jewish community activities. He refers to protests as "First Amendment activity" and explicitly states that police will neither be armed nor have crowd control gear and equipment with them, instead there will be unarmed "de-escalation teams." @TheJusticeDept needs to look into this, and investigate whether NYC is meeting the statutory requirements of non-discrimination and the like for the federal money it gets.

We are disbanding the SRG.

1:42
David Bernstein avatar
⟳ David Bernstein retweeted
David Bernstein@ProfDBernstein·Nov 15

The most important thing about watching this video is to understand that many "antizionists" in the West believe that threatening Jews in the disapora is a perfectly acceptable, indeed commendable, way to advance their version of the Palestinian cause. This is why Jews on college campuses have been subjected to a wave of violence, intimidation, and threats, why Philly bike-riders wanted to intimidate Jewish businesses, why Jews are being harassed more generally all over the country. It's what "globalizing the intifada" means in practice. And "antizionist" politicians like Mamdani and El Sayed, instead of forthrightingly condemning this, turn questions about it back to Israel. Jews and their friends need to be 100% clear on this, as a total red line: we don't care what your views are on Israel/the Palestinians, how deeply you feel them, or what your colonial studies professor told you: the rights of Jews in the the US, Canada, and other countries, like the rights of all other citizens, are completely non-negotiable, and any politician who thinks or acts otherwise is not fit to hold office.

Palestinian Nationalist Laith Marouf issued an ultimatum to "anti-Zionist Jews" like Ben Moser: Lead an anti-Zionist revolution and take control of all Jewish synagogues, schools, organizations and institutions OR you will be Holocausted again. This is what BadEmpanada ("George of Patmos") and Barak Mayer is demanding too. Anything less than that is "upholding Zionism". (And while Benjamin "Moser" Moser claims that anti-Zionism means Arabs and Jews living in love and peace in a one-state solution, Marouf, Aladwan and other Palestinian nationalists say all Jews will be expelled after Israel is destroyed.)

2:58