←
James Mitchell7,810 posts
James Mitchell avatar

James Mitchell

@ProfJMitchell

Professor of Public Policy, Edinburgh University

◷ Joined March 2014▧ 172 Photos and videos
Scott Wortley avatar
⟳ James Mitchell retweeted
Scott Wortley@Scott_Wortley·Nov 16

From my experience reviewing consultation responses at the scottish law commission and as an adviser to a holyrood committee pro forma consultation responses to policy consultations are rarely helpful or taken into account. Individual responses tend to matter more.

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 15

The extremely brief paper on local govt reorganisation is both inadequate and has the oddest starting point. Form must follow function not other way around as in the paper.

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 15

These reforms should not be rushed. So many parts including finance, relations with other public services to be considered. There isn't the necessary joined-up thinking at the moment.

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 15

As a start...holyrood.com/inside-politics… I've studied previous major reforms - late 1920s, late 1940s, 1970s and 1990s - each including the last which was the most rushed of these was far better prepared than this one.

I see this is about housing. What do you make of the current local govt reforms ?

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 15

I see some of usual lot jumping on what they perceive to be the latest bandwagon of public service reform/local govt reorganisation. Best ignored and best to read, engage with those with real track record of expertise and engagement.

Ken has been thinking and writing about this for 40 odd years. He's contributed to every enquiry, commission, debate (no shortage of them even if not much progress). Absence of reform has made situation worse as each year passes. Time for change. scotsman.com/news/scrap-dysf…

James Mitchell avatar
⟳ James Mitchell retweeted
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 15

Ken has been thinking and writing about this for 40 odd years. He's contributed to every enquiry, commission, debate (no shortage of them even if not much progress). Absence of reform has made situation worse as each year passes. Time for change. scotsman.com/news/scrap-dysf…

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 11

Allan wrote on this subject some years ago including a very good PhD thesis. It's a topic that cannot be divorced from any serious reorganisation. Ken's 'rubik's cube trilemma' in comprehensive reform; sorting finances; allocation of competences/powers; geography of authorities.

History (and crisis) keeps repeating itself on the issue of local taxation in the UK while academics do sterling analysis that is often ignored. Don’t ignore this one from @Gibb6781 @ProfJMitchell

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 11

Launch of @Gibb6781 book today. Ken's been studying + writing about this important topic for 40 years. An excellent study, should be read by all engaged with topic. Important recommendations.

Post attachment
James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 7

Only if there are proper elections and not stitch-ups.

I've long advocated paying recognition for committee convenors at Holyrood. Committees should be at the heart of scrutiny and challenge to government. This won't transform things overnight, but it's a welcome step towards strengthening their role.

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 6

only one convener was elected - remaining 15 unopposed. Travesty of elected conveners. Hence the 'fuss'.

James Mitchell avatar
James Mitchell@ProfJMitchell·Nov 6

That's a much higher responsibility allowance than expected.

With no additional payment this time there were no contested elections for committee conveners - you can bet your boots there will be next time if there is 20 grand at stake