←
Jared Medina341 posts
Jared Medina avatar

Jared Medina

@ProfJaredMedina

Assoc. Prof. at @EmoryPsychology. I study touch, body representations and multisensory perception. ❤️ cognitive neuropsychology.

◷ Joined October 2013▧ 35 Photos and videos
Zhiqing Deng avatar
⟳ Jared Medina retweeted
Zhiqing Deng@DengZhiqin26479·Sep 23

🧠Excited to share that our paper has been accepted at PNAS! We found a hierarchical plasticity in people born without hands: SI remains largely constrained by somatotopy, while SII shows experience-driven reweighting toward the feet. ❤️Thanks to @StriemAmit @YuqiLiu95703261 @MartinezAddiego pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.26…

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

We propose a potential fix that keeps 48 teams: a pod system. The top two qualify, the 12 groups form 4 pods of 3, and the best group winners get byes to the Round of 16. Competitive final games rise from 33% to 62%, and dead rubbers fall from 28% to 8%. 13/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

But opportunity isn't behavior. We tested 224 final-matchday games from every World Cup and Euro since 1994. Teams drew more when a draw was mutually beneficial (p=.003). In 2026, betting markets priced it before kickoff. 12/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

The Round of 32 also costs elite teams (top-8 ranked). Eliminated before the Round of 16: 1.22 under 2022 rules, 2.55 under 2026. Under 2022 rules, three or more elite teams go out in 10% of tournaments. 2026 rules: 51%. 11/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Regarding collusion opportunities (often called biscotti), if teams took every pact the format offers, 43% of tournaments would see a team that qualified on merit knocked out. 10/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

The final group matchday becomes much less interesting. Comparing the 2022 to 2026 format, genuinely competitive final group matches fall from 61% to 33%. Dead rubbers rise from 10% to 28%. And collusion opportunities rise fourfold. 9/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Given that even teams with 3 points and a decent goal differential qualify for the knockouts, the format incentivizes running up the score against the weakest group opponent. 8/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

We used hundreds of thousands of tournament simulations (under various conditions) and actual team performance to quantify how the tournament format shapes incentives, and whether it actually influences team behavior. A summary of the main findings: 7/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Finally, a 32-team knockout round shifted jeopardy from the group stage to first knockout game. This created a risk in which one bad performance against a bunkering team could eliminate a contender (e.g., Germany-Paraguay). 6/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Third, FIFA promoted a head-to-head tiebreaker over goal difference. Combined with the third-place rule, it adds additional "dead rubbers" (meaningless matches: e.g., USA-Turkey). 5/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Second, teams in early groups don't know the bar for the best third-placed teams and are left guessing (e.g. S. Korea, 3rd of 12 groups to finish). Teams who play last know exactly what they need, and are handed collusion opportunities (e.g. Algeria-Austria). 4/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

First, over 99% of teams qualify from the group stage with four points (1W-1D-1L). This incentivizes draws for teams who go into the final group game with 3 points (e.g. Paraguay-Australia). 3/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

For 2026, FIFA expanded from 32 to 48 teams. The original plan was 16 groups of 3, but @julienguyon1977 and others noted the collusion risk, so FIFA switched to 12 groups of 4, with the top two plus the 8 best third-placed teams advancing. That created new problems. 2/14

Jared Medina avatar
Jared Medina@ProfJaredMedina·Aug 4

Does the 2026 World Cup format create bad incentives? And do teams actually act on them? Short answers: yes and yes. Our new preprint is out: "Formats Shape Incentives: A Quantitative Evaluation of the 2026 FIFA World Cup and Alternative Designs." Link in the last post. 1/14