←
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.20,333 posts
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.

@ProfVemsani

Distinguished Univ Professor@SSU multi-award Fulbright Honorary Prof@JNU 8Books Board:OAH,HAF,HUA,ICHRRF; Editor-in-Chief, Intnl Jrnl of Indic Rel;Pres,OAH,AAIS

◷ Joined November 2013▧ 679 Photos and videos
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·10h

And the biggest problem of the Ramayana film was force fitting the epic Ramayana into the artificial Colonialist-Marxist frameworks of oppressor vs. oppressed. It’s never going to achieve the depth of Valmiki Ramayana. The entire emotional state of Ramayana and Dharmic framework Valmiki carries in the original composition is missing from the recent Ramayana movie which renders it shallow and difficult to watch. Tried to watch it twice but couldn’t sit through it. Epic failure! It’s not the small changes that make it uncomfortable to the devoted viewers but the whole outlook of the Ramayana film and its lack of emotional depth.

A nukkad Ramlila with Bhakti will have more impact than a grand spectacle with contrived bhakti. And a contrived narrative. I found Hanuman Ansh spectacularly moving in comparison, no budget. The key of good storytelling is not spectacle but getting the audience to relate to the characters. Even the hyped Ravan is random. One moment he is playing a musical instrument in a cave; next moment he is undergoing the biggest penance ever in the three worlds. Just because "my mamma told me" is very weak. No one gets motivated for that kind of earth-shaking one-pointed sadhana on a random conversation. We never get the character arc. And if you don't have time to build it, drop it. Also the rakshasas (conflated with Asuras) as some kind of enslaved people is again pushing an unnecessary agenda. They were exiled, not in slavery or poverty.

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·11h

Was that the “mohabbat ki Dukan” Someone mentioned?

ANI@ANI16h

#WATCH | On Sonia Gandhi's memoir 'Belonging: A Journey of Love', Congress leader Supriya Shrinate says, "Look at the kind of people we are dealing with. Mrs Gandhi's memoir is out. Have you seen Kangana's stories? It looks like a deranged mind. I don't worry about what she's saying. I worry about the fact that somebody with no sound mind is in Parliament. The kind of things that she's written about her and not about her citizenship... I read it because it was unputdownable for me, and nobody asked me to read it... It is a love story. I think it is; at the bedrock of it, a love story, and all that happened in her life was on account. She was 21 years old when she travelled here to marry Rajiv Gandhi... For 23 years of those 60 years, she has lived as Rajiv Gandhi's wife and, for a much larger part of it, as his widow. Do people realise when they say the kind of things that they do? Have you seen the kind of nonsense the BJP talks about her? Her personal memoir will touch upon her mother-in-law, who happens to be the Prime Minister..." Watch Full Episode Here: youtu.be/DHEBUvsp0Jo

4:54
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·12h

I don’t know how this artificial theory lasted this long! Hope people wake up to truth. #ReclaimHistory #DecolonizeHistory

What amazes me is that the theory has lasted so long. Follow its history and it keeps changing shape, because it was weak from the start. It began as an idea about languages, with Schlegel around 1808. By Gobineau's Essay on the Inequality of the Human Races in the 1850s, a family of languages had become a conquering race. Max Muller, who did more than anyone to spread the "Aryan race," withdrew the phrase himself in 1888. Marshall, who first announced the Indus cities in 1924, dated them deep into the past and saw in them the roots of later Hinduism. My understanding is that he was removed from the project because his dating and his continuity conflicted with the grand narrative. Then Wheeler wrote "Indra stands accused" and gave the theory its massacre. In 1964 Dales found no massacre. So the invasion became a "migration," and now the migration has become genetics. Each version arrived as the last one collapsed, and the conclusion never moved. When the conclusion comes first, the evidence has to be found afterwards to fit it. That is how "Indra stands accused" ended up in our children's textbooks, while at the dhuni Indra was never on trial.

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·12h

#Left is good at performance theatre!

Zohran Mamdani praises the Hindu epics: “The Ramayana shows us the brother, wife, husband and friend we desire to be. The Mahabharata shows us what families are really like, where even the bravest heroes and wisest gods stumble..”

0:31
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·13h

Colonialist theory: “Invaders vs. indigenous” Exactly, the original colonialist narrative was “invader vs. indigenous” construed as two warring races with the artificial Aryans as invaders. FYI #NoAryans but that didn’t stop colonialists and surprisingly that “Indra stands accused” excerpt was included in NCERT school textbooks until recently. Rebranding by the Left as “Oppressor vs. oppressed” And Left/Marxist historians under the aegis of the High Priestess of history embraced that theory of invader vs. indigenous changing it to class theory rebranding it as “oppressor vs. oppressed”. These Colonialist and Marxist narratives are not as innocent as they seem. They are created to twist your mind, infuse self-hatred and servility. They make you zombies. Unfortunately, I am also included in this ‘you’. I only came out of these narratives 2-decades ago.

For most of the twentieth century, the textbooks said the Indus cities were destroyed by invaders. In 1947 Mortimer Wheeler wrote that "Indra stands accused". Aryans from the steppe, he argued, had massacred the inhabitants of Mohenjo-daro. In 1964 the American archaeologist George Dales re-examined the "massacre" and found a handful of skeletons from different periods, none of them the victims of a battle. No archaeologist defends the invasion now. What ended the cities was water. At Mohenjo-daro, Dales found massive brick platforms built to lift the city above floodwater. Along the Sarasvati there was too little. The Sutlej had swung away around 2500 BC, and lake sediments in Haryana record a drought lasting some two hundred years from around 2100 BC. Then the western market collapsed with the fall of Ur in 2004 BC. Drains went uncleared, public buildings filled with squatters, and people buried their jewellery and left. Episode 4 of my graphic novel, Maritime World: The True Cradle, is called The River That Died. Link in the reply.

Post attachment
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·14h

The Left has done everything to spread #Hinduphobia through textbook narratives and public #antiHindu propaganda events such as “Holi Against Hindutva”. It’s become difficult for simple Hindus to celebrate festivals or simply be Hindu on college campuses in the USA. Infused race into Hinduism Reinterpretation of Hindu epics with oppressed vs. oppressor beginning with Aryans (FYI #NoAryans), “demons as oppressed class and identical to Dalits” is Colonial interpretation but Left promotes it as truth incorporating into all texts and works of history of Hinduism thus presenting everything related to Hindus and Hinduism is evil. This is one of the reasons they don’t want Aryan invasion or migration theory to be denounced. That would pronounce their artificial racist theories of “oppressed vs. oppressor” useless. Unless the Left denounces these colonialist anti-Hindu narratives and stops promoting anti-Hindu activities on college campuses their wishes are just theatre. Please read this: academia.edu/90219272/GLOBAL…

Not everyone is going to wax lyrical about the Ramayana and Mahabharata like Mamdani, but no Democrat gets into trouble for wishing their constituents Happy Diwali. The idea that there’s some dark Democratic conspiracy against Hinduism is nonsense largely spun by Hindu nationalists who would like you to believe that criticizing a political party in India is the same as criticizing the faith of over a billion people.

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 17

That looks so heartbreakingly sad! Why is the baby elephant alone? So, if the baby elephant is born right there why not let the baby elephant breastfeed from the mother elephant. The baby can be supplemented with feedings but why not let the baby breastfed by the mother elephant? It’s tough for elephants to live in zoos why not let them have at least a little bit of solace?

Take a sneak peek at Storytime's next special guest — adorable baby elephant Linh Mai, who lives at the @NationalZoo 🐘 Full episode drops tomorrow!

1:03
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 17

Why do they kick, scream, and throw a tantrum every time we tell them no civilization altering invasion or migration ever happened. We know small numbers of people from outside came sometime but we’re thoroughly assimilated. Indian civilization developed independently and indigenously and influenced the premodern world in multiple ways. #NoAryans

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 16

When they say South Asia in media or modern scholarship, it’s always Pakistan, even in case of history. So, please be sure to check.

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 16

#NoAryans #NoYamnaya replacement in India Euro-centric scholarship projects European history onto India. Don’t fall for their half baked theories. For example, the recent hypothesis about Yamnaya spread and replacement is more consequential to Europe than India. 1. Yamnaya and their Caucusus to European links and replacement of European population Yamnaya male genome is dominated heavily by specific haplogroups, notably R1b Studies published in Nature and Science revealed that Yamnaya-derived male lineages swept through Bronze Age Europe, replacing up to 90% of native Y-chromosome lines in places like Britain and nearly 100% in Iberia within a few centuries, even as local maternal (mtDNA) lines survived to a greater degree 2. Yamnaya related genetic heritage R1b is rare or absent in India aplogroup R1b is generally very rare or largely absent across most of the Indian population, with average frequencies estimated to be around 1% to 5% in broad South Asian genetic surveys, and often near 0% in many specific regional or ethnic groups.

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 15

#NoAryans 1. Languages is not race. The linguistic theory is insufficient to explain Aryan race or their invasions or migrations. Nowhere was the term “Aryan” used as a race in the Vedas. It was just Arya that was found in the Vedas which signifies knowledge, refinement, or respect. 2. Lactose intolerance or tolerance is not linked to race or language. Indo-European language is not linked to lactose tolerance or intolerance. The European nations with Indo-European languages like Greece and Italy also have high lactose intolerance when compared to northern India. 3. And genetic history completely disproves the false Aryan invasion or migration theory. #NoAryans

Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D. avatar
Dr. Lavanya Vemsani Ph.D.@ProfVemsani·Nov 15

#NoAryans What’s the date of the Vedas? They decided it takes 200 years for something to go from oral record to literary record. This is based on their Bible experience. But they overrule the fact that the gap for oral to literary record might be different in the ancient world. Do you think the evidence of Mittani inscription is enough to fix the Vedas at 1500 BCE based on the assumption that it takes 200 for oral record to transition into literary record? But the Vedas still remain oral so how does one reconcile with that? How can one fix that date of origin of something that refuses the rules of oral to literary transmission?