I completely understand the ramifications of the Park Slope Food Co-op BDS vote and the passions running high on both sides, but can we all just be honest and admit this recent dust-up doesn’t hold a candle to the last big controversy:
Brownstone Brooklyn mommies sending their nannies to work their required co-op shifts.
Happening now in Tel Aviv: A couple hundred protesters mark 1,000 days since nine-year-old Haymanut Kasau went missing from an absorption center in northern Israel.
The investigation into her disappearance has been plagued by accusations of racism and negligence, including allegations that the police and Shin Bet have been unwilling to devote the same resources to the search that they would have if the missing child were white.
Her family has fought tirelessly for answers.
Bari's an open lesbian. Yes? And Ben Shapiro: he's supposed to be an orthodox Jew. Yes?
Yet both prattle on about how inseparable Judaism supposedly is from the modern state of Israel—this government that wasn't even imagined for not decades, not centuries, but millennia after the Jewish diaspora.
A charitable interpretation is that they're just trying to overcome differences and get along. Everyone wants to do that. That's nice.
A less charitable interpretation is that they're simply turning their backs to God to fashion a new religion in their own image, one which overlooks moral law to make a central idol out of a secular state, the practice of which new religion feels to them more enjoyable because it makes them feel superior to everyone else without their having to do anything but come out of the right vagina and talk a lot about how that matters more than anything.
I have spent years defending Israel’s right to protect its people. I’ve done it on television, on campuses, and here on my social media, and I stand by all of it. That is the reason I’m posting this.
On Monday night, a Palestinian woman named Fada Fheidat was shot dead at her home near Jericho. The facts are still disputed, and I lay out both the army’s account and her neighbors’ account in the video.
Israel’s case to the world rests on being a country that enforces its laws. Every time a violent minority in the West Bank acts without consequences, that case gets harder to make. Israeli soldiers are put at greater risk, and Israel’s enemies are handed exactly what they want. I served there, and I know how much the army has to carry already.
Israel’s friends should be the first to demand that the law be enforced. I will update this if the facts change.
Also very much worth noting what the Tikvah Fund is and what they fund: You received a gift article from Haaretz.
A U.S. Jewish Fund's Ambitious Bid to Put a Settler Elite in Control of Israel's Security - Israel Political News haaretz.com/israel-news/isra…
“The first thing that people need to do is inculcate this when your kid is three or four years old. I’m dead serious,” Ben Shapiro tells the crowd at the Tikvah Fund’s Jewish Leadership Conference.
Their solution to the problem of Jewish kids not being connected to Judaism (which, for them, means Israel) is to “put them in a Jewish bubble in their formative years” (Dan Senor) and spend “all of the resources in our community…” on “making Jewish day schools the price of Catholic schools” (Bari Weiss).
These people have never had a single meaningful conversation with young, disenfranchised anti-Zionist Jews.
For Bari and Ben and Dan, the college student who chooses to attend a freedom Seder at his school’s encampment over the Seder at Hillel or, chas v’shalom, his own family Seder is just a caricature – a pink-haired, pronoun-preferring JINO moron who only cares about Palestinian children because he thinks it’s cool. And because Qatar tricked him into it.
They have never actually sat down with a member of JVP or Not In Our Name, heard them talk about what it felt like when they learned their parents and teachers and rabbis had lied to them, or listened to them tell the story of trying to ask a question at Hebrew school only to be shamed or dismissed.
These three, and everyone else in the room with them – who already agree with everything they have to say – are so absolutely certain that the only possible reason someone could reject Israel and/or Judaism is that they are easily brainwashed.
So, of course, the solution is simply to brainwash them first.
Zero self-reflection. Zero accountability or responsibility. Just, “We are doing absolutely everything right. The only thing we get wrong is not doing it enough.”
Also: At the end of this clip, Bari tells a story about going to socialist summer camp and how that was her first encounter with socialism, which she now despises, THEREBY TOTALLY CONTRADICTING THEIR ENTIRE POSITION.
Because the one thing about Bari Weiss is that she might make some really terrible arguments.
But she’s also really terrible at making them
And just because, poor Hillel, all the other videos went viral and his did not: “Settlers do not commit their violence in the name of Judaism” and “Islamaphobia doesn’t exist… there are 200 million Muslims that are not just committing terror, they are doing it in the name of Islam… fearing a religion that has 300 million members that are committed to my death is not irrational” is WILD WORK.
The “Is it offensive/is it funny?”argument is futile. We’re just gonna go back and forth about those questions and no one is going to change anyone’s mind.
However, the idea that the people who have nominated themselves to “end Jew hatred” are going to accomplish that by perpetuating Muslim hatred is… crazy? Non-sensical? Asinine? Hard to find a word to adequately convey the stupidity of that premise.
I will never ever stop saying this: If you are handing over your money to these people, in any form - making a donation, paying conference fees or synagogue dues which fund their speaking engagements, buying the subscription/ticket/merch/book/ - because you think they are fighting antisemitism on your behalf, you have been duped.
Time to walk away.
I don’t disagree with you about any of those things - though I want to be clear that I very much do disagree with all of the fear-mongering and the vile hatred as it relates to Muslims, Arabs, Palestinians and… other Jews who disagree with them.
My issue here is with the tone-deaf, narcissistic, self-congratulations mixed with zero - and I mean zero - introspection. “Look at this amazing job we are doing fighting this problem that has (as you yourself point out) gotten so much worse under our watch.”
Just as an example: One of the recipients won her accolades solely by going on Instagram every day and telling people that the Iran war was a rescue mission to save the Iranian people and anyone who dares to say otherwise is obviously a terror-loving IRGC supporter. Did she ever walk back any of the absolute nonsense she spewed? Well, technically no. But look how beautiful her dresss is!
Shut it all down. Cancel every single dinner and gala and Night of 1000 Jewish Stars until you are ready to publish a statistic that proves you have actually accomplished even one step towards whatever is written on those weirdly-shaped glass trophies.
And in the meantime, lock yourselves in a room that isn’t a ballroom decorated with 50,000 dollars worth of flowers, and think about what you have done wrong - not “How can we do exactly the same thing only more so?” but truly what needs to change - maybe listen to the people who are actually building bridges, working towards real peace and understanding - the ones who don’t get nearly as much airtime or appreciation - and don’t come out until you are ready to admit you messed this up pretty badly.
(The Royal you, not you specifically unless you are a part of this circus)
These people spend all day, every day telling the rest of us just how bad antisemitism has gotten. How much worse it is getting by the moment. How nowhere is safe. Not New York City. Not Michigan. Not London. Not Amsterdam. Not our universities or our synagogues or the Equinox on 31st Street - the one with that trainer who wears a Palestinian flag pin.
The Jihadists are coming for our children, they prophecy. For our Western values. For our very democracy. Any day now, the terrorists are going to march into our towns and impose Sharia law.
The world is once again, not a safe place for Jews, they warn us. Over and over and over again.
Then, they get dressed up in tuxedos and fancy gowns, and they hand each other awards, and lavish praise on one another – for the incredible work they have done to make the world a safe place for Jews.
Hasbarah. Is. A. Grift.
One of the problems with the online discourse (other than bringing about the demise of civilization) is that when you talk about someone as an evil Jew-hating satanic liar who is both stupid and wrong in everything he says and everything he has ever said,
you look really f*cking stupid when he says one thing you agree with and all of a sudden you’re retweeting him. “Absolute mic drop from this respected expert who knows what he’s talking about!”
By the way, you all do this exact same thing with Hamas.
And the New York Times.
“I can’t believe I’m retweeting this goblin” is code for “you were useful to me as an enemy when what you were saying was antisemetic and now you’re even more useful to me as an ally if what you’re saying is pro-Israel and that’s even more important because it’s harder to find.”
I’m not often at a loss for words but today I can’t find any of them.
A popular Israeli “entertainment account” with nearly a million followers. 23,000 likes and counting. I’ll spare you the comments section.
Translation: Praise God - A few minutes ago, the IDF eliminated a 14 year old terrorist next to Shchem
For those who still don’t understand, here’s how it works:
A few days ago, a flyer for a planned pogrom was posted by a right-wing activist on his social media account (first photo).
Translation of the flyer: In light of recent events in Lod, in which Arab rioters have grown increasingly emboldened, we will hold an Israeli flag march. We’ll explain to everyone who this country belongs to and who its rightful owners are.
(Flag march, of course, is meant to invoke the annual Jerusalem Day flag march through the Old City of Jerusalem, when Jewish rioters are given free rein to terrorize Palestinian residents and business owners.)
The date is set for the 15th of November.
“Recent events” seems to be referring to an incident last week in which Arab residents of Lod, furious at Likud’s relentless attempts to delegitimize both Arab politicians and voters, went outside and honked their horns.
“Attacked with sirens (horns) and chants” is incredible. (Second photo)
That’s when right-wing provocateur (and perennial attention whore) Mordechai David steps in, leading his pathetic hangers-on through a mini Flag March of their own last night, which inevitably leads to a response from the Arab residents of Lod, who are understandably sick of this shit. (First video)
But wait, isn’t that clearly a provocation? Who’s gonna buy the version that Arabs attacked Jews when we can all clearly see exactly what happened?
Now it’s the media’s turn.
Israel Hayom (as a reminder, Israel’s most widely read newspaper, owned by Trump bestie and megadonor Miriam Adelson) comes out with this report: “Arabs and Jews clash, 11 suspects arrested,” and a short clip that only shows Arabs throwing rocks. The comment section whips itself into a racist, violent frenzy. (Second video)
All of this gets shared right back in the WhatsApp groups and on social media.
Interestingly enough, the original flyer appears to have disappeared. Mark my words, it or something similar will pop back up.
And now the phrase “in light of recent events” will have taken on a whole new meaning.
Regular people who are feeling afraid: Why won’t anyone take our concerns seriously?!?
Hasbarists, who nominated themselves to speak on everyone else’s behalf:
What an odd way to report this story. No mention that the first film is what brought Bari Weiss her first bout of notoriety, that she was heavily involved, that she and in the filmmakers we’re accused of conducting a witch hunt and trying to get anti-Israel professors fired , that it turned out some of the students interviewed weren’t even enrolled in the classes they were talking about. That it kicked off a national firestorm and launched Bari Weiss’ career.
The first film is simply described as “not fixing the problem” and later Weiss is actually mentioned, but only as “a noted media commentator” who is interviewed in the new film.
Genuine question. Do newspapers still have editors? (And if not, who keeps sending me notes on my pieces 🤔)