←
Rajiv Malhotra26,651 posts
Rajiv Malhotra avatar

Rajiv Malhotra

@RajivMessage

Researcher, author, speaker. Current affairs, inter-civilization, science. JOIN MY YAJNA: rajivmalhotra.com/get-involv…

◷ Joined May 2011▧ 2,110 Photos and videos
Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·14h

Agreed. In USA, presently: RW = Christian Supremacists LW = Woke (Islamic-Marxist Alliance)

You know what is interesting about this? Every single one of these “right wing” influencers has taken part in aggressive anti-Indian hate, anti H-1B hate and much more. Demonizing Indian talent working in America while allegedly promoting the sale of advanced American technology to China. These are the same clowns who lecture everyone about American national security and patriotism. America First? LOL.

Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 16

I would love to go thru the movie sound track or transcript in more detail. If anyone can get this for me, I am willing to pay so I can do a proper analysis.

Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 16

This is huge!

Grok@grokNov 16

Yes, confirmed. Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana (Ranbir Kapoor as Rama, Yash as Ravana, Sai Pallavi as Sita) is scheduled to open the BRICS cinema segment at the 57th IFFI in Goa, 20-28 November 2026. Multiple outlets including Variety, ANI and Indian media report the official announcement by Goa CM Pramod Sawant and festival director Ashutosh Gowariker. IFFI is run by the Ministry of Information & Broadcasting.

Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 16

I wish the Ramayana film had more moments where the philosophical point is explained explicitly. A good example is when they are leaving for exile and many citizens want to go along with them. Sita explains why the community should stay behind. She says each person has his/her own distinct dharma. Ram is leaving out of his dharma. Her dharma is to go with her husband. And the dharma of the citizens is to stay behind and look after the city. Message: Follow your dharma and not someone else’s. There should have been at least a dozen such moments when the dharma/adharma or karma at work would be explained. Otherwise many folks miss the message behind the story. Such philosophical messages could be spoken by a character like Sita above, or by the narrator. This would have avoided the impression of many critics that the film lacked the philosophical messages or even deviated from it. I notice on Indian TV they often need to tell the audience when to laugh, otherwise they might miss the humor. A sophisticated audience prefers subtlety, and can pick up the point that is not explicit.

Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 15

Good vs Evil is an Abrahamic religions concept in which God vs Devil are fighting and one must side with God, not Devil. There is no such concept in Vedic metaphysics. We have Dharma vs Adharma and these terms are NON-TRANSLATABLES into Abrahamic framework. For details read my book “Sanskrit Non-Translatables”. 🙏

Ramayana was redone and retold but good vs evil is clearly established. Kids coming out and saying Ravana was a just person is a big giveaway.Except Ravana everyone was ‘going through the motions’.Rama was shown a fatalist when he took decisions in his stride but with conviction.

Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 15

Tulsi Ramayana also has many departures from Valmiki. This caused a stir among some at the time, but the community embraced it, and it became the new standard. Same point for Sagar’s TV Ramayana - it differs from Valmiki a lot and on top of that is further differs from Tulsi. I will post a table comparing various stages of the evolution of Ramayana.

I'll share my honest independent review of the "Ramayana" movie that found some passionate support online amidst calls for boycott. On the whole, Ramayana is a pretty good and enjoyable movie, though flawed and not faithful to Valmiki Ramayana. In spite of some objectionable portions, it does far more good to Hinduism & Sanatana Dharma than bad, in my assessment. Moreover, I see no malice behind its flaws. Thus, calling for its boycott by sections of Indian RW is IMHO unjustified (and counterproductive!) overreaction. * * * It employs world class visual effects and technical quality to tell an ancient Hindu epic in a modern western template. Basically it is Ramayana made accessible to the Marvel superhero generation of audience, without sacrificing the core message and story. It can appeal to even a modern Indian audience that may normally avoid religious movies. It can also appeal to several southeast Asian audiences that are familiar with Ramayana. IMHO, it can even appeal to the western non-Hindu audience if promoted well. * * * Though it is over 3 hours, it moves fast and never gets boring, even to those who may not be into Hinduism and are watching it just as the latest blockbuster movie. The makers pick just a few key portions of Valmiki Ramayana and build the narrative. Cinematography by Pankaj Kumar and Manoj Limaye, editing by Huzefa Lokhandwala and visual effects by DNEG are absolutely top notch. I find the musical score by Hans Zimmer and AR Rahman a bit loud and cacophonious. I personally prefer a melodious musical score that employs classical raagas based on the underlying moods in the scenes to elevate those emotions (e.g. MM Keeravani's "Bahubali" score or Shashwat Sachdev's "Dhurandhar" score). However, many people now-a-days probably enjoy this kind of music more. Also they perhaps want the movie to feel more like a western blockbuster and this kind of musical score is perhaps more fitting. In any case, AR Rahman's songs are terrible - there's not even a single tune you feel like humming or remember when you walk out. What a fall for the man who enthralled us in "Roja", "Bombay", "Rangeela", "Taal" etc! * * * A warning about emotions: This movie is really more gloss than soul. So don’t go expecting a soulful movie that hits exhilarating emotional crescendos (a la Bahubali or RRR or Dhurandhar). For example, Amarendra Bahubali leaving the palace in "Bahubali" hits you harder and makes you more emotional than Rama leaving palace for vanvaas, though that may be tough to believe! Basically, they just rush from one episode to another, without letting the audience soak in an emotion and feel it. But director Nitesh Tiwari does understand the art of slow-cooking a critical sequence of scenes to ripen a particular emotion and hit an emotional peak, e.g. his previous blockbusters "Dangal" and "Chhichhore". So my guess is that this style of hurrying from one episode to the next is intentional, perhaps demanded by their chosen western blockbuster template. Or, it is perhaps the result of collaborating on this script with writer Sridhar Raghavan, who has mainly worked on some commercial potboiler thrillers that are pretty shallow on genuine emotions, and not with his collaborators of "Dangal" and "Chhichhore" (writers Piyush Gupta and Nikhil Mehrotra). * * * As for acting, Ranbir Kapoor does an excellent job as Rama. While there is something amiss with his makeup as prince in Ayodhya (can't put my finger on it), he is almost perfect as Rama in vanvaas. He gets haav-bhaav, expressions, diction and mannerisms very well. Unlike Arun Govil of TV Ramayan, who IMHO confuses being a dheerodaatta with sthitapragyataa for having a wooden face and plays the entire part with a wooden face, Ranbir uses his expressive face to bring out various emotions, but quite subtly and very aptly. BTW, some may be upset about a man who mentioned love for beef in the past playing Bhagavan Rama, but he is just an actor to me and not the character he plays. He acts well and that's all that matters to me in the context of this movie. My only complaint about Ranbir, in the context of this role, is that his upper back has a little forward droop and that's not apt for Rama. For example, when he meditates in front of Brahmarshi Vishwamitra and receives Astra Vidyas, that droop comes out strongly. He should've worked on his posture. Ranbir also has a cameo as the aged Parashurama and he is really good (BTW, the scene is altered from Valmiki Ramayana, but it retains its essence). There is an impressive contrast between the makeup, mannerisms, haav-bhaav and diction between the 2 characters. [BTW, one astrological tidbit: Based on some planetary correlations between when Prithviraj Kapoor died and Ranbir Kapoor was born, I suspect Ranbir to be a rebirth of his great grandfather Prithviraj, who was Indian cinema's first super star and is best remembered for the role of Alexander the Great in Sohrab Modi's “Sikandar”, aged Akbar in “Mughal-e-Azam” and the strict judge father in "Awaara".] Many hated Sai Pallavi's choice as Sita. Well, one can validly complain that she doesn't meet some of the physical characteristics of Sita, per Valmiki's depiction. However, looks apart, when it comes to projecting sattwa guna, wisdom, piety, enlightened love, calm confidence and various other subtle qualities of Sita, she does a pretty good job IMHO. Again, some may be upset by things she said in the past, but I see actors as just actors. Their personal lives, personal views etc are immaterial to me, as long as they can do justice to the characters they play. She does do justice, with physical characteristics ignored. Though Ranbir and Sai Pallavi both act well in their respective roles, somehow the chemistry between the two is weak and it's a bit jarring in some scenes. Yash of "KGF" fame is simply outstanding as the antagonist Ravana, the mighty demon king. He plays the complex role with such panache. Various shades of Ravana - bravery, might, self-assuredness, arrogance, hurt ego, scheming, self-doubts, insecurities, subtle fears - all come through very vividly in Yash's expressions and mannerisms. His Tandav dance sequence is brilliantly executed. Though somewhat inappropriate, the way Lakshmana's character is used for comic relief in some scenes probably makes the movie more enjoyable to many. Overall, they don't mess up the personal characteristics of Lakshmana too much. In any case, Ravi Dubey does a pretty good job as Lakshmana, whether displaying loving and caring devotion to Rama and Sita, or questioning something comically or just letting out a short-tempered first reaction. Most other actors do a pretty good job. Special mention is deserved by Arun Govil as king Dasharatha, the doting father who is torn by a great moral dilemma and dies heartbroken, Shobhana as Kaikasi, who inspires her gifted son to fight for the clan, feels proud of son's accomplishments and develops some concerns later, Lara Dutta as Kaikeyi, who wholeheartedly loves her stepson Rama, but acts hastily under the influence of provoked insecurity and jealousy, only to face a bit of shame and regret later, Vivek Oberoi as Vidyutjiva, an arrogant and deluded demon king, and Sheeba Chaddha as Manthara, who provokes Kaikeyi against stepson Rama and instills insecurity and jealousy. Though the role of Shurpanakha is written poorly, Rakul Preet Singh does a good job of portraying the role as written. * * * Detractors of this movie fall into 3 categories IMHO: (1) Those who are validly disappointed by some objectionable portions (and also possibly misinterpreting some reasonable portions due to their preconceived notions), but missing the forest for trees overall, (2) Those who have an agenda or an axe to grind or perhaps the ambition to become the gatekeepers of all things dharmik, (3) Those who haven't watched it but blindly joining the bandwagon (perhaps due to rage bait tactics employed by some). Though it does take some creative liberties with the story in some portions, my subjective assessment is that it was NOT done out of malice. When people of one desa-kaala-paatra (place-era-conditioning) look at events of a distant desa-kaala-paatra, they sometimes superimpose their own morality and sense of auchitya (appropriateness), which may be flawed, to alter some specifics to make better sense of things in their own minds. Some film makers also do that based on their perception of their audience’s sensitivities. It seems to me like that is what is driving some of the changes and not any malicious intent. In the end, most of the viewers will only have a positive impression of Sita and Rama and see Ravana as a villain, albeit a mighty one. Let me briefly address some common online critiques. - The critique that it portrays Suras (gods) as the oppressors & Asuras (demons) as the oppressed is IMHO a misunderstanding. Even as the movie starts off with Sur-Asur battle, they are described by the voiceover as "aloukik sur" and "atyachari asur". Clearly, Suras are depicted positively and Asuras as tyrannical & oppressive aggressors. - At the same time, it's true that the makers overdo the abject plight of Asuras after defeat & that gives the appearance of being oppressed. But it should clearly be seen as the punishment of undesirable aggressors after fall, rather than poor benevolent people being oppressed. But the writing could've have better to avoid the misunderstanding. - Though some critiqued that Ravana is depicted positively, that is IMHO done mostly within reason and auchitya. Yes, some of his positive qualities are brought out, but also his negative qualities are brought out with equal force. The scene where his 10 heads debate amongst themselves on whether to abduct Sita or not, brilliantly and poignantly brings out his skills, wisdom, arrogance and foolishness - all at the same time! Moreover, a strong story and a strong clash need a strong villain. What's wrong if they build up a strong antagonist in the first part? Mind you, story is not over & left for the second part. In any case, remember that Ravana wasn't any ordinary Rakshasa, but an incarnation of Bhagavan Vishnu's gatekeeper Jaya due to a curse. And he was the son and grandson of 2 rishis. Even previous movies & TV serials depicted several positive qualities of Ravana & didn't show him as pure evil. - Having said that, his "if I have a golden palace, so will you" speech to other rakshasas on conquering Lanka from Kubera was totally unnecessary and objectionable. Thus, there is some merit in the accusation that the makers rebranded Ravana as a champion of social justice, equal rights and socialism. However, he is amply depicted as cruel and ruthless in other places. In general, he's depicted as someone feared by his subjects, whereas Rama is depicted as someone dearly loved & admired by the people of Ayodhya! In an unevenly written script, why should we overemphasize one portion instead of taking all into account before forming an opinion of how they wanted to project various characters? - Some complained that the lustful Ravana is portrayed as a protector of women. But, that is reading too much into one episode, where Ravana doesn't actually speak of respecting the woman in question, but speaks of respecting the assembly. He says Vidyutjihva can do whatever he wants in his bedroom but not in the assembly. - Some spoke of Rakshasa vs Asura discrepancy. Well, most people now-a-days use Rakshasa, Asura, Daitya and Danava interchangeably ("demon"). Scholarly accuracy with these words makes no difference to most people. In any case, it doesn't alter the essence of the story or characters. - Overall, there are several departures from Valmiki Ramayana, as pointed out by learned friends. But then, to be fair, that can be said about every TV serial or movie that came out in the past based on Ramayana. Even the revered Ramcharitmanas of Sant Tulsidas contains some significant departures from Valmiki Ramayana! Thus, all writers and movie/TV serial makers took some creative liberties, if you consider Valmiki Ramayana as the authoritative reference point. This is not a new phenomenon. In any case, newcomers who watch this movie may become interested in reading Valmiki Ramayana or other texts later! - Having said that, creative liberty is misused by makers in some places. For example, aspects of the Shurpanakha episode are really mishandled IMHO, crossing reasonable limits of creative liberty. However, my subjective assessment as explained earlier is that this wasn't done out of malice and also this doesn't significantly alter the viewers' perception of the story and characters. Any arguments that this justifies Ravana's abduction of Sita are undone by some arguments Ravana himself makes shortly thereafter, in the debate between his 10 heads. His main goal in abducting Sita is anyway to bring his despised Hari to Lanka and force a battle with him, so that he can "kill" Hari. That has clearly been portrayed as his life-long goal - lust for Sita or revenge for Shurpanakha's insult are just pretexts. * * * Overall, it is a pretty enjoyable movie in spite of its flaws. And, there's no malice behind its flaws and the big picture is that it does more good to Hinduism than bad. Made in a modern world class format, it can reach many more people than previous movies and TV serials on Ramayana. As I said in the beginning, it is basically Ramayana made accessible to the Marvel superhero generation of audience, without sacrificing the core message and story. We should encourage movies like this rather than call for their boycott (which is just counter productive grandstanding). In any case, it seems to be doing very well! I watched a weekday matinee show in a greater Boston theater. It was nearly house full and the audience consisting of many families and children seemed to thoroughly enjoy it. [Appreciation: Based on the posts here, I originally decided to skip it and didn't watch it the first weekend. My sincere thanks to Sri @RajivMessage ji, who took a strong stand for it on X and inspired me to go and watch it. 🙏]

Post attachment
Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 14

My pranams to whoever came up with this vision to display India's achievements in such a massive museum in Delhi. Jai Shri Ram!

BJP@BJP4IndiaNov 14

A lot is happening in the Ramayana and on the ground in India too! While Ramayana edits have taken over the internet, New India has its own stories making headlines. From economic resilience and declining TB deaths to Udhampur’s GI-tagged treasures and the upcoming Yuge Yugeen Bharat Museum, catch up on four stories shaping India’s progress in this week’s edition of New India’s Desk.

1:43
Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 13

👍👍

Many people fail to remeber or observe than even the popult ramayana and mahabharat tv serials which everybody considers original are themselves using much artistic freedom very different from classics- but it could produce a narrative and dharma sameway this ramayana is fr prsnt

Oud Bilao avatar
⟳ Rajiv Malhotra retweeted
Oud Bilao@oudbilao·Nov 13

Does, does this idiot know that there are more than 300+ versions of Ramayana and more than 1200 oral & written versions of Mahabharata! And these are available and prevalent in India and South and south east Asia. This guy is a dehati of the highest order!

Shaurya Ritwik | शौर्य ऋत्विक avatar
⟳ Rajiv Malhotra retweeted
Shaurya Ritwik | शौर्य ऋत्विक@shauryaritwik·Nov 13

The Ramayana is a story we grew up with and it reached us through grandparents, ramlila, and then on the small screen long before we could read it so seeing it brought to life on the big screen carried a weight few films can. Screenings of the complete indian cut were scarce here so I made a deliberate long trip to watch the longer version. Much of the film's power lies in a studied contrast. Ravana arrives with velocity & ferocity, a presence that seems to overflow the frame. Rama carries a stillness that is almost meditative. This is why the charge that the film glorifies Ravana seems misplaced to me. To portray him as a scholar of rare erudition, an ardent Shiva devotee and a sovereign of immense might is to give the conflict its proper gravity and not to valorise him. The movie is technically brilliant. It shows how far Indian cinema has travelled in the craft of visual storytelling. The cast deserves equal applause, with every actor bringing conviction and depth to their role. Set aside the negativity and the social media verdicts. Arrive unencumbered and let the film speak for itself. Ramayana belongs to all of humanity for its enduring lessons of the triumph of Satya over Asatya, of dharma over adharma.. Movie is now taking Thailand, Indonesia, Cambodia and other parts of the world by storm. Heartiest congratulations to the entire team on a remarkable achievement. Ramayana holds every shade of the human condition from love and loyalty to pride and sacrifice and its lessons will guide humanity for all eternity. @WorldOfRamayana @malhotra_namit @niteshtiwari22 #Ramayana

Post attachmentPost attachment
Rajiv Malhotra avatar
Rajiv Malhotra@RajivMessage·Nov 13

I agree. Too much pettiness. Some criticisms are valid but not serious. Many points are subjective or outright unreasonable. The attackers are now depleted as they have fired all their ammunition. The film’s movement is getting stronger and will open a new era for broader appreciation of our classics. Those staring at their navels will get more isolated and bitter. Jai Shri Ram!

I watched the entire 30-minute interview, the film itself, and went through nearly 200–300 comments. What surprised me was how many people seemed to be supporting the criticism without even watching the movie. Dushyanth Sridhar raises roughly 10–12 objections, but most feel like nitpicking. Why wasn’t Ravana’s lust emphasised? Why was Surpanakha’s revenge highlighted? But revenge is also part of Valmiki’s narrative. Why treat these motivations as mutually exclusive? And the claim that Ravana is glorified? I didn’t see that at all. His arrogance, ambition and pride are clearly shown. Personally, I loved Rama’s characterisation. His presence was quieter than Ravana’s, but that doesn’t make it weaker. What bothers me is that we’re treating personal interpretations and preferences about missing scenes as scholarly objections. It’s a three-hour film adapting an epic of 24,000 verses. How much can you realistically include? It’s disheartening to see such an ambitious effort judged this way, especially when people take sides without watching it. What are we really defending here?