Director, US Policy @crypto_council, GP @LucrumVC, @dydx @CoryBooker alum | DC sports fan. You can probably find me reading. Crypto//History//Politics//Art
Tomorrow, CCI’s Director U.S. Policy and Digital Energy Council Policy Lead, @Rashan joins @NABSummit to discuss crypto’s convergence with AI, new fronts with agentic commerce, and frontier markets.
From Legislation to Implementation: What’s Next for Digital Asset Policy?
Wed, Nov 18 · 10:45 AM CT
See you in Texas.
CCI expresses our strong support for the nominations of Mr. Nathan Anonick and Mr. Matthew Rowland to serve as Commissioners of the @CFTC. They are experienced nominees and their appointment would come at a consequential moment for the CFTC.
Mr. Anonick has spent years as professional staff and counsel to Senate Ag, where he was one of the most effective and knowledgeable voices on various critical issues including digital commodity policy. He brings experience across traditional and digital markets, deep understanding of regulations, and a genuine willingness to hear from all stakeholders. Mr. Rowland’s tenure as a career CFTC attorney and work for Senate Ag provide the experience and institutional knowledge critical to the position. He knows the Commission, the legislative process that shapes it, and has demonstrated a thoughtful regulatory approach that balances innovation with market integrity.
CCI commends the Committee for moving promptly on these nominations and urges Members to advance both nominees.
cryptoforinnovation.org/wp-c…
Congratulations to Nathan Anonick and Matt Rowland on their nominations to the @CFTC, and to Kristin Johnson and Steve Levine on their nominations to the @SECGov. Strong, bipartisan representation is essential to developing durable rules that safeguard markets, protect consumers, and keep the U.S. leading on innovation.
Nathan’s deep expertise across traditional and digital asset markets would make him an outstanding addition to the CFTC. I’ve seen his leadership, substance, and work ethic up close, and I know he will bring the same to the CFTC. He cares deeply about getting policy right, and our markets will benefit from his thoughtful and rigorous approach.
Matt has more than a decade of experience at the CFTC, most recently as a CFTC detailee to the Senate Ag Committee. That institutional knowledge will serve the CFTC well as it implements new rules. I’ve always respected his command of the issues and his willingness to engage directly.
Kristin brings a rare combination of government service and academic depth, including her prior tenure as a CFTC Commissioner. I always appreciated her expertise and transparent approach, and she will bring both to the SEC. Her understanding of innovation and investor protection will serve the SEC well.
Steve brings valuable experience from his prior service at the SEC and as General Counsel of the White House Council of Economic Advisers. His perspective and knowledge will certainly be an asset as the SEC modernizes its rulebook and takes on other important regulatory matters.
Both the CFTC and SEC will continue to play central and consequential roles in our financial markets, and together these nominees bring a wealth of experience and expertise that will help ensure continued American leadership. 🇺🇸
whitehouse.gov/presidential-…
Everyone agrees about the vaults that hold most of DeFi’s capital.
If a user supplies assets to a lending protocol with parameters that no one can unilaterally reconfigure, the securities laws aren’t triggered—the user didn’t buy a security, the protocol isn’t an investment company, no one is an adviser, no one is a custodian.
Control is what matters.
The same applies to vaults where a DAO can change parameters through public, timelocked votes. DAO governance that sets rates and collateral parameters is market administration, not managing anyone’s money.
In July, then-Commissioner Peirce asked the people “setting interest rates, deciding which assets to accommodate, setting loan-to-value limits, and establishing liquidation thresholds” to think about whether the securities laws are implicated.
A group led by CCI and a group led by Aave recently submitted compelling answers to that call—securities laws do not reach the vaults that hold most of DeFi’s capital, and the SEC should confirm that this activity sits outside their scope.
But vaults come in many forms, and when you add complexity, the legal arguments get more complex.
Where a vault has a single curator with unbounded discretion over how the vault’s assets are deployed, the argument that it falls outside the securities laws is much more tenuous, because one cannot credibly argue that such a vault is truly autonomous.
Aave’s letter makes the strongest form of the argument that even curated vaults fall outside. But that argument depends on the SEC reading “note” to require a person who promises repayment, “common enterprise” to require a venture that investors finance rather than assets they co-own, and “issuer” to require an entity that owns the vault’s assets. Those are good arguments, but they're not conclusive. The letter also concedes that curators may be subject to the Investment Advisers Act, but does not say how they would comply.
CCI’s letter addresses what happens if the SEC does interpret securities laws to apply to some subset of curated vaults. In that world, curated vaults should still exist! The passages being quoted as “concessions” are CCI stating the adverse facts before the SEC does, which is how the baseline argument keeps its credibility, and it is what lets CCI then argue for a way for curators to comply under authority the SEC already has to tailor compliance.
Ultimately, the two letters work well together.
Both safeguard a broad vision of DeFi, both open the door for regulated financial activity—like investment fund management—to move onchain, and both provide the SEC with a lot to consider, based on how different types of vaults actually work.
*Disclosure: a16z is a member of CCI and commented on drafts of its paper.
Wonderful to see that the CFTC and @ChairmanSelig, with their remarkable speed and diligence, has approved Equity Perpetual Futures under the joint regulatory framework first proposed by American Perpetuals in the Harmonization Committee meeting we led in June.
This framework is a significant step towards enabling a robust 24/7 equity perpetuals market that is fully regulated and onshore. American Perpetuals is excited to work further with regulators to create this reality.
18 years ago, the Bitcoin Whitepaper set out a foundational vision for open, peer-to-peer transactions without intermediaries.
As the financial system continues to evolve, today reminds us of the idea that started it all, and the community that has carried that vision forward by building for the long term.
bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf