🚨Just published in the British Journal of Psychiatry!🚨
Evolutionary explanations of anxiety rated as 5x more useful for patients and 3x more useful for clinicians than genetic explanations of anxiety!
Our paper is the largest RCT of evolutionary explanations to date!
Anthropologist and Cyberneticist, Dr. Gregory Bateson argued that pathology often lives in the feedback circuit between organism and environment, not "inside the skull" alone. Evolutionary psychiatry simply adds the deep-time dimension: our control loops were optimized for Pleistocene ecosystems, not algorithmic feeds.
🔪"Psychiatry has a secret. Despite billions of dollars in research and decades of study, it has taken us no closer to understanding what causes common mental disorders."
-@RealAdamHuntamazon.com/Specialized-Mind-…
The brain is the most calorie-expensive organ we have. And yet the states of depression, anxiety, and etc, are assumed to be error - despite this most efficient organ "generating" them consistently.
Striking to think that in one of the richest, most powerful families in 1730s England the wife was pregnant 27 times, but only 7 children survived infancy (1 of the 7 died young) and this was "not unheard of... for the times but at the high end." (Danielle Allen, Radical Duke)
Pain evolved to signal tissue damage. Sometimes it misrepresents the damage. Still, the idea that pain is a signal is the starting point for intervention. It would be bizarre for a doctor to assume at the outset that your pain is “all in your head.” The same goes for depression.
The idea that depression/anxiety are reliable signals that something's wrong in life is terrible. Often they're instead (not signals but) signs that something's wrong in how you're making sense of things. Certainly don't blow up your job/marriage just because you're low/stressed.
Consider "Low-Mood" as a disengagement protocol. Complex systems can often "get stuck" in some kind of cycle. If a current life strategy is yielding zero returns, it makes sense for a meta system to pull the emergency brake to conserve metabolic resources.
We treat unpredictable -"low level crazy" - behaviour as a pathology.
Evolutionary perspective: it’s a "fast life history strategy." If your early environment signals that life is highly unpredictable and brief, shorting the future for immediate return is the "evolutionarily optimal play."
Happening soon: The Evolutionary Psychiatry Symposium, 6th of November London:
Every known society creates rhythm, melody, and pattern-based harmony, yet its exact adaptive value remains unclear. Highly anticipating Prof. Martin Bruene’s talk on the "Evolution of Music" for this reason. He will detail what the adaptive cause of musicality could be; and the analogies between musical performance and successful therapeutic treatment.
More event details in thread:
Suppose low mood isn't merely an error - what if it evolved as a social/semiotic signalling mechanism to withdraw and conserve energy during periods of social or environmental defeat? The implications for it's treatment are massive.
An old adage is that “Worrying is like a rocking chair: it gives you something to do, but gets you nowhere.”
But from an evolutionary psychological perspective, this is wrong.
Emotions evolved to solve adaptive problems. Jealousy motivates us to guard relationships against rivals. Disgust motivates us to avoid sources of pathogens.
Anxiety motivates vigilance, preparation and precautions.
An alternative explanation for these findings is that some dreaded outcomes never happened because anxiety motivated people to take action to prevent them.
If worrying about failing an exam prompts you to study and pass, the fact that the dreaded outcome never materialised hardly makes the worry pointless.
As Randolph Nesse puts it, there are “good reasons for bad feelings.”
“Anxiety is the handmaiden of creativity”
- Chuck Jones
Anticipating problems can inspire solutions.
one of the most liberating realizations a human can have:
almost all of your thoughts are completely useless, wrong, and meaningless.
they are just biological feedback from a dysregulated nervous system, old childhood defense mechanisms, and genetic conditioning.
"Cliff-edged fitness functions increase the risk of maladaptive outcomes. In this example, directional selection for higher values of the trait tends to shift the trait distribution toward the fitness optimum. As a result, some individuals may overshoot the optimal trait value and experience a substantial fitness loss."
Evolutionary Psychopathology, A Unified Approach.
Dr. Macro Del Giudice