←
The Realist Guild411 posts
The Realist Guild avatar

The Realist Guild

@RealistGuild

In a world that appear to have lost its mind, the Realist Guild gives classical realists a structure to prevail. substack.com/@realistguild

◷ Joined September 2026▧ 67 Photos and videos
A_wobble avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
A_wobble@a_real_wobble·6h

X4 Freedom is forgiving, and that is why some people hate it. Under servitude, disagreement is punished right away and often severely. One forbidden word, or one innocuous word misinterpreted or even just misheard, and you are done. During the woke folly, even refusing to utter a certain formula was enough to get in trouble. There was no later moment of correction and no way out. Freedom works the opposite way. You can criticize the rules, say inexcusable things, renounce freedom itself, or stay silent, and it does not immediately matter, because the next instant you can change your mind and exercise the same freedom again. You are given the chance to make it right. And if freedom is intolerable for you, you can always leave. The point is that making mistakes, and even doing bad things, is not the end because freedom is forgiving. Failure to understand this feature leads to hatred of freedom. Indeed, it is often the case that when going from authoritarian conditions to freedom, many expect a reckoning and punishments for those who aided and benefited from the repression, but they are often disappointed. Instead, the past is largely left alone and life resumes on a new basis. After the woke folly, those who used to discriminate against white people and men, who destroyed lives with resentful witch hunts, who censored and compelled speech, kept their jobs and never had to admit to doing anything wrong. This experience of liberty can certainly feel like an intolerable refusal of justice. Why should these people get away with what they did while we did nothing wrong and end up with the same freedom? It is thus tempting to reject freedom as an aberration and to redefine the Good as obedience (or even submission) to strict rules that guarantee the desired outcome. They never really wanted freedom, they wanted the freedom to get their revenge. Condenados por la Inquisición by E. L. Velázquez

Post attachment
Reductio ad absurdum avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Reductio ad absurdum@AlexanderM1986·8h

Theology, metaphysics and science is one, that is, they agree. If not, there is error. As modern man rejected theology and ignored metaphysics, while he undertook the quest for science, he got very confused. It is the tale of learning to stand before walking. Or fall.

A_wobble avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
A_wobble@a_real_wobble·5h

X6 The problem of the moral corruption of the individual is that: 1. It is inseparable from freedom. 2. Many easy ways lead to Hell. 3. Only one path leads to Heaven via the Truth, and it is most unpleasant. 4. It gets harder and harder to go back once you let yourself slide. Lying to yourself is thus the fastest and surest way to misery and suffering. Look at those who lied to themselves and tacitly approved things they disagreed with when free speech was under attack. Their faces are tired, angry, and anxious. Their lives feel heavy, even when they have everything you can dream of, like a family, a nice house, land, a prestigious job, etc. They just lack the lightness and elegance of the innocents, and the peace of the righteous. They have only one way out. “Thence issuing we again beheld the stars” (illustration for Dante’s Inferno, Canto XXXIV, c. 1860s) by G. Doré

Post attachment
credonauta avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
credonauta@credonauta·8h

Niestety, w dyskusji z tym rodzajem taki argument na nic się nie zda, chociaż obserwacja cenna. I rzeczywiście najlepiej przypatrzeć się jakiejś z przesłanek i ją podważyć. Jego argument można by rozpisać tak: P1. (Every) sex is a way to create babies. P2. Babies are blessings. P1 + P2 => C1. (Every) sex is a way to create blessings (in the form of children). P3. (Some) sex is a sin. C1 + P3 => C2. That means sin is way to create blessings. So let's commit more sins. Na pierwszy rzut oka widać, że mamy tu dwa problemy. Po pierwsze, „blessings” jest użyte w sensie partykularnym; chodzi o błogosławieństwo wynikające z posiadania dzieci lub którym są dzieci. Po drugie, autor chce połączyć C1 i P3, lecz na bardzo kruchym gruncie, ponieważ – czego nie wie, ale my wiemy – w pierwszym seks jest użyty w sensie uniwersalnym, a w P3 – partykularnym. Może więc dokonać połączenia tylko przyjmując „słabszy” sens – partykularny – i powiedzieć, że niektóre czynności, które są grzechem, a konkretnie np. seks pozamałżeński, są sposobem, aby przynieść na świat błogosławieństwo (jakim są dzieci). Jednak autor pragnąłby, aby konkluzja brzmiała, że każdy grzech (uniwersalnie) przynosi błogosławieństwo (uniwersalnie). Niestety, sens, w jakim używa zarówno słów „błogosławieństwo”, jak i „seks”, tak bardzo zawęża mu możliwe sensy w konkluzji, że nigdy nie wyjdzie mu to, czym wydaje mu się, że zaorał tych głupich teistów.

The Realist Guild avatar
The Realist Guild@RealistGuild·4h

Do you know s/o who believes that truth & goodness are objective, both are intelligible, human beings have a nature, ends and limits & reality is ordered? If so, please ask them to subscribe to us on YouTube & Substack! youtube.com/@RealistGuild substack.com/@realistguild

Pyurah avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Pyurah@MortalPura·5h

Moral progress requires a standard beyond current opinion. Otherwise, saying a society has improved would amount only to saying its preferences have changed.

Pyurah avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Pyurah@MortalPura·7h

The beauty that makes us want to stay may be telling us to move. I keep catching myself trying to own what awakened the longing, as though the signpost were the country.

Lori avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Lori@NoNewLoops·8h

Good Wednesday morning fam, and welcome to Tommy’s Diner. 👻☕️ On the menu: You’ve been given a million dollars, and you have to make one completely ridiculous purchase. What are you buying? Panda says: You can't do charity or goody-goody BS.

Post attachment
Orv avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Orv@Orv4Good·Nov 15

“St. Albert the Great, help me to seek knowledge with humility and to use my gifts for the glory of God. Inspire me to see His hand in all creation and to use reason and faith in harmony. May I follow your example of wisdom and dedication to truth. St. Albert the Great, pray for us! Amen.” -@AscensionPress

Post attachment
Orv avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Orv@Orv4Good·Nov 15

Christian anthropology matches reality and thus unlocks the greatest depths of human dignity and flourishing.

Today, the promises of transhumanism and posthumanism are multiplying. These are ideological currents according to which, sooner or later, technology will eliminate all disease and pain, as well as aging and even death itself. Precisely because scientific progress is a supreme achievement of human intelligence, it must not be confused with a privilege reserved for millionaires seeking immortality, while entire peoples suffer from poverty and oppression. In the face of this mirage, which promotes the illusion of human beings perfected by cybernetics and biotechnology, Christian anthropology reminds us that a limitation is not a manufacturing defect, but rather the very condition of human grandeur. #ApostolicJourney #Peru #MagnificaHumanitas vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/e…

Fermat's Library avatar
⟳ The Realist Guild retweeted
Fermat's Library@fermatslibrary·23h

"Science is built up with facts, as a house is with stones. But a collection of facts is no more a science than a heap of stones is a house." - Henri Poincaré

Post attachment