←
Robin Poe 🐑31,199 posts
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar

Robin Poe 🐑

@RobinPoedev

"Woke Grummz" Allegedly Making a Mina the Hollower clone

◷ Joined July 2020▧ 1,832 Photos and videos
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 17

It really is impossible to see either of these games for what they are or even appreciate them if you don’t also hate the games at least a little bit

BOTW has real dungeons, unbreakable weapons would undermine the core gameplay loop. BOTW has real progression, & the story being told through memories mirrors Link's amnesia; it lets you piece the past together if you choose to do so, which fits the point of BOTW: player freedom.

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

it makes the shiekah's age and longevity less interesting, it makes the apocalypse toothless, it makes adaptability unnecessary, makes salvation routine, maybe thats intentional, but i think a massive step back from what Windwaker did in a "traditional" Zelda game

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

cynically it feels insecure to me. insecure about its identity as a zelda game so it clings on tightly to its tokens, then makes those tokens immortal. this isnt universally true, it does away with the Triforce, i love what it does for Ganon, but i wish it was more bold elsewhere

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

and this is a very odd choice for the Zelda that changed everything about zelda. Botw changed what it's series could be fundamentally. Mechanically its looking forward, link's even wearing blue now, but its worldbuilding often exists to reassure you that it will never change.

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

it gives Botw/Totk's present this feeling of a perpetual status quo, that no mater how far back or how far forward you go everything will look basically the same. there will always be a hyrule and it will always look more or less the same. its weirdly "end of history" coded

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

in Botw(and her ugly younger brother Totk) Zora, Gerudo, Gorons and bafflingly ""Rito"" come back and whats worse is that they are all Gorons now, every race has existed for countless thousands of years being depicted in the 10,000 year old tapestry and shown in totks past

Post attachmentPost attachment
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

and i love that the Gorons return, they are the only race to make it to all 5 3d games besides hylians. they are immovable rock people and the only thing that was ever temporary was where they lived. it makes them distinct, gives them character

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

Skyward sword is primordial, it has a bunch of new faces, the Mogma, Parella, Kikwi and they dont really try and ground connect them to any future tribe and theyve never returned. the only connection to the future games are the Gorons (& Sheikah but thats a whole other subject)

Post attachmentPost attachment
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

and, a big reason why i think that is because it adds to the thematic throughline of legacy/tradition in Twilight princess, gives their invasion of hyrule context and explains why Ganondorf even bothers to use them.

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

personally, i think the intent of the devs, at least initially, was for the twili to just be the Gerudo remnants. that they were banished with Ganondorf and became twisted and evil and there is a lot of supporting evidence for this. but thats subtext at best

Post attachmentPost attachmentPost attachmentPost attachment
Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

it also does do interesting things with the Gerudo, by making them "disappear", the implication of their absence and the only signs of human design being arbiters grounds a place of judgement and exile says a lot very quietly, the desert is still called "gerudo desert"

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

twilight princess' races have not changed much from oot but this too is just as deliberate as windwaker. these two games are thematic parallels to one another, where WW is about throwing away useless traditions TP is about holding on to lineage/tradition/legacy

Robin Poe 🐑 avatar
Robin Poe 🐑@RobinPoedev·Nov 16

either way they are using the races to reinforce the narrative about adaptability. peoples ability to find new meaning after a crisis, in their case, messenger birds. the Kokiri similarly change to kodama like tree planters, with no forest anymore they change become forest makers

Post attachmentPost attachment