←
Rock Chartrand74,592 posts
Rock Chartrand avatar

Rock Chartrand

@RockChartrand

I spend most of my time on X trying to save authoritarians from themselves.

◷ Joined November 2018▧ 3,036 Photos and videos
Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·Nov 7

Capitalism is perhaps the most misunderstood economic system in history, largely because it is routinely blamed for the consequences of violating its own principles. Capitalism means private property, individual rights, voluntary trade, and a government limited to protecting those rights. It is a system in which individuals are free to produce, compete, trade, and prosper without requiring political permission or favoritism. Cronyism, by contrast, means government granting economic privileges through subsidies, bailouts, tariffs, regulations designed to protect favored businesses, and other forms of political favoritism. Socialism, communism, fascism, theocracy, absolute monarchy, feudalism, mercantilism, corporatism, and cronyism differ in their doctrines, methods, and objectives. Yet all have permitted political authority or privileged groups to override individual economic freedom. The fundamental distinction is between voluntary exchange and political coercion. Under capitalism, economic success depends on creating value that others voluntarily choose to purchase. Under cronyism, political influence can substitute for earning that success through trade. This brings us to the mixed economy, where elements of capitalism coexist with government intervention, redistribution, regulation, and political favoritism. When intervention produces unintended consequences, critics routinely attribute those failures to capitalism simply because they occurred in an economy containing private businesses and markets. That is a fundamental error of causation. The existence of private businesses does not make every government policy capitalist. Nor does the existence of wealthy businessmen make political favoritism a product of free markets. A businessman who earns a fortune through voluntary trade and one who obtains privileges through political coercion are operating on fundamentally different principles. Pure laissez-faire capitalism has never been fully implemented. Yet to the extent economic freedom has existed, it has demonstrated its extraordinary capacity to create wealth, increase productivity, encourage innovation, and raise living standards. And here lies the great irony. The remaining economic freedom continues to generate much of the wealth that makes government intervention and redistribution possible, while helping cushion society against their destructive consequences. Critics then demand further intervention to remedy problems caused or aggravated by previous interventions, perpetuating a cycle in which political power expands while capitalism receives the blame. Before blaming capitalism for any economic problem, establish whether that problem arose from voluntary exchange or the coercive exercise of political power. You cannot reasonably condemn a system for the consequences of violating its principles while ignoring the benefits produced when those principles are respected.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·13m

Socialist logic outside taxation: “I paid $5,000 for this Mercedes. I’m being ripped off. Someone owes me.” “The car costs $30,000. You only paid $5,000 because someone else was forced to pay $150,000 for theirs to cover yours.” “Yes, but they can afford it. Why wasn’t mine free?”

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·29m

Socialism: the ideology that turns someone else’s refusal to live for your demands into a grievance. Keeping what you earned is “greed.” Demanding what someone else earned is “justice and compassion.” Apparently greed becomes a virtue the moment you want someone else’s money instead of to just be able to keep the money you earned.

craigwhytefanclub @craigwhitefanc1 Nov 17

Post attachment
Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·34m

When equality of outcome becomes the standard of justice, success becomes evidence of exploitation and failure becomes proof of victimhood, regardless of how either outcome was earned. The poor wife beating drunk becomes someone society owes, while the man who gets rich through trade by improving people’s lives becomes the villain expected to pay. What could possibly go wrong with an incentive structure that treats achievement as a debt and failure as a claim on it?

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·37m

“We must abolish class,” say the people who assign everyone a class, designate one as the enemy to be robbed, promise another the proceeds, and empower a political class to seize and distribute everything. Conveniently, the people administering this “classless society” get to decide what everyone else deserves, including themselves. Apparently class hierarchy becomes moral once you’re on top of it.

#CapitalismIsCancer

Post attachment
Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·48m

“Everyone helped pay for it” doesn’t establish that the billionaire still owes you. How much did each person contribute, and how much have they already received? If you pay $2,000 in taxes and receive $10,000 in services, someone else is already covering the difference. What makes that an unpaid debt to you? It’s like covering the tip while someone else buys the pizza, eating four fifths of it, then calling them greedy because they won’t give you the leftovers. Talk about projection.

“Billionaires don't owe you anything.” Oh, shut the hell up. You think a billionaire built a fortune without roads, airports, ports, public schools, courts, publicly funded research, workers, customers and an entire country supporting the business environment that made that fortune possible? The CBO estimates $2.6 TRILLION in federal tax expenditures for 2026. That's revenue lost through tax breaks, credits and deductions for households AND businesses. So no, I'm not asking your favorite billionaire for charity. I'm demanding a fair contribution from people who benefit enormously from the country the rest of us help pay for. Stop confusing wealth with immunity from responsibility.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·53m

The government should know NOTHING about us, but Christian nationalism should decide how we live, what we teach, and whose beliefs shape the law? Quite a trick: policing everyone’s conscience blindfolded. Stop borrowing the language of liberty to sell religious control. Have enough respect for your audience to pick a principle and stick to it.

We should know EVERYTHING about our government, and they should know NOTHING about us.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·2h

You represent the political parasite class that burdens the people who actually work, produce, and pay the bills. Working families are already paying for politicians’ promises. Your answer is more promises, more control, and another bill sent to those same families. Then you campaign on their struggle as though you had nothing to do with it.

The working families of this country are struggling. This election was a demand that we finally address their interests, and not those of the billionaire class. As incoming Chair of the HELP Committee, that’s exactly what I intend to do, including: Medicare for All Cut Prescription Drug Prices by 50% Raise the Minimum Wage to $20 an Hour Pass the PRO Act Universal Childcare Tuition-Free Public College Restore Defined-Benefit Pensions Moratorium on AI Data Centers Let’s get to work.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·5h

A reminder to those who want to live off someone else’s taxes: 0.5% of a trillion is $5 billion. 40% of a billion is $400 million. Too bad so many care more about making someone else poorer than about how much revenue their policies actually collect.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·5h

To my critics: fucking step it up. If I have to supply both my argument and a better version of yours, you’re barely participating.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·5h

The fact that government funding is compulsory means it doesn’t have to serve your interests or earn your support. It gets your money either way. In private trade, the seller has to offer something you consider worth the price. You can refuse, choose a competitor, or stop paying if the service disappoints. That gives businesses a financial incentive to control costs, improve quality, and keep you satisfied. Compulsory funding weakens that relationship. Your dissatisfaction doesn’t automatically cost the agency your business. Failure can even become an argument for a bigger budget, while success can mean having its budget cut. Private businesses can disappoint you, too. The difference is that voluntary trade gives you a way to make your disappointment matter: take your money elsewhere.

Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·5h

Seems like a simple solution: let people opt in, pay the full cost of their coverage, and let everyone else opt out of both the program and its taxes. Then people can judge the price and value for themselves. An idea so good they have to take away your choice.

Bullshit. Medicare for All is not too expensive, but let me tell you what is. If we do nothing, our current broken healthcare system will cost $72 trillion over the next 10 years. That's trillion with a t. Medicare for All saves $1 trillion & 114,000 lives a year. Let's do it.

Alex Epstein avatar
⟳ Rock Chartrand retweeted
Alex Epstein@AlexEpstein·Nov 17

We the people are the ones using the data centers. “Big tech” is meeting our demand for life-enhancing computing power and the reliable energy it requires. They’re not emitting CO2 for kicks. Same argument applies to the oil companies.

A new Harvard study estimates that 403 of the largest data centers in the United States were responsible for 25.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions in just one year. That's roughly as much as Denmark produces in a year. So while the rest of us are told to turn down our heaters, switch off our lights and avoid wood burners because of net zero, the big tech data centres get to guzzle vital energy supplies and emit vast amounts of CO2.

Post attachment
Rock Chartrand avatar
Rock Chartrand@RockChartrand·6h

First, you’re treating tax cuts as though trillions in unpaid tax bills were erased for 600 billionaires. Second, notice your standard: “Someone else got to keep more of their own money, so I deserve someone else’s money to pay my debts.” Talk about desperately entitled. And if the taxes you pay don’t cover the services you already receive, other taxpayers are already making up the difference, including the wealthy people you condemn. Apparently even subsidizing you isn’t enough. They owe you a degree, too.

Why do I support cancelling student loan debt for 45 million students? Because we canceled trillions in taxes for 600 billionaires. That's why