
Cool. Thanks for that quote - and insight.
To quote “Sunday in the Park with George” (Stephen Sondheim) “The choice may have been mistaken The choosing was not” @rorysutherland

Thinker, author, strategist, advisor, & author of Playing to Win

Cool. Thanks for that quote - and insight.
To quote “Sunday in the Park with George” (Stephen Sondheim) “The choice may have been mistaken The choosing was not” @rorysutherland

Hah! You should have been there to laugh in person!
Brilliant article! And I love that you made a gangsta reference :)

Agree it is a tricky problem. That is why I consider strategy a lost art. People who don't know what it is hire folks purporting to know - but don't. Unsurprising results - rote plans not strategy.
Not to be cynical, but could the plight of intuition-guided decision making be that many leaders are sleepwalking through management? Question at end. Leadership and management as true skills and capabilities have been hollowed out. Too many people in these roles lack the domain specific intuition. Data or consensus becomes the crutch. The proxy. Again, I come from legal services. Far too many firm leaders are practicing lawyers. Little to know business experience in operations, strategy, and systems management. Their intuition in managing cases and clients in the practice may be elite. But that does not transfer to leading the firm. Too often their job is about managing the internal political economy, not the strategy. How does an organization select based on intuition if there is no one in the business with the domain experience? What adjacent attributes support intuition?

For sure I would recommend calling what it is. I think that leads to better learning and better performance over time.
The finding that executives hide an intuitive call behind an analytical cover story is familiar from implementation work. Once the real bet is dressed up as analysis, it rarely gets written down, so the team cannot test it and the leader cannot learn from it. Would it be more useful to frame it categorically as a judgement call, and name what would have to be true to make it valid? When you take a strategic bet to your team, do they know the actual wager, or only the slides that made it look certain?

For sure!
Dear Professor @RogerLMartin , I am currently discussing with the @GDruckerForum team (@grobicreativ , @rstraub46) a series of articles on the individual panels and other sessions. May I send you a draft relating to your panel? Best regards, Winfried Felser PS: I will also add a few sentences about your panel to my very long overall article. winfriedfelser.medium.com/a-…

I don't think they have released it yet but I believe they will be.
Thank you 🙏 is there a recording of your talk in the forum?

This week features an original Playing to Win/Practitioner Insights post. This one is entitled The Assault on Intuition: A Profound Danger for Strategy. rogerlmartin.substack.com/p/… It is inspired by a panel I was on at the 2026 Global Peter Drucker Forum along with intuition expert, Gerd Gigerenzer. It is important for all strategists to understand that intuition – which is critical to strategy – is under systematic attack. The piece describes why and how – and what you can do about it in your personal practice. Hope you enjoy!

I think it will go down as the most important question that I have framed in my career.
@Riggs_martin @RogerLMartin @bovolox Gentlemen, I hope you are all doing well. Here is a very interesting interview in which Roger's lesson on "What Would Have to Be True" has been greatly applied: youtu.be/pRXMqm5bMFk?si=SpMx… Have a great Thursday.

Cool.
Indeed. There actually has been quite a bit of good academic work in the last decade on categories, heterogeneity, lifecycles, redeployability, etc. of resources and capabilities that produced some interesting insights into firm performance and its persistence.

Thanks so much for sharing. I had never seen that article - which appears (I will read it) to have an intelligent premise. I.e. not all resources are created equal.
It may be tempting to dismiss competitive advantage as ambiguous fluff Yet some firms are able to develop sources of competitive advantage that last, as @RogerLMartin alludes My friend Prof. Wibbens has a research paper that measures its sourches and persistence in 4000 firms:

Hadn't heard that Welch'ism. But I like it.
Even JackWelch ('our hero') recognized this! “If you don’t have a competitive advantage, don’t compete. - Jack Welch

This is a subtle point. I am not sure that it is becoming more difficult to maintain - maybe but I am not sure. I am sure that it is becoming more important to maintain.
Consider the whole chessboard of competitors (not just the market leader). As @RogerLMartin notes: an initial competitive advntge is an option to continue fighting to *maintain* that advantage. 'Competitive Advantage' isn't going away: but it is getting more difficult to maintain

Scott, I think we are in full agreement on your series of posts. On this one, my view is that this demonstrates that true competitive advantage in more important today than at any point in business history. In 1958, you could survive as an S&P 500 firm for more than half a century without competitive advantage. Playing to play didn't get you killed. As the business world has progressed, playing to play has become more deadly more quickly. It is the opposite of 'the end of competitive advantage.' It is the primacy of competitive advantage. That is why building one and then continuously upgrading it is of utmost importance in 2026.
But compare to the declining lifespan of ALL firms on S&P500: from 61 yrs to 15. And consider what latest AI Firms are doing to today's giants: they're feeling the pressure and responding aggressively.

If you look at the most valuable companies in the world, as I did in this piece (4 yrs old now), you will note that competitive advantages are immensely long and not showing any signs of shortening. rogerlmartin.substack.com/p/…
Your Thoughts?

If the answer is yes, they don't have a competitive advantage. And guess what, the thing that they have goes away quickly - and always has...
Your Thoughts?

To them it means a lead - right now we are #1/first to market/whatever. They don't ask the Can't/Won't question - can/will competition easily match what I am doing? ....
Your Thoughts?