Can sit and moan or make the best of it. I’ll be watching the match at the hotel. Not keen to watch in on my own. So lets give it a go and hope I get the “tech” sorted = TV on, My Laptop camera on, and you’re welcome to join me. Sign up here (adults 18+): watchwithrassie.com. This is personal, not official.
Irma Stern’s very beautiful “Still Life with Strelitzias, a Songe Mask and a Songe Nkisi Figure” goes on auction at Strauss this week, in case you have R5-7 million lying around.
Someone talking sense, thinking deeply and commenting thoughtfully - not creating a villain because they need excitement in their life and don’t like solving bigger problems. Thank fuck we have Jim Hamilton in rugby media.
World Rugby’s comms is terrible, and I think I know why. They are terrified of losing control. If they acknowledge failure, they fear it will become a free-for-all; that a tidal wave of criticism will engulf them. And so they assert their authority is a grim-faced fashion. Think of it as a laager mentality, if you will.
But it would really be much better if someone stood up and said: “We are open to criticism, and will work harder to ensure the knee-drop rules are understood, enforced and enforced consistently. But you can’t accuse officials of match-fixing or purposefully influencing the outcome of matches, unless you have clear evidence of a causal link. So we are sanctioning Rassie, but we also commit to ensuring we get the knee-drop rule right in future.”
Why not?
One of the reasons people outside South Africa find our support for Rassie so bewildering is they think of him as a rugby coach, and how important can coaches really be, at the end of the day?
But he’s not simply a rugby coach to us. He is a beacon of hope in a bleak landscape; he represents what could be: diversity and success, together; he is a winner in a country that feels too often that it’s losing.
He is the only rugby coach on earth that is those things, and probably the only one that ever has been.
🙄 We now live in a world in which these pearl-clutching worthies tut-tut their tedious way through our lives. Sort of person who misses being made blackboard monitor by the teacher.
Very useful information and explanation from @Scienceofsport 👇. Given the videos I’ve seen, there were lots of knee drop tackles in the SA/FRA game. I think the question “how much safety is enough, and how much is too much” will divide opinion, and shift as cultural mores shift.
The coaches themselves raised it as potentially dangerous, which it is for a couple of regions. One is that it puts tackler heads in proximity of knees, which is the second highest risk for injury (behind head to head, this data is published). It's also risky for BC knees and has
To paraphrase Helen Suzman when she was told her parliamentary questions brought South Africa into disrepute: “It’s not my questions that are the problem; it’s your answers.”
Great article by Murray Kinsella on another interview with Rassie which threads the line of bringing the sport into disrepute 🗣️
We’ve seen the great doctor banned for calling out officiating decisions before, how do you think World Rugby will respond to this latest outburst?🤔
☘️Rassie on Prendergasts hip drop tackle:
“We all thought it’s an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that’s exactly what they said the hip drop tackle is.
“I swear I’m not moaning. I’m just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and play, for example, in France or in Ireland.”
🇫🇷Rassie on multiple knee drops from the French and Lucu sin bin time:
“The other thing that was brought up at the World Rugby meeting was knee-drop tackles. Now, I give you my word, there were 16 against us against France. 16 knee drop tackles.
As he continued, Erasmus said that France scrum-half Maxime Lucu had only been in the sin bin for seven minutes on Friday night, despite a sin-bin period being 10 minutes.
“So that’s fine that happened, but then there’s 17 knee-drop tackles and the TMO doesn’t come in once,” said Erasmus.
#Springboks#NationsChampionship#Rugbythe42.ie/rassie-erasmus-tack…
Feelings: an under-appreciated driver of history. There was an interesting discussion on @TheRestHistory about why Alexander went as far as he did. As ever, historians and analysts try to discern the strategy that underlies people’s actions, but quite often (think of yourself and the people you know) people do what they do because a feeling compels them. Can’t help themselves. I can think of many examples from personal experience of politics. And I am not immune to it either (no one is, except Harry in MobLand.) But also, I think Rassie just couldn’t help himself. He’s angry and it drove his behaviour. So you see, quite a lot of what you’re engaged with right now on X can be explained by this.
He ain’t wrong, but on a seperate note, why is it illegal to be on your knees when you tackle? I get the hip drop thing, but this? Why is this law necessary at all?
Jeepers, Rassie ain't wrong ... Knee drop after knee drop from the French ... And he's spot on re the Prendergast hip drop tackle against Fiji ... Right onto the ankle, which rolled badly
youtube.com/watch?v=L-Gw_JeG…
I’m sorry but none of what most people are saying is the point. Rassie may be right or may be wrong. And if he has defamed the TMO I am sure France has defamation law. But what I will not accept is that some bureaucratic body should decide which views I may or may not hear. Who do they think they are?
South African punditry centres race way more today than it did in the 90s. As is the case elsewhere in the world, racial and ethno-centrism has become acceptable in a way it wasn’t before. More honest, I suppose. But more depressing and more dangerous, too. (Nice little touch throwing Jews in there, by the way. How predictable.)
Prince Mashele exposes @Our_DA for what it truly is;
1. A white party created as an insurance plan for English and Jewish, not necessarily Afrikaners.
2. They think they can fool 2 groups of South Africans, the blacks and Afrikaners. They don’t like both groups, but subtly fool them by adding a sprinkle of them into their leadership structures.
3. @Our_DA doesn’t trust blacks, that’s why they went all the way to Western Cape to get @helenzille as a @CityofJoburgZA mayoral candidate.
4. @Our_DA will never lead @GovernmentZA as a majority because they’re not sincere to especially blacks and their material living conditions.
5. @Our_DA destroyed 2 types of black leaders; those they made like @MmusiMaimane and @LindiMazibuko for example and those they didn’t make like @HermanMashaba.
6. @Our_DA must stop being condescending and start being sincere towards other national groups if they want to break their 20s percentage ceiling.