←
Sarah Phillimore194,085 posts
Sarah Phillimore avatar✓

Sarah Phillimore ✓

@SVPhillimore

Mit der Dummheit kämpfen Götter selbst vergebens. Protection against defamation crowdfunder here crowdjustice.com/case/protec…

◷ Joined April 2011▧ 9,374 Photos and videos
Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·7m

Agreement that Defendant would start and have 30 minutes today and 2 more hours tomorrow. Want to check can sit to 4.30pm today. Judge will need to leave slightly earlier.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·9m

Look at all factors in the round. Is the process as a whole unfair. We say taking all factors together, cumulatively this is an unfair process.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·10m

The assessment by the decision maker was minimal. Guidance requires person making decision to determine if basic components of crime met. look at this cumulatively. Deciding if basic components are met, decision is just made on review of complaint and to the civil not criminal standard.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·12m

Needs fair consideration of both sides. Here decision made in 2023 and no investigation until 2024. Then decision made and a farcical interview with DS Singh. Even if that constrained to own facts, in policy terms an interview after a decision made was hopeless way to ensure a person was treated fairly.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·13m

Making a decision uncritically on assertion of victim assumes the victim is credible and makes no account of those motivated by malice or have mental health conditions that impair their judgment and credibility.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·14m

HM KC - crime recording rules require recording of a crime without telling person. Next point is the mandatory requirement to believe the victim. That is an important factor. Is the requirement to make a decision on the belief of a victim, accepting the victim is 'not the problem'. That is very different on making a decision based on victim's perception. Recent years increasing tendency to 'believe victims'. that is for obvious reasons, as in past vulnerable victims not properly listened to. but believing victims is not final decision, on victim's say so. if that was the case, we would not have criminal trials.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·16m

Judge - have I understood your point. Should not be recorded as a crime. Record it as some form of intelligence. HM KC - we would have no difficulty if LW allegations recorded as allegations and kept on local police file Judge - then HM doesn't need to be told or make representations, might be relevant later HM KC - yes.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·18m

Judge - e.g. of domestic violence. Where does it go? Keep the record, or only keep the record if being fair? HM KC - I was handed this document at the door of the court. Intelligence report from Authorised Professional Practice from CoP Judge - has anyone else got it? HM KC - they can keep it on their records as intelligence Judge - can keep a record but of intelligence but not recorded as a crime.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·19m

Judge - if complainant doesn't wish to give evidence and police want to keep a record of the allegation made, continuing domestic abuse allegation, obvious reasons. Are you saying at what point is the person it is recorded against given the chance to know about this? HM KC - first stage is making allegation. Properly recorded as allegation. Then specialist teams to review allegation and decide appropriate type of investigation. Then decision has to be made as to whether to progress a criminal case. Judge -if decision not to take further action, does fairness require the police to tell the person. Person adversely effected? Should be given explanation? HMKC - not our case that national security is only area of exemption. But when its a recording of an allegation and no decision at that juncture. Judge - it may be that... I am just interested in where it goes, can think of a few examples where you want police to keep record on file even if not taking action. Interested in knowing where that went in terms of fairness and what the police are supposed to do. HM KC yes record as allegation Judge - don't have to inform person?

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·24m

HM KC - we are concerned with one form of recording Judge - but you ask me to look at Lord Mustill re fairness. You pick national security but strikes me quite a few other areas where its problematic (to share info) HM KC - abusive relationship example, no impediment and would be proper for the police to record an allegation, that is proper part of policing, to see if a pattern emerges. Not controversial, no impediment to fairness. Indeed even in this case police would have been perfectly entitled to make a recording of an allegation and may even have been required to. Having recorded such an allegation, its a matter for the officer to decide how to deal with it. Domestic abuse and sexual crimes are inevitably very sensitive and dealt with by specialist officers BUT at some juncture in all these cases, that person will right to defend themselves prior to conviction.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·27m

Judge - you give national security as an example when its not appropriate to inform the subject of a recording, might that not also be true in many other cases, e.g. allegations of coercive and controlling behaviour. Are you suggesting that those individuals should be consulted... you are talking about lawfulness of recording and saying its unfair the way its been done. You emphasise the need for the subject to be informed, consulted, given details. Not this case, but other cases where there would seem to be ... HM KC - domestic abuse good example as victims and perpetrators... that territory. Police have well thought through systems... Judge - but I look at coercive control as those raise issues about harassment and stalking - how are the police going to be dealing with those HM KC - take classic stalking case where that arises, police have duty towards any victim. Judge they are just recording matter has been raised and take victim centred approach as otherwise these things don't get recorded and victims less likely to come forward.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·30m

Right that not expressed in absolute terms but with caveats that proved well founded. But also clear that the standards apply to administrative decision making generally. No reference to final determinations. No reference to restricting it to particular classes of case. It is a general proposition. Essentially that builds on 1911 case - it can't be good faith unless you listen to both sides, and that's a duty on anyone who decides anything. that might be too broad, but you know what he means.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·33m

Continuing momentum in Administrative Law to open decision making - recognised by Lord Mustill in 1994. Despite the unattractiveness of the murderous appellants, they were nevertheless entitled to know and understand why they got the sentence they did. We are now 30 years later. Openness in decision making is such that it is as plain as it can be, that standards set out by Lord Mustill should be applied. They are a norm that should be followed unless good reason not to do so.

Sarah Phillimore avatar
Sarah Phillimore@SVPhillimore·35m

Person effected must know the process but also knows whether or not something has gone wrong, to raise an appeal or seek redress. These are the rules of natural justice.