←
Umut Sahin391 posts
Umut Sahin avatar

Umut Sahin

@SahinLabSU

Scientist, principle investigator @sabanciu, studying SUMOylation in health and disease; @BrownUniversity, @MSKCancerCenter, @institutpasteur, @Inserm alum

◷ Joined February 2020▧ 37 Photos and videos
Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Sep 3

Many thanks to our fantastic collaborators Alain Prochiantz and Stephanie Vargas @cdf1530, who helped us with these analyses ++

Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Sep 3

Happy to see our work featured on the cover of @FEBSJournal. This confocal image shows mutant NEK1 aggregates (orange) in motor neurons of the mouse spinal cord, ultimately driving ALS pathology ++

Post attachment
Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Aug 15

More troubling is when editors act as mere secretaries, unwilling or unable to filter out reviews that clearly miss the point. A journal recently rejected our manuscript based on such reviews, then published essentially the same story from another group.

Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Aug 15

After seeing how our last manuscript was handled by a few journals, I’m increasingly OK with AI reviewing papers. At least AI will read the manuscript & engage with its core concept, rather than produce a 20-point wishlist of irrelevant experiments, each worthy of its own paper++

If you’re letting AI do a review of a manuscript for you, just know that (A) it’s super obvious to anyone reading it, (B) it’s dishonest - as you’re explicitly instructed not to do so, and (C) it’s careless - because you’re uploading someone’s confidential material to an AI app.

Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Jul 22

Thrilled to share our new review in @emboreports ! @CytoLabKoc and I explored an emerging concept in neuroscience: the centrosome/cilium/centriolar satellite axis may represent a fundamental, yet underappreciated, contributor to neurodegeneration link.springer.com/article/10…

Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Jun 21

Happy to see our recent paper highlighted through this insightful commentary by Stefan Müller. Read the full piece highlighting our findings, their implications for neurodegenerative diseases, and broader relevance across multiple fields here febs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com…

Leslie Vosshall PhD avatar
⟳ Umut Sahin retweeted
Leslie Vosshall PhD@leslievosshall·Apr 16

Scientific publishing needs to change. In a new preprint, HHMI President Erin O'Shea and Bodo Stern argue that the incentives are misaligned. Researchers should be evaluated on what they choose to share, not what journals select. I’m proud that @hhmi_science is leading the way. Read the preprint here: doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.19600…

Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Apr 4

Definitely one of the funniest and most accurate academic memes I’ve ever seen

peer reviewer finding a flaw in your argument

0:18
Roland Dunbrack 🏳️‍🌈 @rolanddunbrack.bsky.social avatar
⟳ Umut Sahin retweeted
Roland Dunbrack 🏳️‍🌈 @rolanddunbrack.bsky.social@RolandDunbrack·Mar 13

Talked to someone who failed to cite our preprint that showed an AlphaFold model with lots of experimental validation when he submitted cryo-EM paper of exact same sytem in Nature with no bio. data 6 months later. He said as a matter of policy "I don't cite preprints." Unethical.

I currently have three papers in review at "high impact" journals. One of them has been sitting there for two years. In that time my daughter was born and learned how to walk, but apparently publishing a PDF was still not possible for me. For another one, after four months in review the editor told me they cannot find a second reviewer and asked me to suggest more reviewers. A third one sent me a message in 2026 saying the PDF I uploaded was larger than 10 MB and that I should please reupload everything to make the file smaller. All of this just to eventually pay between 7,000 and 12,000 USD per paper so someone can officially approve that the science we do is "legitimate". Reminder: not a single reviewer will be compensated here. I still don't understand how we as scientists can collectively be so smart when doing science and still tolerate a system like this when it comes to sharing our findings. We should move to preprints plus open review, whether human or AI, asap. So frustrated about it. I'd suggest sharing your work on bioRxiv or medRxiv, reading and reviewing preprints when you can, and highlighting good research, especially if it is still a preprint. Try platforms like ResearchHub (that pay for peer review) and experiment with AI based reviewers for faster feedback. Instead I read this as a proposed "revolutionary" measure:

Post attachment
Umut Sahin avatar
Umut Sahin@SahinLabSU·Mar 10

Our new paper demonstrates for the first time the in vivo feasibility of PML-based therapeutic strategies for neurodegeneration. Focusing on ALS, we provide strong proof of concept evidence that inducing PML to clear disease-causing proteins is a promising therapeutic approach

Post attachment
Venk Murthy MD PhD avatar
⟳ Umut Sahin retweeted
Venk Murthy MD PhD@venkmurthy·Jan 24

Sadly, the rate publication inflation is likely to get worse! The slicing of what should be a supplemental figure into entire separate papers, and then slicing again, and again is now standard practice It threatens scientific quality and actually may slow real progress

Post attachment
Sabine Hossenfelder avatar
⟳ Umut Sahin retweeted
Sabine Hossenfelder@skdh·Jan 10

Two business school professors from the University of Technology in Sydney have sounded the alarm on the declining quality of academic literature in a new publication titled “The junkification of research”. Drawing parallels to the “enshittification” of online platforms, they argue that similar forces are now overwhelming scholarly publishing. The key drivers are threefold: 1) relentless “publish or perish” pressures in academia, 2) scientific publisher’s incentive to publish more to make more money, and 3) AI making paper production faster and easier. Taken together, they say, these drivers are a recipe for disaster. The authors call for a shift to not-for-profit models of scientific publishing and better evaluation systems. I strongly doubt either is going to happen. The problem is of course not new, and you all know that I have been drawing attention to this trend for more than a decade. It is interesting to see, however, that the awareness for the issue is increasing. Paper: Rhodes, C., & Linnenluecke, M. K., “The junkification of research” Organization (2025).

Post attachment
Jason Locasale avatar
⟳ Umut Sahin retweeted
Jason Locasale@LocasaleLab·4 Dec 2025

Science used to be about discovery. Now it’s about formatting PDFs correctly for a 9% chance of funding.