←
Sam Altarac4,891 posts
Sam Altarac avatar

Sam Altarac

@SamAltarac

HS Math & Science teacher | Math & Science education consultant | CogSci | Here to learn.

◷ Joined April 2012▧ 330 Photos and videos
Sam Altarac avatar
Sam Altarac@SamAltarac·Oct 17

Make invisible science visible. 🔬 90+ interactive simulations for K–12, from plate tectonics to particle models. Students change the variables, watch what happens, and explain why. 🇬🇧🇫🇷🇪🇸 · NGSS-aligned · no student sign-up 12 are free 👉 omnilabseducation.com

0:30
Dissident Teacher avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Dissident Teacher@edudissenter·Nov 9

Great explanation of E.D. Hirsch’s core insight, and the reason he was unfairly shunned:

He clearly (and courageously) articulated what should be common sense: the ability to read & understand increasingly complex texts depends on the reader having an equally complex fund of culturally shared knowledge & vocabulary. A writer for the NYTimes can assume his reader will know who Abraham Lincoln was, what is meant by "The early bird gets the worm," what the Bill of Rights is, what anesthetics are. Doesn't need to be expert on any of that - just know without the writer having to define it. Hirsch was maligned when his first book Cultural Literacy was published as a nasty, supremacist Conservative at the time. It was taboo to take him seriously. White Man's List o'Facts, they jeered.

Dissident Teacher avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Dissident Teacher@edudissenter·Nov 8

Inquiry learning and group projects mask misbehavior and give the illusion of learning. In a direct instruction setting, misbehavior can’t be ignored, nor can the damage it does. And thus, in a permissive school, direct instruction exposes the inadequacy of the new no-punishment orthodoxy. No wonder principals are loathe to embrace it.

Had an interesting conversation with a visiting American teacher - their position is that the push back against explicit teaching* is because it exposes the problems with the systems. It exposes the poor behaviour, it exposes the kids who can't read, it exposes the students who don't get it. If you have discovery learning, and kids milling around and chatting and copying off each other, everyone looks engaged and like they're learning. Once you try to get them to sit down and actually teach them, you have to have systems in place for the kids who refuse. *They said direct instruction, but they were talking about explicit teaching more generally

Zach Groshell avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Zach Groshell@MrZachG·Nov 8

Anita Archer made a point on Progressively Incorrect I keep coming back to. Teachers shouldn't have to build curriculum from scratch. Get the best program you can, annotate it, and put your energy into the teaching. The podcast returns soon. Catch up here. 👇

Post attachment
Anna Stokke avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Anna Stokke@rastokke·Nov 4

💬 Don't confuse the end goal with the best way to get there. We want students to become independent thinkers and problem solvers, but we can't expect novices to learn the same way experts do. Experts have a lot of knowledge for problem solving, but novices don't. @hruizmartin 🔗 Episode link below.

Post attachment
Carl Hendrick avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Carl Hendrick@C_Hendrick·Oct 31

*NEW POST* Is Understanding Just "Remembering in Disguise”? Revisiting @DTWillingham's aporism in light of a new paper by John Sweller and colleagues.

Post attachment
Zach Groshell avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Zach Groshell@MrZachG·Nov 4

Carl Hendrick revisits Willingham's line that understanding is remembering in disguise, using a new paper from John Sweller. Worth your time.

*NEW POST* Is Understanding Just "Remembering in Disguise”? Revisiting @DTWillingham's aporism in light of a new paper by John Sweller and colleagues.

Post attachment
Robert Pondiscio avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Robert Pondiscio@rpondiscio·Nov 2

The uncomfortable question is why a basic, bedrock government funded and run service, public education, is not required or expected to follow evidence where it leads, without a hint controversy.

What if one of Americas largest education experiments revealed something we still don’t want to talk about? In the 1970s, Project Follow Through put nearly 20 teaching models to the test in classrooms serving children from low income families. There was one approach that stood out - Direct Instruction. It didn’t just produce stronger academic results in reading and mathematics, but it also performed incredibly well in problem solving and student self esteem. Yet decades later, we’re still debating whether this approach belongs in our classrooms…Why? The latest season of Sold a Story brings this debate back into focus. But the history goes much deeper than one podcast or one teaching method. Perhaps it’s time to ask a bigger question: Are we choosing teaching methods based on what looks good in a classroom, or what actually helps children learn? 🎥 Watch the video and join the conversation. @ehanford #Soldastory

1:30
beanie0597_2.0 avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
beanie0597_2.0@0Beanie05923291·Nov 1

I was telling my husband about season 2 of Sold A Story yesterday. He was absolutely baffled by it. He doesn’t understand how a proven and effective model of teaching children, especially children who arrive at school behind, can just be dismissed. This is how most people outside of education respond when they hear about what really goes on in education. It sounds absolutely nonsensical to everyone else, because it is.

Robert Pondiscio avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Robert Pondiscio@rpondiscio·Nov 1

I’ve spent 20 years convinced that the way we train teachers to teach reading and writing is broken, counter-productive, and harmful. There is a non-trivial chance math is worse.

This 2nd grade teacher is being propped up as an example to people across Utah as to how math should be taught in elementary school. He “trains” hundreds of new and current teachers. What say ye @rastokke @MrZachG @sarahpowellphd

2:23
Vince Boley avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Vince Boley@VinceBoley·Oct 29

"Gaining a broad knowledge of words, and therefore also a knowledge of the things to which words refer, must be among the most practical and significant educational goals in our time." -E. D. Hirsch 1996

Anna Stokke avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Anna Stokke@rastokke·Oct 28

Giving novices problems they lack the knowledge to solve makes little sense. Ausubel said this in 1968 and it still holds true. "If I have to reduce all educational psychology to just one principle, I would say this: the most important single factor influencing learning is what the learner already knows. Ascertain this and teach [the learner] accordingly." -David Ausubel

Zach Groshell avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Zach Groshell@MrZachG·Oct 24

I used to teach science where I’d facilitate an experiment, stop it on occasion to explicitly teach, and then have them dive back in. While that was better than discovery learning, it was way worse than pre-teaching the science content. This is true of other subjects as well.

Dylan Wiliam avatar
⟳ Sam Altarac retweeted
Dylan Wiliam@dylanwiliam·Oct 25

That's why I think opportunity cost is the single most important idea in school improvement. Every hour our teachers—and our students—spend on one thing is an hour they don't have to spend on something else. And this matters most of all for students who find learning hardest...