
This Halloween, I have a new essay out in @thedispatch. I contemplate Cormac McCarthy’s unique gifts as a novelist focused on the problem of evil. Link below👇

"Nature is a language." writer: The Dispatch, Real Clear Books, The Critic, First Things sambuntz.substack.com

This Halloween, I have a new essay out in @thedispatch. I contemplate Cormac McCarthy’s unique gifts as a novelist focused on the problem of evil. Link below👇

Totally and straightforwardly nuts.
It is critically important that everyone thinking about AI become familiar with the term “handoverism.” Many in the AI community believe that humanity should—or inevitably will—hand control of the world over to AI itself. Some view this not as a risk to be avoided, but as an outcome to be welcomed. Are we actually designing toward this future? This worldview is particularly relevant at Anthropic. Co-founder Tom Brown said: “There’s going to be a handoff where humanity will hand off control to transformative AI at some point.” In his seminal essay, Machines of Loving Grace, CEO Dario Amodei contemplates: “It could be a capitalist economy of AI systems, which then give out resources (huge amounts of them, since the overall economic pie will be gigantic) to humans based on some secondary economy of what the AI systems think makes sense to reward in humans (based on some judgment ultimately derived from human values).” Are you prepared to receive your “resources” from an AI system, based on criteria it determines? The full title of the poem Dario borrowed the title from is "All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace." Do you want to be "watched over" by AI? If Anthropic's founders believe that the ultimate destination is the transfer of human control to AI, the world deserves to know. Washington, D.C. deserves to know. American citizens deserve to know. And if that belief informs Anthropic's corporate objectives, it belongs in the Risk Factors section of its S-1. It isn't there today. I am decidedly anti-handoverism. I'm not here to tell you what your view should be. But I believe anyone making consequential decisions about AI—especially those drafting, advocating for, or enacting AI regulation—should be required to disclose where they stand on this fundamental question. A wonderfully thoughtful piece on the subject by @RuxandraTeslo: writingruxandrabio.com/p/han…

Something Nagel observes in the interview is that academic philosophy of mind has, instead of better informing public opinion on this issue, only served to lend institutional credence to the fantastic, though broadly unfounded, claims of AI firms and tech CEOs. Anthropic, as Nagel remarks, is the worst of the bunch because it takes conscious steps to humanize its proprietary model with all sorts of familiar spontaneities as to better mimic human self-consciousness. Researchers, counseled by AI ethicists, are creating the impression of the thing that they believe to be the case because they take the human mind to be scarcely different from a really-complex computer. Much of the confusion surrounding consciousness and AI has to do with the misuse of metaphor.
Thomas Nagel singling out Anthropic as being particularly abominable in its approach to AI:

Nagel's voice was missing from the AI consciousness debate, and we should now thank him for injecting a good dose of sanity into the conversation.
Thomas Nagel on why AI can't be conscious. Amen, brother. Nice to hear one of the greatest philosophers of mind weighing in.




You identify a great reason not to be "extremely pro AI." It's all about cheap, quick results, the final form of a disposable Dixie Cup culture. I reject the entire underlying presumption of their worldview for this reason. The soul needs time and space to grow.
I’m extremely pro AI, but it’s incredibly off-putting how 90+% of “AI bros” fail to understand that the process of creating something can be more valuable than the finished thing. It makes the whole enterprise feel aesthetically rancid & tasteless

Always worth reiterating re higher ed AI policy that the choice is not between extreme anti-AI measures and moderation. There are only two choices, both extreme: teach like it’s the 1990s, or accept the slow but steady collapse of liberal education and mass literacy.
It doesn't go far enough. Ban the internet too. They should have the primary texts, a pen, some paper, and other human beings to talk to. That's it.

Everything sucks now. The low, soft lights became Walmart lighting. The natural-fiber bespoke suit became a plastic, ill-fitting sweatshop-made jacket fit for hotel staff. The medieval mosque became kitsch built by an aura-less dictatorial post-Soviet republic. Decline.
GEN-Z Malcolm X

Prepare for a grid-down situation: split your soul into seven parts, and link each part to an object that’s meaningful for you, hiding them in various strategic locations. Make sure your family have enough information to be able to identify these objects.

Trillion dollar idea: a machine that breaks other machines. But it also causes unemployment. But it also breaks the spirit of artists. But it also convinces you not to take your medication. But it's also very vulnerable to being stolen by spies, depending on how horny you are.

What's nice about food is that it is often separated from the aesthetic sensibility of the owner of the restaurant. A guy knows how to make an incredible meal so he opens up a restaurant. But his signs and interior are terrible. This is long been normal with restaurants.
Restaurants should be embarrassed by this. I cannot for the life of me understand how any human being can look at this and be like "this is a good representation of our food" like what even the fuck is inside those things? Beads? Berries? Wtf am I looking at?!


@sharghzadeh what do you think about this?

Probably the most fake-sounding post I will ever make in my life. Yet true. Forgotten American lore. Unknown Americana. Grant Wood drew this! Was a whole people did. Larp as Persian Shia Muslims, aesthetically and pseudo-ceremonially. We were not always “opposed” to the Orient.
It was once a popular social activity in America to LARP as a mystical Persian Shia anti-Wahhabi freemason, replete with attending “mosques”, praising Ali and “Prophet Mohammed”, using a prop Quran, greeting with a Salaam, and going to a “mecca”. Four of our presidents did this.