Why this OC crime victim's sister supports @CAgovernor@GavinNewsom's decision to take people off death row. More than half a dozen family members spoke at a virtual news conference, urging the California Supreme Court to quickly approve Newsom's plan.
Bethany Webb's sister, Laura, was one of eight people killed in Seal Beach in 2011. "I'm a mom. I have taught my children two wrongs don't make a right," Webb said. "This is for all of us — the people who have been fed that false narrative that someday they're going to feel better when that person is murdered. It's not going to happen that way. Nothing is taking this pain away."
nbclosangeles.com/news/local…@NBCLA@HettyNBCLA@DPFocus@SmartJusticeCA@Journey0fHope@uscedp#deathpenalty
The California Supreme Court has issued a briefing schedule "invit[ing] briefing by interested persons or entities as amici curiae addressing the legal issues raised by the Governor's request for a recommendation allowing him to issue a commutation reducing all sentences of death to life in prison without the possibility of parole."
The operative phrases are "as amicus curiae" and "addressing the legal issues." I read this to mean that the court views prosecutors, defense counsel, victim family members for or against the commutations, and other "interested persons or entities" as friends of the court, not as parties to the action.
The language that the court will consider submissions "addressing the legal issues raised by the Governor's request for a recommendation" for universal clemency suggests that the court is not interested in policy arguments for or against the death penalty, political arguments about the clemency process, or case-by-case assessments of the merits of individual grants of clemency. Instead, it appears to want interested individuals and entities to present arguments limited to discussing the legality of the commutation process (universal clemency) that the governor is proposing.
appellatecases.courtinfo.ca.…@DPFocus@SmartJusticeCA@Journey0fHope@ACLU_NorCal@ACLU_SoCal@ellabakercenter@NAACP_LDF@WTIUSA@uscedp#deathpenalty
“It felt important that he understand that we haven’t forgiven the man who killed Polly,” said her sister. “We still feel anger and grief, but we just believe that those feelings, however understandable, shouldn’t determine public policy.” latimes.com/california/story…
Capital punishment is a barbaric, inhumane practice that belongs firmly in the past. As a long-time vocal opponent of the death penalty, I commend @CAgovernor for commuting the sentences of everyone on death row in the Golden State.
Breaking News: California Governor Gavin Newsom spared the lives of everyone on death row in the state, commuting the sentences of 548 prisoners. nyti.ms/4zu9I2f
"it’s a can of worms he didn’t have to open — the clearest statement we’ll ever get of who Newsom is as a leader. And it’s a welcome reminder that sometimes, occasionally, values still have a place in politics." #commutetherow
As a lawyer, you should know the law.
State regulations explicitly exclude these individuals from the new review process established by the Board of Parole Hearings. (See California Code of Regulations, Title 15, section 2843, subdivision (b)(6))
Profound appreciation to Governor Gavin Newsom who courageously commuted the sentences of all 548 prisoners on death row in California.
My father was murdered in California and when his assailant was sentenced to death, his brother, Senator Edward Kennedy, on behalf of our family, asked that the murderer's life be spared. He was right then, and Gavin Newsom is right today.
It may be politically expedient to support the death penalty, but it is always morally repugnant.
Let's remember the words of Robert Kennedy on April 5, 1968:
"Whenever any American's life is taken by another American unnecessarily - whether it is done in the name of the law or in the defiance of law, by one man or a gang, in cold blood or in passion, in an attack of violence or in response to violence - whenever we tear at the fabric of life which another man has painfully and clumsily woven for himself and his children, the whole nation is degraded."
“Today I am acting on my long and deeply held conviction that individually and collectively we are stronger as a society when we reject state-sanctioned killing,” Gov. Newsom wrote when announcing he would commute the state's 548 death sentences.
eji.org/news/gov-newsom-comm…