←
Michael Smith487 posts
Michael Smith avatar

Michael Smith

@SmithBeeLab

Assistant Prof at Auburn. Interested in collective behavior, automated tracking, social physiology, and how honey bee colonies do what they do.

◷ Joined November 2019▧ 82 Photos and videos
Peter Marting avatar
⟳ Michael Smith retweeted
Peter Marting@AztecaCecropia·13 Nov 2024

New pub! Honeybee nests are super symmetrical, the pattern of cell contents is mirrored on either side of the comb. This symmetry 1 is unique to each comb in the nest 2 evolves over time while maintaining symmetry 3 aids in thermoregulation and rearing 4 conserved across Apis🔗⬇️

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

As for symmetry, well, it looks like we ALSO find it in the extended phenotype of the superorganism, and it has a functional benefit. And it’s been sitting right in front of us for so long! Once again, you can observe a lot just by watching.

Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

So, what did we learn? Well, first off, this wouldn’t have been possible without a rocking lab team, funding from the @NSF, and exceptional collaborators. Huge thanks to all for making this happen. (it's an old lab photo, but lots of important peeps are in there!)

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

Would we find this symmetry in other Apis species? It was a long-shot, but we got in touch with Bajaree Chuttong from Thailand, to see if she had nest images of other Apis species (both sides). With @EricaMaul, we transcribed these nests, and holy moly, they’re symmetrical too!

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

But does this symmetry actually exist in a 3-dimensional nest? @prathibha897 and @ben_koger to the rescue! We let colonies build 3D nests in empty boxes, and compared both sides of each comb - each one is only symmetrical with its backside (not within or across colonies).

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

So, does this actually matter to a colony? YES, it does! If you “fold” a one-sided nest onto itself, creating a two-sided nest, then colonies produce more brood, AND have a more stable temperature profile (temp is super important for developing brood; Ethan is our temp guru).

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

And it’s a bullseye – the colonies exactly position their brood nest with the higher temperature. 100% of the capped brood was colocalized with the heatpad (yes, we also tested this statistically, obvi).

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

So, how exactly are the bees inferring the nest contents across an impermeable barrier? Maybe it’s temperature cues? (bees keep their brood nice and toasty). We randomly placed heatpads to see if that would bias where nests were located.

Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

YES, THEY ARE SYMMETRICAL! The two sides of comb are as symmetrical when you have two independent colonies (without contact) or a single colony with access to both sides. Shout-out to “team photo” led by @AztecaCecropia, and “team gross” led by… me.

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

…but… do the bees need to be in direct contact with both sides of the comb? Introducing the weirdest observation hive ever: one colony goes on one side, and a totally independent colony on the other. Will they continue to build symmetrical nests?

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

Surprise! Whatever is on one side of the comb, is a mirror image of the opposite side! Here’s an example, where the colors denote different nest contents. Roberto Molinari, statistician @AuburnU, made sure we weren’t totally insane.

Post attachment
Michael Smith avatar
Michael Smith@SmithBeeLab·13 Nov 2024

Symmetry is everywhere. We find it aesthetically pleasing, and it’s important for locomotion (see planes, trains, and automobiles). But… would we find it a structure built by the collective? (see awesome nest photo by @AztecaCecropia)

Post attachment