←
Nicholas Beale46,171 posts
Nicholas Beale avatar

Nicholas Beale

@Starcourse

Chair, 695th Lord Mayor's Ethical AI Initiative. Personal views only. Blog on science & religion etc. Work in Strategy & Search. I only follow people I’ve met.

◷ Joined January 2018▧ 2,483 Photos and videos
Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·1 Jul 2020

#unethicalOptimizationPrinciple paper now out in @royalsociety Open Science. Thanks to brilliant co-authors Heather Battey, Anthony Davison & Robert Mackay. @DameWendyDBE gave us quote for press: "This is a really important paper. It shows that… (1/n) royalsocietypublishing.org/d…

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·15h

Wise to experiment. But  the 23% of…audit committee chairs who ‘had “limited” confidence in AI. Concerns included…risk of auditors becoming over-reliant on AI…data security &… “hallucinations”’ are wise too. ft.com/content/5168b3e9-75d0… via @ft

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·Nov 17

Sorting out NEETs & Social Care are laudable ambitions. But they need a coherent focused programme that encourages economic growth. It’s v hard for HMG to do more than 3 things at once. So maybe the main focus should be getting NEETs into social care? thetimes.com/comment/columni…

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·Nov 16

“latent defect caused servers to become…unresponsive under certain load conditions…result of a fix…update went through safe deployment…globally over several weeks, during which time no issues were observed” Underlines need fur verification not just testing.

More details on the root cause can be found in the Microsoft 365 Admin center, and an abridged version can be found below. We are deeply sorry for the impact to all our customers and recognize the impact that this has on their normal business & operations. The incident on Thursday, November 12th, 2026, was caused by three main factors that together caused a global outage for the networking gateway that fronts many Microsoft 365 services. First, a latent defect caused servers to become overwhelmed and unresponsive under certain load conditions. This was due to lock contention inside an internal process which caused the machine to become unavailable. This defect was the result of a fix that was prepared specifically for Microsoft 365 networking gateway servers; neither the underlying defect nor the fix applies to broader Windows deployments. The initial change in behavior first started deployment in July of this year. The update went through safe deployment and saturated globally over several weeks, during which time no issues were observed. For more than three months, the change was deployed worldwide without impact. Our normal load testing did not detect the latent issue because the different traffic and SKU mix used in our test labs. The contention issue is worsened on machines with more cores and newer hardware; whereas our load testing tended to focus on our weaker hardware SKUs with fewer cores. Second, a surge in load increased the likelihood for the networking gateways to encounter the contention. Within Microsoft 365, we maintain two independent and heterogenous network gateway systems designed for isolation and high availability. This allows many Microsoft 365 services to fail to/from them during outages or disruptions. Approximately fifteen hours before the outage, Teams failed over from the alternative networking gateway to the ‘primary’ gateway that also supports Exchange Online. This increased the load on the networking gateway and changed its traffic patterns. This type of failover is part of normal operations and is integral to standard Microsoft resiliency efforts. Third, at the same time, nearly 14% of server capacity for the networking gateway was out of service due to an unrelated issue from the previous day. This server capacity was on track to be returned to active service through routine maintenance and health processes. The service had sufficient capacity headroom, so the reduction in server capacity had no impact on its own. Taken together, the increased load and the reduced server capacity, caused the network gateway to encounter the latent bug from July. This caused requests to build up until servers ultimately stopped responding. This occurred during the peak window of traffic in the United States. When servers lose connectivity, our traffic management systems automatically route users to other healthy endpoints. This happens often and is critical to avoiding any interruption due to hardware, software, or network defects and is normally what makes the service resilient. However, the redirected traffic increased the likelihood for the same problem to occur on the remaining endpoints. This caused a cascading failure from server to server as the same amount of load was spread across fewer servers. In less than two hours, the previously unknown defect was encountered across our fleet and rendered them unresponsive. At its lowest, more than 80% of servers were unresponsive. Normally, the network gateway is composed of thousands of ‘capacity units’ which represent shards of capacity, hardware, and networking infrastructure. These ‘capacity units’ are then organized into regions. In this case, due to a separate issue, the normal bulkheads between these different partitions did not stop the cascading failure. This is what allowed the impact to spread across our network gateway infrastructure globally. Several services like Teams, OneDrive, SharePoint, and Office apps failed out of the faulty network gateway infrastructure. That is why those services were restored earlier, with Teams chats and meetings functioning without issue for most of the outage. But not all services, like Exchange Online, can fail out of this network gateway. Recovery took longer than usual because as servers returned to service, they were immediately overwhelmed by waiting traffic and became unresponsive again. Our normally automated recovery processes were not designed to restore service from this broad unresponsive state. Additionally, since the main code defect was a latent bug from several months previous, our normal rollback, flighting, and feature flags were unable to quickly revert the change. After engineers confirmed the defect as the cause, we developed an update that returned the code path to the previously known good state. To effectively apply this fix, and to slowly bring the service online again, we took groups of servers out of service, applied the change, and restarted them before returning them to service. This process was carefully applied to large quantities of infrastructure at a time (e.g. 50%+ of a region). The final Post-Incident Review (PIR) will provide more details later this week.

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·Nov 16

“restoration of Buckingham Palace…10-y project with a £369mn budget…praised by the [NAO] for disciplined management, risk controls & willingness to make…trade-offs. The palace has remained operational throughout.” Put them in charge? ft.com/content/9bbefade-8ca7… by @Jesse_Norman

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·Nov 14

Revd MB Peel won an MC & Bar in WW1 & was killed by a sniper whilst tending to a man in Battle of Cambrai. "His practice was to live with the men in the line & in action to go over with3rd…wave, so that he might tend to all those who had fallen earlier" winchestercollegeatwar.com/R…

Nicholas Beale avatar
Nicholas Beale@Starcourse·Nov 13

For Brits of a certain age having someone called Harvey Jones sorting out corporate troubles has a delightfully retro ring. Sobering to think that Nvidia’s Market Cap is more than 100x that of ICI when Sir John Harvey-Jones was chairman, in real terms. thetimes.com/business/compan…