←
Stef Benstead24,194 posts
Stef Benstead avatar

Stef Benstead

@StefBenstead

Christian interested in disability, poverty, welfare, & justice. Author: Just Worship; Second Class Citizens. Chronically ill/ELCI: hEDS, PoTS & fibro/?SFN.

◷ Joined January 2012▧ 111 Photos and videos
Thanos Angelopoulos avatar
⟳ Stef Benstead retweeted
Thanos Angelopoulos@Th_Angelopoulos·3h

3/ Most of that money goes to pensioners: • In 2024/25 DWP spent £304.7bn on benefits, at 2026/27 prices. Of that, £173.7bn, or 57%, went to people over State Pension age. • Since 1978/79, benefit spending has risen by £219.9bn a year after inflation. Of that rise, £115.8bn, or 53%, went to pensioners. • In 2024/25, 12.99 million people received the State Pension, against 8.58 million in 1978/79.

Thanos Angelopoulos avatar
⟳ Stef Benstead retweeted
Thanos Angelopoulos@Th_Angelopoulos·3h

2/ The bill is not out of control. Out of every £100 the economy produces, this is how much goes on benefits: • £8.25 in 1978/79, the last year before Thatcher took office. • £12.04 in 2012/13, under the coalition, which was the peak. • £10.38 in 2024/25. With council tax support added back (DWP stopped counting it in 2013), that's about £10.50. That is roughly where it stood in 1993/94 under Major, at £10.53. DWP's own forecast for 2030/31 is £10.88.

Post attachment
Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

"Over decades, even as employment has been rising, youth employment has been falling." - this statement should have been paired with the graph from the IFS report "Why has the NEET rate risen?", to provide visual clarity on what has actually happened with youth employment rates.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Yes, there is a broad trend downwards: the employment rate for young adults in 2025 is lower than 1991. But to generalise this as 'decades of downward trend' overlooks times of growth and stability, and implies an overall picture that ignores the failure to recover from 2007/8.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Figure 9 from Michael et al (2026) shows that youth employment rates: - rose from 1992 to 1997; - remained stable until 2002; - started to fall until 2007, then fell sharply 2007-2009; - stabilised and then started to rise in 2013; - stabilised until around 2023 (except Covid)

Post attachment
Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

I'm finding it surprisingly hard to find data on youth *employment*. Internet searches prioritise pages containing data on *unemployment*. Milburn links to the *press release* for an IFS report, rather than to the report itself. That's poor referencing. ifs.org.uk/news/recent-fall-…

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Not evidenced: "Over decades, even as employment has been rising, youth employment has been falling." ONS data: "The total number of employed young people has increased for the sixth quarter in a row." #FactCheckMilburn youthemployment.org.uk/labou…

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Not evidenced: "Fewer young people get early exposure to work." That's a claim that needs data over time.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Correct: "Employment policy has concentrated on changing the young person. The almost exclusive focus has been on improving their employability. The assumption has been that the labour market would then generate demand for that improved supply. That is not what has happened."

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

- Available data indicates that the main gap between the UK and other OECD countries when it comes to NEETs is not the employment rate, but the vocational education rate; - 2/3 of NEETs have previously had work; - Govt, not private business, is responsible for full employment.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Ch3 of the Milburn report is "Labour Market: A first chance". It opens with: "A first chance. That is what is missing from the labour market for too many young people. Employers hold the key to creating that opportunity." Hang on a minute...

Has anyone else felt that the Milburn report reads more like a (very) extended blog post than a formal report? The language is very informal and choppy. There are no data tables, even in the Analytical Annex. The data provided feels superficial, and insufficient for the claims.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

73% of NEETs want EET. Who are the other 27%? Do they all actively say that they don't want EET, or did they say they didn't know, or did they not answer? If they don't want EET, how many are parents, carers, or sick/disabled themselves? Or just on a gap yeah?

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

I'm left wanting so much more information. 2/3 of current NEETs have had work before. Of the 1/3 who haven't, how old are they? Have they recently left education? What are their characteristics compared to those who have worked?

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

My overall feeling from Milburn Ch2 is that the data is very superficial and it's not well-presented; the conclusions are not supported by the data; and the language is emotive and informal rather than clear and objective.

Stef Benstead avatar
Stef Benstead@StefBenstead·1h

Did your school help you: - gain the quals you need = NEET 35%, EET 62%; - develop skills = 29% v 48%; - be successful at work = 16% v 30%; - prepare for adult life = 14% v 22%; - get a job = 11% v 22%. I'm not getting much confidence from schools, even for EETs!