←
Stuart Dowell5,246 posts
Stuart Dowell avatar✓

Stuart Dowell ✓

@StuartDowell_

Political Editor & Commentator at TVP World | Poland & CEE | Politics, elections, security and geopolitics | Warsaw-based | Views my own

◷ Joined March 2018▧ 1,005 Photos and videos
Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·21 Nov 2025

A shocking part of the Trump–Russia "peace plan" isn’t just what it does to Ukraine. It is what it quietly does to Poland. Buried in point 9 is a sentence that looks harmless: European fighters will be stationed in Poland. On paper, that sounds fine. In practice, though, it looks like Washington and Moscow have agreed over Poland’s head to limit the presence of foreign forces on Polish soil, including US forces, and to put a ceiling on NATO air power over the region. If “European fighters” are explicitly named, the obvious Russian reading is simple: no US jets in Poland. And if Russia is co-signing language that defines who and what can be stationed here, it is also a de facto say over NATO air policing in the Baltics and the rest of the eastern flank. That is not “Pax Americana.” That is the US accepting a Russian veto over the security posture of front-line allies. For Polish politics this hits a very specific nerve. For years, Jarosław Kaczyński and now President Karol Nawrocki have built their doctrine on one core idea: forget Brussels, forget Berlin, our security rests on a direct, privileged relationship with Washington. For a country that has spent a decade telling itself that American power is the only real guarantee, that should be a brutal wake-up call.

Post attachment
Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·4h

It's worth pointing out that the latest reporting is that the Constitutional Tribunal has yet to announce the outcome of yesterday's General Assembly meeting, whose legitimacy is disputed, concerning the immunity of its disputed president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and vice-president Bartłomiej Sochański. The assembly considered prosecutors' applications to lift their immunity, including a request to authorise Święczkowski's detention. Polish Radio reported yesterday that both judges had lost their immunity, which I repeated in my earlier post. But the Tribunal subsequently announced that the outcome would only be made public today. So we are still waiting for confirmation of what was decided, including whether detention was authorised.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·6h

A Russian false-flag operation involving potentially large numbers of casualties was reportedly thwarted by Polish security forces earlier this month. This is an extremely serious report, suggesting that Russia was prepared to risk a major confrontation with NATO. According to Rzeczpospolita today, which cites senior security sources, Russian intelligence was preparing an operation near Poland's border with the Russian exclave of Kaliningrad in late October or early November. The plan allegedly involved saboteurs crossing into Poland and a staged attack on a target inside Russia, with evidence planted to implicate Ukrainians. One source compared it to the 1939 Gleiwitz incident, staged by Nazi Germany to help justify its invasion of Poland. Poland responded by deploying counterterrorism police, intelligence officers, border guards and elite military units, including GROM special forces, to the border region. Similar warnings reportedly reached Lithuania, Latvia and Estonia. Poland's intelligence services coordinator, Tomasz Siemoniak, confirmed that the authorities had responded to what they considered a real threat, although he declined to confirm details of the alleged Russian plot. The reported objective was to undermine Western support for Ukraine. rp.pl/konflikty-zbrojne/art4…

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·19h

Donald Tusk's government has comfortably survived today's vote of no confidence in the Polish parliament, with 242 MPs voting against the motion and 200 in favour. The result was never really in doubt. The opposition simply doesn't have the numbers to bring down the government. But I suspect Mateusz Morawiecki, the former prime minister and now leader of the breakaway centre-right Rozwój Plus, will regard the exercise as something of a political success. He managed to bring a constructive vote of no confidence before parliament, proposed former Sejm speaker Marek Jurek as an alternative prime minister, and put himself at the centre of the debate about the future of the Polish right. Meanwhile, the General Assembly of the Constitutional Tribunal, the legitimacy of which is disputed by the opposition, voted to lift the judicial immunity of its disputed president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and vice-president Bartłomiej Sochański. Prosecutors want to pursue Święczkowski over alleged abuses of power during his time as national prosecutor, including the use of the Pegasus and Hermes surveillance systems, as well as allegations that he obstructed other Constitutional Tribunal judges from carrying out their duties. Sochański faces allegations concerning the obstruction of judges and violations of their employment rights. But the legitimacy of today's General Assembly is itself contested. Święczkowski insists that he remains the Tribunal's lawful president and that only he has the authority to convene such a meeting. He also disputes the status of judges who have not taken their oath before President Karol Nawrocki. Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, who has assumed control of the Tribunal's day-to-day operations, rejects that interpretation. So we now have another set of potentially consequential legal decisions whose validity is disputed by the very officials they concern. And finally, Nawrocki has announced that he will make the long-delayed changes to Tusk's government on Friday. These are expected to include the appointment of Finance Minister Andrzej Domański as deputy prime minister and Agnieszka Bartol as minister for funds and regional policy. The president has been holding up the appointments for weeks, with the dispute over the Constitutional Tribunal further aggravating relations between the Presidential Palace and the government. At least that particular standoff now appears to be nearing an end. rp.pl/polityka/art45501961-r…

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 17

Two things to keep an eye on in Polish politics today. At 9 am, Constitutional Tribunal judges meet to consider stripping the Tribunal's disputed president, Bogdan Święczkowski, of his judicial immunity. Prosecutors have submitted several applications concerning alleged misconduct, including one seeking permission to detain him. My assessment is that the lifting of his immunity is highly likely. Meanwhile, this afternoon, the Sejm is scheduled to debate and vote on a motion of no confidence in Donald Tusk's government. Submitted by Mateusz Morawiecki's Rozwój Plus, the motion proposes Marek Jurek as replacement prime minister. The debate begins at 3 pm, with the vote expected after 4.45 pm. The motion needs 231 votes to pass. In my view, its chances of succeeding are virtually nil.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 16

Poland's Constitutional Tribunal has money in the bank. The trouble is, the national bank won't let it spend any. Welcome to the latest episode of Poland's constitutional soap opera. The National Bank of Poland (NBP), headed by Adam Glapiński, has frozen outgoing payments from the Tribunal's accounts because it cannot establish who is legally entitled to authorise them. Bogdan Święczkowski, the Tribunal's disputed president, insists he remains in charge. Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, who has taken over its day-to-day operations, says otherwise. Both have submitted competing documents to the NBP. Święczkowski actually asked the bank to block his opponents' access to the money. He has welcomed the freeze, even though it applies to him too. Meanwhile, Korwin-Piotrowska has produced another embarrassment for the Tribunal: a collection of yellow sticky notes allegedly used by its previous leadership to manipulate the composition of judicial panels. The handwritten instructions reportedly specified which judges should hear particular cases and which should be excluded. Most date from Julia Przyłębska's presidency, although some concern Święczkowski's tenure. Judges are supposed to be assigned according to established rules, rather than handpicked by the court's leadership. Otherwise, a president who knows how individual judges are likely to interpret the law could potentially influence the outcome simply by choosing who hears a case. The allegations have yet to be independently established. wiadomosci.onet.pl/kraj/chao…

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 15

Potentially good news for Poland's long-running campaign to secure a permanent US military base. The Pentagon is reportedly planning much smaller cuts to US troop numbers in Europe than originally feared, with NATO’s eastern flank potentially getting reinforcements. That is encouraging news for Poland, which is pressing Washington for a permanent American military base. Bloomberg reports, citing officials familiar with the Pentagon’s deliberations, that cuts could be far smaller than the 25,000 troops initially feared. European allies now expect around 5,000, although nothing has been confirmed. Germany could bear the brunt. Congressional restrictions on troop withdrawals and the importance of European bases for US operations in the Iran war appear to be influencing the Pentagon’s thinking. But what strikes me is the timing. Washington has just invited Moscow to submit its demands for a new European security architecture as part of the Ukraine peace negotiations. And we know that Russia has long wanted restrictions on NATO forces in Eastern Europe, including American troops and bases. Poland could be on the verge of securing a permanent US base just as Washington opens discussions with Moscow about the very security arrangements that would govern its presence. Bloomberg: arcamax.com/currentnews/news…

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

It's a political trap: Nawrocki wants to defend free speech, but Tusk can say he's blocking measures to protect children online.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

Nawrocki still wasn't satisfied. Donald Tusk has seized on the veto, saying that "protecting children from online criminals" should transcend political divisions. "And yet he vetoed it."

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

This is his second veto of the legislation. After the first in January, the government revised the bill, reserving decisions on blocking some categories of content, including hate speech and totalitarian propaganda, for the courts rather than administrative bodies.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

Nawrocki warns of the return of the "spectre of an official censor". He argues that the legislation would give government officials excessive powers to control the internet, including blocking entire websites.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

Nawrocki's latest veto could actually harm him politically. Poland's president has rejected a bill implementing the EU's Digital Services Act, intended to speed up action against illegal online content, including material involving the sexual exploitation of children. 1/ rp.pl/komentarze/art45487811…

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

If Rozwój Plus crosses 5%, Morawiecki could hold the balance of power. Below it, his party wins no seats and its votes may be wasted. For now, he's betting on independence rather than returning to Kaczyński's PiS fold.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

Here is the seat arithmetic. A majority requires 231 of the Sejm's 460 seats. WP projects PiS + Confederation + Braun at 215 seats. Add Morawiecki and the bloc reaches 238. KO + New Left have 222, or 245 with Morawiecki.

Stuart Dowell avatar
Stuart Dowell@StuartDowell_·Nov 14

But it's a gamble. Rozwój Plus keeps hovering above and below the 5% threshold. In the latest United Surveys poll: KO 30%, PiS 15.5%, Confederation 14%, Braun's KKP 9.1%, New Left 6.8%, Rozwój Plus 6.1%.