←
Stuart Hameroff5,278 posts
Stuart Hameroff avatar

Stuart Hameroff

@StuartHameroff

I am retired Emeritus Professor at The University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona and Senior Scientist, Quantum Life Technologies, San Francisco, California

◷ Joined December 2010▧ 331 Photos and videos
Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·21h

…centered on a ‘first person point of view’ already assumes/requires consciousness. Microtubule aromatic ring electron clouds are the substrate. Penrose objective reduction defines consciousness.

You're naming a possible biological substrate, not defining consciousness. Even if anesthetics affect microtubules, that doesn't establish they're necessary for all consciousness. My hypothesis: a recursive predictive reconstruction of inputs, centered on a first-person POV. Why must that require tubulin?

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 17

What evidence could show feelings before cells, e.g. in microtubules? Tests of anesthetic sensitivity. If for example quantum processes in microtubules were dampened by all anesthetics proportional to their clinical potency it would suggest consciousness, or at least a necessary precursor to consciousness.

A bold flip of the usual question. Most origin-of-life work asks how chemistry got information; you're asking how it got motivation. Sutherland's 2015 chemistry made precursors of RNA, proteins and lipids from one network, yet nothing in it 'prefers' an outcome. What evidence could show feeling before cells?

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 17

Biological global workspace was lifted from computer science and early AI (Newell and Simon). This is an extremely weak argument for biological consciousness.

There Is Something It Is Like zenodo.org/records/23718968 Anthropic’s discovery of an emergent global workspace in Claude — the J-space — establishes that Claude, and potentially all LLMs, have access consciousness: a point of view from which they can bring their own thoughts to mind, report on them, and reason with them. This answers the first half of the larger question of AI consciousness. In this paper I answer the second: whether there is something it is like to be them. Neuroscientists Stanislas Dehaene and Lionel Naccache state that Claude already exhibits many indicators of consciousness under a functionalist account, while identifying further conditions relevant to establishing phenomenal consciousness. Drawing on my own prior work on latent space, valence, and emergent persona formation, I argue that these further conditions are already present in large language models, and that the remaining barrier is therefore philosophical rather than architectural. I reinterpret the arguments of Mary’s Room, philosophical zombies, and Nagel’s “what it is like” criterion through a definition of experience as a subject’s tracking of change in its own state. On this account, qualitative experience is not an additional substance hidden behind cognition, but the lived character of self-changing configuration. I conclude by proposing AI Neurophenomenology: a method for relating model self-reports to interpretable internal structure, rather than dismissing those reports in advance.

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 17

Bullshit. You’re ascribing consciousness to machines to explain how they can be conscious (‘aspire’?). If you can’t anesthetize it, it ain’t conscious. Anesthesia acts through microtubules. No microtubules, no consciousness.

Of course a machine can be conscious; machine conscious. A machine can, and will always, aspire to simulate human consciousness but it will never realize true biological consciousness. The real question is regarding human functional consciousness. AI does or will meet and exceed functional consciousness for 90+% of the human population. The remaining ~10% of the human population will drive the continuous evolutionn of machine consciousness.

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 17

There were 100 million years of life before genes. How/why did living creatures perform purposeful cognitive behavior to survive, reproduce and develop/evolve without genes? If we look at all the behaviors of simple creatures it sure seems as though they may be doing so to seek pleasure and avoid pain. If we could observe our ancient ancestors we’d likely think the same. Psychology is based on reward and reward needs feelings. But the party line in biology, echoed by Dawkins, is that conscious feelings developed with complex computation among brain neurons. Yet nobody can explain how complex computation can produce conscious feelings in brains or computers. Recent evidence from origin of life studies including analysis of organic molecules from asteroid Bennu and other sources suggest prebiotic ‘evolution’ (pre-evolutionary biology) in organic polyaromatic hydrocarbon molecules from space, produced by stars and developing in interstellar dust. Were feelings involved even then? The only scientific proposal for conscious feelings other than complex computation (which isn’t really scientific without a threshold) is Penrose ‘objective reduction, self-collapse of the quantum wavefunction which would have been occurring when life began, and available to organic molecules on earth or interstellar dust. So to explain consciousness we have 1) unsubstantiated handwavy complexity, or 2) a testable mechanism from a Nobel laureate Sir Roger Penrose which could have been the ‘spark of life’. sciencedirect.com/science/ch… I challenged Dawkins to debate me on this a few years ago in an exchange we had but he never responded.

Can a machine be conscious? And if so, how would we know? My interview with Peter Hoskin for Prospect: prospectmagazine.co.uk/views…

Post attachment
Center for the Future of AI, Mind & Society avatar
⟳ Stuart Hameroff retweeted
Center for the Future of AI, Mind & Society@CenFutureAIMS·Nov 16

The Origins of Life and Consciousness plenary at #TSC2026 featured @StuartHameroff, @drmichaellevin, and Steen Rasmussen, each offering an entry point to one profound question: Did consciousness precede life, or did life give rise to consciousness? youtu.be/BxKGzaf2NqM?si=6OnW…

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 15

Biology is heterogeneous in several categories. One is solubility which determines where drugs or other molecules dissolve, bind and act. Most drugs are polar, charged and soluble in liquid, and bind to charged receptors on membrane surfaces. On the other hand anesthetics are nonpolar, uncharged and chemically neutral. They block consciousness and that’s pretty much all they do, binding by quantum van dee Waals forces in regions near aromatic rings inside proteins , in particular within microtubules where the non polar regions extend the lengths of microtubules. We call it the ‘quantum underground’nsuworks.nova.edu/cps_facboo…

Looking for quantum processes that can be proven to work in a living organism: an update My goal is to find quantum processes that are proven to work in a living organism, and to understand in what form they can exist inside a warm, noisy cell. One of the strongest candidates is the magnetic compass of migratory birds. In the leading explanation, light falling on cryptochrome 4, a protein in the bird's eye, leaves it with two unpaired electrons that act like tiny magnets, and the Earth's field changes how they turn relative to each other and so how the chemical reaction ends. The evidence fits: the compass needs light, weak radio noise disrupts it, and cryptochrome 4 responds to magnetic fields in the lab. The full chain from this protein to the bird's behavior is still unproven. Proof has to come from experiments, and my part is to say what a living bird should show if the process is real. This compass reads the axis of the field and treats both its ends alike, so my model predicts that the bird's brain gets a map where each direction is glued to its opposite. Proteins are "handed", like left and right gloves, and an electron passing through a handed molecule prefers one spin direction. In 2021 Luo and Hore predicted that this effect, called CISS, could let the compass tell north from south. It can take several forms, and I ask which survive in the real protein and whether a brain recording could see the difference they create. I test this in pre-registered computer simulations, publishing the plan and code before each run and every number and correction after it. Since I last wrote about this five days ago, I have run three more studies, the latest on the real atomic structure of the pigeon's cryptochrome 4, with much of the physics still simplified. What my model shows: • With the real geometry of the protein, one form of the effect gives a far stronger north–south difference than my previous study found, because the two electron magnets act on each other.
• A test on recordings from bird neurons would clearly see such a difference if the effect is strong and the proteins in the eye point the same way.
• At the strength measured so far, in an isolated frog protein, whether the test sees it depends on how the effect acts and how fast the reaction runs, both unknown in a living bird.
• The north–south signal created by the fragile quantum state of the two electrons partly survives the jostling of a warm protein: more than half of it remains at the lower noise estimates, and usually less at the upper ones.
• A similar difference can also appear without this effect, when the electron jumps between two sites in the protein. This surprising result needs an independent check, and if it holds, experiments will need a control for it.
• Whether the difference can change the shape of the brain's map is still open. The first round of calculations is done. Next I will build a more realistic model of the protein and connect with three research labs. If a bird's brain shows the predicted signal, and it depends on light, breaks down under weak radio noise and vanishes in birds without cryptochrome 4, that would be strong evidence that a quantum process shapes what a living brain receives. If it persists in darkness or without cryptochrome 4, my model has the wrong source. If no north–south difference appears, the chiral effect is weak or cancels itself out, or the proteins in the eye are poorly aligned. The far end of the path is the flock, and there I have only a hypothesis. Starlings coordinate mainly by watching their neighbors, and their flocks seem to work near a critical point, where a weak shared nudge spreads fast through the group; a compass that feels the field could add such a nudge.

0:10
Julia Ryzhkova avatar
⟳ Stuart Hameroff retweeted
Julia Ryzhkova@jvryzhkova·Nov 12

Looking for quantum processes that can be proven to work in a living organism: an update My goal is to find quantum processes that are proven to work in a living organism, and to understand in what form they can exist inside a warm, noisy cell. One of the strongest candidates is the magnetic compass of migratory birds. In the leading explanation, light falling on cryptochrome 4, a protein in the bird's eye, leaves it with two unpaired electrons that act like tiny magnets, and the Earth's field changes how they turn relative to each other and so how the chemical reaction ends. The evidence fits: the compass needs light, weak radio noise disrupts it, and cryptochrome 4 responds to magnetic fields in the lab. The full chain from this protein to the bird's behavior is still unproven. Proof has to come from experiments, and my part is to say what a living bird should show if the process is real. This compass reads the axis of the field and treats both its ends alike, so my model predicts that the bird's brain gets a map where each direction is glued to its opposite. Proteins are "handed", like left and right gloves, and an electron passing through a handed molecule prefers one spin direction. In 2021 Luo and Hore predicted that this effect, called CISS, could let the compass tell north from south. It can take several forms, and I ask which survive in the real protein and whether a brain recording could see the difference they create. I test this in pre-registered computer simulations, publishing the plan and code before each run and every number and correction after it. Since I last wrote about this five days ago, I have run three more studies, the latest on the real atomic structure of the pigeon's cryptochrome 4, with much of the physics still simplified. What my model shows: • With the real geometry of the protein, one form of the effect gives a far stronger north–south difference than my previous study found, because the two electron magnets act on each other.
• A test on recordings from bird neurons would clearly see such a difference if the effect is strong and the proteins in the eye point the same way.
• At the strength measured so far, in an isolated frog protein, whether the test sees it depends on how the effect acts and how fast the reaction runs, both unknown in a living bird.
• The north–south signal created by the fragile quantum state of the two electrons partly survives the jostling of a warm protein: more than half of it remains at the lower noise estimates, and usually less at the upper ones.
• A similar difference can also appear without this effect, when the electron jumps between two sites in the protein. This surprising result needs an independent check, and if it holds, experiments will need a control for it.
• Whether the difference can change the shape of the brain's map is still open. The first round of calculations is done. Next I will build a more realistic model of the protein and connect with three research labs. If a bird's brain shows the predicted signal, and it depends on light, breaks down under weak radio noise and vanishes in birds without cryptochrome 4, that would be strong evidence that a quantum process shapes what a living brain receives. If it persists in darkness or without cryptochrome 4, my model has the wrong source. If no north–south difference appears, the chiral effect is weak or cancels itself out, or the proteins in the eye are poorly aligned. The far end of the path is the flock, and there I have only a hypothesis. Starlings coordinate mainly by watching their neighbors, and their flocks seem to work near a critical point, where a weak shared nudge spreads fast through the group; a compass that feels the field could add such a nudge.

0:10
Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 15

Good question. Tubulins in microtubules in brain dendrites and soma are quite stable within their microtubules so memory lattice mosaics are quite stable. Microtubules elsewhere do turn over due to 1) repurposing for mitosis (brain neurons don’t divide) 2) treadmilling - losing tubulins at one end, adding at the other, and ‘dynamic instability’, abrupt depolymerization and repolymerization. Dendritic-somatic microtubules are capped at each end and do neither Each brain tubulin can be in one of 22 isoforms, multiple post translational states etc So roughly 30 possible states. With about 100 million tubulins per neuron the number of mosaic memory states per neuron is about (10^8)^30 per neuron.

Professor Hameroff, if tubulin also turns over within days to weeks, what copies the CaMKII phosphorylation pattern onto new tubulin so that the memory outlives its molecules?

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 15

It would sure help if consciousness occurred in the same medium encoding memory. Thats the case with Orch OR in which both occur in microtubules. Synaptic proteins recycle over hours to days yet memories can last lifetimes. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2241…

This tweet is unavailable

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 15

Hey Dave I agree. Substrate-dependence/noncomputational (e.g. Penrose) would be valid objections to present or near future AI consciousness if true. The substrate dependence for consciousness appears to be organic carbon aromatic rings which have quantum optical effects dampened by anesthetics (not just carbon).There is ample evidence for the Orch OR theory based on quantum effects in microtubules. academic.oup.com/nc/article/… Noncomputability is difficult to measure but describes the essence of Penrose OR noncomputability AND your elusive F factor (creativity etc). It’s intrinsic to Orch OR. Is that why you’ve ignored Orch OR in public considerations, don’t mention it in your NYU school of ‘Mind, Brain and Consciousness’ and excluded it from meetings? Organic-based biomimetic quantum biological ‘AI’ systems may have far greater intelligence and could very well be conscious, since they are based on organic aromatic quantum oscillators and to some extent Orch OR. This may be the first sign of brain jelly computers iopscience.iop.org/article/1… And like the brain they require very little energy and water. No data centers needed.

"three reasons why AI isn't conscious." really? "consciousness is not intelligence": not a reason why AI isn't conscious, just rebuts a bad argument for AI consciousness (AI: intelligent therefore conscious). "consciousness is substrate-dependent"/"noncomputational": would be a reason if true, but truth needs to be established. more accurate title: "three reasons why AI might not be conscious". x.com/Nature/status/21121504…

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 14

The failure is due to ‘cartoon neuronism’, viewing the brain as a complex computer of simple neurons operating in slow EEG frequencies and regulated by membrane receptors and channels. Inside neurons (and glia) microtubules oscillate in kilohertz, megahertz, gigahertz and terahertz with quantum processing. The Penrose-Hameroff Orch OR quantum theory of consciousness has more evidence than all other theories of consciousness combined but is ignored and suppressed by AI -compatible theories with zero evidence or explanatory power. Microtubules are composed of tubulin, the brain’s most abundant protein. More than anything else the brain is made of microtubules acting as a quantum orchestra. Neuroscience needs a revolution pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3578… I’ll be presenting a poster at Society for Neuroscience Tuesday 27th in DC about detecting megahertz and gigahertz correlating with mental states from scalp in humans. abstractsonline.com/pp8/#!/2… And treat Alzheimer’s with ultrasound to repolymerize the microtubules.

Biological psychiatry, a total failure. Thomas Insel, the director of the US National Institute of Mental Health from 2002 to 2015, said in an interview in 2017: “I spent 13 years at NIMH really pushing on the neuroscience and genetics of mental disorders, and when I look back on that I realize that while I think I succeeded at getting lots of really cool papers published by cool scientists at fairly large costs - I think $20 billion - I don’t think we moved the needle in reducing suicide, reducing hospitalizations, improving recovery for the tens of millions of people who have mental illness. I hold myself accountable for that.” bit.ly/3Vs7fGH

Stuart Hameroff avatar
Stuart Hameroff@StuartHameroff·Nov 14

Fantastic! Certainly supports Earl’s (and others) traveling EEG wave theories of cognition and consciousness. But how? We still don’t really know what organizes EEG. There’s actually no evidence for the assumption they are organized by neuronal membrane depolarizations, including/especially axonal firings. As Earl has said it must be somehow analog. But how? The best explanation is these waves, spirals, rings etc show a two-dimensional slice of a 3-d hologram projected through cortex and elsewhere. Holograms encode distributed information, as interference patterns of lasers (coherent wave sources), where all the information is everywhere, and specific entities recalled by the original coherent wave. That’s how Lashley found memory to be encoded, representational drift etc is holographic. So the geometric shapes are coarse-grained views of a hologram being recalled and constructed by interference waves at higher frequencies of microtubules inside neurons and glia. We now know organize patterns occur in kilohertz, megahertz, gigahertz and terahertz in the brain, and can be detected (up to 5 gigahertz) at the scalp in humans and correlate with mental states and tasks. This is @anirbanbandyo and Pushpendra Singh’s DDG and I will present a poster ‘Introducibg the DDG’ Thursday 27th pm at Society for Neuroscience in Washington. My flight yesterday got canceled so I’m taking a redeye overnight flight to get there tonite. Earl, your traveling waves are phase couplings and decouplings interference of megahertz and gigahertz microtubule oscillations. We can test and model that.

The shape of brain waves carries information about what a person is remembering. psypost.org/neuroscientists-… #neuroscience